
Get the book
The Sensualist
on Guardian Bookshop
Gary Shteyngart is not a natural essayist in the way he is a natural novelist. What he is, in this debut collection, is a natural performer — and the essays work best when that distinction doesn't matter. The vodka-soaked New York bar crawl, the capybara odyssey across three continents, the disastrous Atlantic-funded cruise: these pieces succeed because Shteyngart's comic timing transfers cleanly from fiction to nonfiction, and because his self-deprecation is structural rather than decorative. The jokes are doing the argument's work. The central thesis — that pleasure is a form of resistance against joyless productivity, tech-bro asceticism, and the general collapse of civic coherence — is stated early and reiterated often. Mark Zuckerberg's monk's hoodie gets its mention. The oligarchs get theirs. What Shteyngart proposes instead is specific: a martini trio, a master-tailored suit, a TikTok account populated exclusively by capybaras. This is not minimalism. The Atlantic flew him to Milan; the New Yorker sent him to South America. The sensualism on display here is very expensive, and the book is honest enough to half-acknowledge this, though not quite honest enough to fully reckon with it. The strongest piece isn't the most pleasurable one — it's the week spent in a Four Seasons hotel watching Russian state television. It begins as dilettantism (wagyu beef, pinot noir, the author lolling) and builds into something genuinely affecting: a portrait of propaganda's psychological mechanism, and of Shteyngart's own parents, radicalized into fearing vaccines and catching critical race theory from mayonnaise. The suit and the capybara essays are charming; this one has actual stakes. The weakest is the cruise. Shteyngart knows it too — he flags that the smart-outsider-infiltrates-floating-hellscape conceit has aged out, invokes David Foster Wallace, and then does the piece anyway because his editor told him to. The resulting essay is intermittently funny and structurally inert. Wallace's 1996 version worked because the form and the dread were perfectly matched; Shteyngart's version works in spite of itself, in the way that most things Shteyngart writes do, because his sentences are genuinely pleasurable to read. But the essay knows it's the weakest chapter and can't hide it. The capybara piece deserves more credit than it will probably receive. What begins as a goofy TikTok fixation becomes, in Shteyngart's hands, a surprisingly coherent argument about the animal for the current moment: a giant, amiable, perpetually anxious rodent that is hyper-social yet constantly imperiled. The Buenos Aires standoff between capybaras and luxury developers is the most overtly political image in a book that is mostly content to let politics hover in the background. It's also very funny. Shteyngart teaches writing at Columbia and observes that pleasure has gone missing from his students' work. The diagnosis is probably correct. The prescription — bespoke tailoring, four-figure watches, a $19,000 cruise — reflects the ambition of the editors who commissioned these pieces as much as it reflects any coherent philosophy. Travel + Leisure produces narrower travelogues; Men's Health produces sweet parenting pieces; the Atlantic produces the cruise. The magazine ecosystem shapes the argument, and the resulting collection is uneven in a way that published collections of magazine essays almost always are. The prose itself is the argument's best evidence. Shteyngart writes in great lolloping sentences that break against short ones for the punchline, and the rhythm is calibrated enough that even the weaker essays are enjoyable at the sentence level. The tone — confiding, slightly absurd, never mean — is exactly right for a book about pleasure. Whether the case for sensualism as serious political philosophy holds is a separate question. It mostly does. The cheaper options he mentions at the end — the implied acknowledgment that capybaras and martinis are more accessible than four tailored shirts — lands as the book's most honest moment.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
60
/100
Readers who liked Shteyngart's novels and want more of the voice without the plot machinery; Sedaris fans who want more geopolitical texture; anyone who has ever watched capybara TikTok at 2am and felt briefly better about everything.
Cultural Placement
Like David Sedaris but more geopolitically anxious, with the immigrant displacement of Nabokov's memoirs and the magazine-assignment gonzo of early David Foster Wallace. Shteyngart's essays operate where high-low comedy meets genuinely melancholy observation — he is funnier than most writers who make serious arguments, and more serious than most writers who are this funny. The closest structural predecessor is probably Sedaris's Me Talk Pretty One Day: confessional, self-deprecating, episodic, built on comic timing rather than essayistic argument. But Shteyngart's émigré perspective adds a register Sedaris doesn't have, and the best pieces here are doing something Sedaris rarely attempts: using humor to approach grief and political dread without flinching.
Honest assessment
This is a very good magazine collection that occasionally becomes something more. The voice is reliable, the comedy is real, and the immigrant perspective on American collapse gives it weight the form doesn't always demand. Its limits are structural — commissioned essays have commission shapes, and the weaker pieces wear their assignments visibly — but the best third of this book is as sharp as anything Shteyngart has written.
What Is NOVEL?
60
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
2/5
Originality
3/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Low risk. A novelist doing magazine essays is a safe extension of existing brand. The cruise piece acknowledges the DFW comparison and does it anyway — that's not nerve, that's assignment completion.
Permission slip
Consensus says: Early reviews are treating this as a lighthearted pleasure-manifesto and packaging it accordingly. We'd argue the Russian TV essay is the book's center of gravity, not a bonus track — and the collection is stronger and stranger than the 'delectable romp' framing suggests.
What they're missing: The 'romp' framing undersells the grief content (three close friends dead in five years, parents radicalized, émigré displacement) and the political sharpness of the best pieces. Readers coming for pure levity may be surprised; that surprise is the point.
Verified Facts (11)
In 2024, Shteyngart flew from New York to Milan in search of the perfect midnight-blue suit
He flew to Hong Kong to be fitted for four shirts, and on to Tokyo, where he was measured by master tailor Yuhei Yamamoto and master shoemaker Yohei Fukuda
Shteyngart describes himself as 'five foot five and a half, with that half doing a lot of work'
Shteyngart emigrated from Leningrad to the US in 1979
He tried on the suit two days after Trump's second election
Shteyngart was a consultant on the TV show Succession
The Atlantic paid $19,000 for a last-minute cruise suite
David Foster Wallace's cruise essay was written in 1996
Shteyngart mentions he has lost three close friends in the past five years
Shteyngart teaches writing at Columbia
The Sensualist is published by Atlantic at £14.99
More latest news
Read all