
The setup is familiar enough to feel safe: outsider arrives, household resists, secrets surface. What Steeds does with that chassis is less familiar. The novel is not about revelation — it moves at the pace of a portrait sitting, which is to say slowly, with long silences and the occasional explosive gesture from Tata that resets the atmosphere without resolving it. Edouard Tartuffe — 'Tata' — is the load-bearing invention here. A painter taught by Cézanne, once celebrated as the 'Master of Light' on the Parisian scene, now one-eyed, tyrannical, and refusing to explain himself to anyone, least of all a journalist. The feud with Cézanne is rumour, not confirmed fact, and Steeds is smart enough to leave it that way. The mystery is not what happened — it's whether you'll ever find out. The sensory layer is doing real work. Fruit and fish left to rot for still-life arrangements, turpentine, heat, cicadas, yellow fields — this isn't atmosphere-as-decoration, it's the novel's actual argument: that art requires proximity to decay, that the beautiful and the foul share a studio. Whether that thesis holds depends on how much you trust the accumulation of sensation over the accumulation of incident. Tanya Reynolds as reader is a genuine asset. She plays Tata's explosiveness without mugging it, and the slow-burning tension the review credits her with is real — she understands that brutishness is more frightening when it goes quiet than when it roars. Ettie, the 27-year-old niece who has lived with her uncle since childhood, is the novel's actual mystery, and Reynolds holds that ambiguity without resolving it for the listener. The audiobook format suits the material better than most. Provence in 1920 is a place you want described to you, not read in your head, and the 11-hour runtime gives Steeds room to let scenes breathe. The risk is that listeners who want plot momentum will bail somewhere in the middle third, when the portrait sessions repeat and the secrets remain hidden. That patience is the price of admission — and whether it's worth paying depends entirely on your tolerance for atmosphere as the primary event.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
52
/100
Readers who prioritised atmosphere over plot in du Maurier, who liked The Master or The Lacuna, and who don't mind a mystery that withholds more than it reveals. Best consumed as an audiobook specifically — Reynolds earns her fee.
Cultural Placement
Like Colm Tóibín's The Master but warmer and more sensory, with the power-asymmetry dynamics of Daphne du Maurier's Rebecca relocated from gothic English mansion to baking Provençal farmhouse. The mechanism — outsider locked in orbit around an opaque, domineering artist figure — echoes Henry James's portrait novels, but Steeds strips out the ironic distance and replaces it with smell and heat. The Cézanne backstory puts this in conversation with a small tradition of art-world historical fiction (Andrew Motion's The Lamplighter, Susan Vreeland's Luncheon of the Boating Party) that uses a real painter's shadow to throw a fictional one into relief.
Honest assessment
This is a well-made, sensory-rich piece of literary historical fiction that knows exactly what it is and delivers it without embarrassing itself. It won't change what you think fiction can do, but if you want to spend 11 hours in 1920 Provence with a one-eyed tyrant and his enigmatic niece, Steeds and Reynolds make that a genuinely good use of time. The audiobook format is not incidental — it's the optimal delivery mechanism for this particular novel.
What Is NOVEL?
52
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
2/5
Originality
2/5
Voice
3/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Low nerve. The template — journalist, reclusive genius, household secrets — is well-worn. Steeds doesn't subvert it; she executes it carefully. The sensory intensity is the only real bet, and it's a modest one.
Verified Facts (7)
Edouard Tartuffe is a revered painter who was taught by Cézanne and is known on the Parisian art scene as the 'Master of Light'
Tartuffe now lives with his 27-year-old niece, Ettie, and is blind in one eye
The novel is set over a summer in Provence in 1920
The reader is Tanya Reynolds
Available via John Murray, 11hr 3min
Sanctuary by Marina Warner, William Collins, 12hr 56min — subtitled Ways of Telling, Ways of Dwelling
Am I Having Fun Now? by Suzi Ruffell, Bluebird, 8hr 54min
More latest news
Read all