
DEFICIT · THIS FY
$31.5B
CLAIMED SAVINGS
$180B
DEFICIT GROWTH
3×
ATO REFORM SAVINGS/YR
$37M
Jim Chalmers is trying to thread a needle that may not have an eye. Speaking at the ASIC conference in Sydney, the treasurer promised the mid-year economic and fiscal outlook (Myefo) would deliver "substantial savings" to ease inflation — while simultaneously insisting growth wouldn't be put at risk. The phrase "cut enough, but not too much" is doing enormous rhetorical work, and the numbers underneath it tell a less tidy story.
Extraction Map
The fiscal picture is deteriorating on a clear trajectory. Despite Labor's claimed $180bn in cumulative savings since taking office in 2022, the budget papers project deficits of $10bn in 2024-25, $22.3bn in 2025-26, and $31.5bn in the current financial year. That's a tripling of the deficit over three years, driven by what Chalmers himself identified: rising debt interest, essential services costs, and "unavoidable spends and variations." The savings are real but are being overwhelmed by structural spending growth. Chalmers leaned on Australia's relative position — lower debt and smaller deficits than peer advanced economies — and pointed to financial market expectations that interest rates have peaked domestically even as they continue climbing elsewhere. That's a reasonable framing if the comparison holds. But economists have already flagged that federal and state government spending is itself contributing to the inflation problem, alongside fuel prices and the surge in datacentre investment. The government is both firefighter and arsonist. The tax agenda adds complexity. The May budget's 30% minimum tax on discretionary trust income is still before parliament. Capital gains tax changes face a business-backed counter-proposal from independent MP Allegra Spender, who wants to cut the CGT discount from 50% to 40% for active investments like shares and small business equity while preserving the inflation-linked model for property. These are substantive structural debates that the Myefo savings exercise sits alongside but doesn't resolve. The one clearly generative move is the announced ATO consultation on business tax modernisation. Pre-filling contractor income for sole traders is projected to save 400,000 hours and $37m annually. Simplifying fringe benefits tax rules for minor benefits below $300 removes a genuinely pointless compliance burden. These are small-dollar, high-signal reforms — the kind of friction reduction that rarely makes headlines but compounds over time. The deeper structural question is whether the government's fiscal strategy is coherent or contradictory. Rolling out "responsible cost-of-living relief" while fighting inflation requires the relief to be non-inflationary — a distinction that depends entirely on design and targeting. After five rate hikes and with unemployment rising, the economy is already cooling. The risk is that savings cuts arrive procyclically, compounding a slowdown that's already underway, while the structural deficit continues to widen regardless. Chalmers is managing a political narrative as much as an economic one. The "$180bn in savings" figure is a cumulative gross number designed to demonstrate fiscal discipline, but it coexists with accelerating net deficits. The mid-year update will be judged not on whether it "cuts enough" in headline terms, but on whether the composition of those cuts actually addresses the spending drivers that are pushing deficits higher — debt interest, services, and the demographic pressures underneath both.
Worth reading?
OPTIONAL
Score
40
/100
Mildly extractive — headline savings claims mask a tripling deficit trajectory, transferring future costs to taxpayers while current spending pressures remain structurally unaddressed.
What Is GRIN?
GRIN stands for Generativity, Resilience, Innovation efficiency, and Novelty openness. These four dimensions capture the essential characteristics of any memetic intelligence — whether a nation, a corporation, a religion, or a movement.
About GRINGenerativity
2/5
Resilience
2/5
Efficiency
2/5
Novelty
2/5
Extractive
3/5
Inverted
Does this create new capability or just redistribute existing value?
Minor generativity from ATO pre-fill and FBT simplification ($37m/yr saved, 400k hours freed). The broader fiscal posture redistributes existing resources without creating new capacity.
Verified Facts (10)
Jim Chalmers spoke at the Australian Securities and Investment Commission conference in Sydney
Chalmers said the mid-year update 'will cut enough, but not too much'
Five interest rate hikes referenced
Financial markets 'seem to think rates have now peaked'
$180bn in total savings claimed since Labor came to office in 2022
Budget papers project a deficit just shy of $10bn in 2024-25, $22.3bn in 2025-26, and an expected shortfall of $31.5bn this financial year
30% minimum tax on income from discretionary trusts announced in May budget
Allegra Spender proposed cutting the CGT discount from 50% to 40% for active investments
ATO to consult on pre-filling contractor income, saving an estimated 400,000 hours and $37m in costs each year
Simplifying minor benefits rules in the FBT system by scrapping assessments of small benefits below $300
More latest news
Read all