You know that moment in a spelling bee when the kid spells the word correctly but the microphone garbles it, and the judges mark it wrong? Now imagine you built 26 elaborate judging systems — panels, appeals courts, lie detectors — to catch cheaters, but the real problem was always the microphone. That is this paper's core finding. The model often already has the right answer; you're just losing it in the extraction step. The committed claim: for frozen small code models (≤1.5B parameters, no fine-tuning, run locally), none of 26 semantic post-hoc operators — selection, verification, repair, elimination, portfolios, sound vetoes, generation conditioning — improves held-out accuracy over the brute-force baseline of Best-of-N sampling. Zero. On every cell and benchmark tested. The negative is not a shrug; it comes with a mechanistic autopsy. Three failure modes explain why. The coverage wall: some tasks are simply beyond the model's capability, and no amount of deeper sampling rescues them. The capability scissors: when the generator is competent enough to pass visible tests, the errors that remain are indistinguishable from correct solutions — there's no discriminable signal for a selector to latch onto. The consensus trap: the scenario where a leakage-free selector could help (visible-pass-but-hidden-wrong majority co-occurring with a correct minority) almost never arises in practice. These aren't implementation complaints. They're structural limits of the post-hoc paradigm for models at this scale. The paper's baseline discipline deserves attention. Every comparison uses one deterministic execution oracle, a leakage-free protocol (no peeking at hidden tests during selection), and matched compute — meaning the post-hoc operators get exactly the same budget as BoN, not more. A distribution-free do-no-harm bound shows you need n≥45 to certify harm rate ≤α at zero observed harm. This is the kind of statistical hygiene most LLM-for-code papers skip entirely. Two operators do help, but on a different axis entirely — outside semantic reasoning. M1, an expression-layer recovery operator, uses robust extraction and public-test signature alignment to recover correct programs that the standard output extractor simply drops. It lifts DeepSeek-Coder-1.3B by +12 tasks on HumanEval+ (p=2.4×10⁻⁴), does no harm (b10=0), and is leakage-free. ACE, an adaptive consensus early-stop, saves ~19% of compute with zero accuracy cost. Both replicate across HumanEval+ and MBPP+ on three model cells. The lesson is uncomfortable: the bottleneck wasn't reasoning — it was plumbing. The field fight this paper enters is whether post-hoc reasoning (re-ranking, self-repair, verification) can compensate for weak generators, or whether you're better off spending that compute on more samples and fixing your extraction pipeline. The scaling-and-reasoning camp — AlphaCode, CodeT, self-debug papers — bets that smarter selection is the path. This paper says: at ≤1.5B frozen, there's no signal to select on. You're building an appellate court for a trial that never produces distinguishable verdicts. The obvious next experiment is scaling: does the negative hold at 7B, 13B, or 70B? Larger models might produce enough variance among test-passing candidates to give selectors actual signal. The author didn't run it — most likely compute-constrained (a single-author paper running 26 operators across multiple benchmarks and model cells is already a substantial compute bill). If the negative breaks at 7B, the coverage wall and capability scissors are scale-dependent, which is useful. If it holds, the post-hoc reasoning paradigm has a deeper problem than anyone wants to admit.