
The book group has a dirty secret that everyone knows and nobody says out loud: a significant portion of members show up having read nothing, armed with wine and opinions about the cover. Zoe Williams surfaced this in a June 8 piece, and the letters that followed are more instructive than they look. Stephen Arnott's Bishopston group solved the problem by dissolving it. They renamed themselves 'Bishopston Not a Book Group,' made books optional, and organized sessions around topics with books as one possible source among many. One session used interpretive dance — choreographed by a member — to explore quantum theory. Another involved fine cheese alongside a history of English cheesemaking. This is not a compromise; it's a genre upgrade. Margaret Squires' St Andrews group took a different tack: they kept books mandatory but made the selection constraint do the work. Current theme: 'any novel containing a male character you couldn't bear to marry.' Previous runs include 'any book translated from Dutch or set in the Netherlands,' 'a happy book,' and 'a book with botany in it.' The theme is loose enough that everyone can find something, tight enough that the conversation has actual shape. What both approaches share is a structural insight: the book group's real product is not literary analysis — it's a recurring social ritual with cognitive texture. The book is the excuse, not the point. Once you accept that, you can design the ritual honestly instead of pretending it's a seminar. The interpretive dance session is the tell. That's a group that has fully internalized the logic: the goal is shared engagement with an idea, and the medium is whatever works. Most book groups are too embarrassed to admit this, so they keep buying books nobody reads and feeling vaguely guilty about it. Arnott and Squires aren't embarrassed. That's the upgrade.
Worth reading?
OPTIONAL
Score
52
/100
People who run or attend book groups and have quietly wondered whether the whole thing is broken. Also: anyone designing recurring social rituals of any kind who wants a two-minute field report from the edge cases.
Cultural Placement
Like the Oulipo movement's constrained writing but applied to reading groups, with the anarchic energy of a Fluxus event. The Bishopston model echoes what Ivan Illich called 'convivial tools' — structures that serve the people using them rather than the institution they nominally belong to. The Squires theme-selection method sits closer to the BBC's Big Read or a well-run improv warm-up: the constraint is the generative engine. Neither group is doing anything new in the history of salons or reading circles, but both are doing it with more self-awareness than the standard book group manages.
Honest assessment
These are letters, not essays — 200 words each, written to be published the next morning, not to last. The Bishopston model is genuinely interesting as a case study in ritual redesign; the Squires theme-constraint method is practically useful immediately. Neither writer is trying to do more than that, and both succeed at exactly what they're attempting.
What Is NOVEL?
52
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
2/5
Originality
3/5
Voice
3/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
2/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Low risk — two letters to a newspaper. Neither writer stakes much. But Arnott's interpretive dance anecdote has genuine strangeness; it earns its place.
Verified Facts (7)
Zoe Williams column titled 'I have found the perfect book group – we discuss problematic text messages', published 8 June
Bishopston Not a Book Group: books welcomed but not obligatory, focus on a topic
One session used interpretive dance choreographed by a member to explore quantum theory
One session involved consumption of fine cheese alongside a book on the history of English cheesemaking
Margaret Squires' group current theme: 'any novel containing a male character you couldn't bear to marry'
Previous themes included 'any book translated from Dutch or set in the Netherlands', 'a happy book', 'a book with botany in it'
Stephen Arnott writes from Bishopston, Bristol; Margaret Squires from St Andrews, Fife
More latest news
Read all