
Get the book
Belonging: A Journey of Love
on Guardian Bookshop
Sonia Gandhi's memoir is two books sharing a spine. The first is a genuine love story — a shy Italian woman from a small construction-family town falls for Rajiv Gandhi over a Greek restaurant meal in Cambridge in the mid-1960s, marries into the most consequential political dynasty in independent India's history, then watches that dynasty consume him. This book is worth your time. The second is a political history of the Congress party and the Nehru-Gandhi era, filtered through loyalty and legacy-building, where charged events acquire a benign gloss and strategic silences do the work that honest reckoning refuses to do. This book is frustrating. The personal material is where Gandhi's measured, frill-free voice earns its keep. The scene in which she waits disoriented in a crowded hospital in 1984 — having ferried her mother-in-law Indira's bullet-ridden body there after Sikh bodyguards shot her in revenge for the army's assault on the Golden Temple — is the book's emotional centre of gravity. When Rajiv embraces her with the words 'they want me to be sworn in as prime minister' and she responds 'they will kill you too', the exchange carries real weight. His reply — 'they will kill me anyway' — lands with the force of foretold tragedy. Gandhi has lived inside this grief for decades. When she writes it, you feel the weight of it. The political passages are another matter. The 21 months of Indira's 1975 Emergency — press censorship, opposition arrests, civil liberties suspended while Sanjay Gandhi ran amok as an unelected power within a power — are rendered with what the Guardian review accurately calls 'brisk calm'. Rajiv's own troubled prime ministership — the 1984 anti-Sikh pogrom in which Congress leaders were implicated, the Sri Lanka entanglement, the Hindu-nationalist openings that handed the BJP its wedge — is eulogised rather than examined. Gandhi was 40, grieving, and severely underqualified, as the reviewer notes, but Belonging doesn't confront that. The book knows what it is protecting. The question of Gandhi's father — Stefano Maino, a World War II veteran described in a 1998 New Yorker profile by Patrick French (briefly a Belonging collaborator) as 'an unrepentant fascist until his death' — is the most telling omission. Gandhi calls him 'padre padrone', traces his resistance to the marriage, notes that he eventually relented and bought her a ticket to India the moment she turned 21. But was he a fascist? The question is raised by the reviewer and left unanswered. This is a pattern. Wherever the history gets uncomfortable, Gandhi maintains what the reviewer rightly calls her 'strategic silence'. The book's most interesting structural argument — which Gandhi doesn't quite make explicitly — is about the peculiar nature of dynastic democracy. She herself had 'no right — except for the fact that I carried the family name'. She came to India for love, not politics. She spent years resisting the role the Congress party was pressing on her. And yet she eventually led the party for a staggering 22 years, handpicked a prime minister (Manmohan Singh) in 2004 while keeping the actual levers of power, and became, whatever the BJP's 'Rome Raj' rhetoric, one of the most consequential political figures of the democratic world. That story — the spectator who becomes the player through a combination of grief, duty, and the structural vacuum a dynasty creates when it runs out of heirs — deserves the interrogation this book declines to provide. The Penguin Random House India deal fell through at the last minute over what the publisher described as 'an impasse over a particular issue' in the text. HarperCollins stepped in. We don't know what the impasse was. What we can say is that Belonging reads like a book that survived editorial negotiation — careful, controlled, strategically incomplete. It is not the memoir India's political historians needed. It is, however, something more personal and in its own way more honest: the record of a woman who chose a country out of love, lost the person she chose it for, and found herself holding the inheritance.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
52
/100
Readers interested in Indian political history, South Asian dynastic politics, or the experience of women who inherit power through marriage and grief rather than through ambition. Not for readers seeking honest political accounting — this is a document, not an interrogation.
Cultural Placement
Like Jackie Kennedy's oral history interviews with Arthur Schlesinger — controlled, grief-soaked, legacy-conscious — but with the structural stakes of a Nehru-Gandhi dynasty that ran India for half its independent life. Closer in texture to Benazir Bhutto's Daughter of the East than to, say, Nelson Mandela's Long Walk to Freedom: the intimacy is high, the political self-accounting is carefully managed. The love story at the core recalls the romantic register of Tariq Ali's novel Shadows of the Pomegranate Tree without the fictional freedom to pursue complexity. What you get is the memoir a devoted widow and party loyalist writes — which is not the same thing as the memoir a historian would want.
Honest assessment
The love story is real and the grief is genuine — Gandhi's hospital scene and the final section on resilience earn their pages. The political history is too managed to trust and too incomplete to use. Read it as the memoir of a woman who outlived the people she loved, not as history of the country she came to run.
What Is NOVEL?
52
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
2/5
Originality
2/5
Voice
3/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Low nerve. Gandhi declines every uncomfortable question the material raises — her father's fascism, Rajiv's political failures, the Congress pogrom in 1984. The book protects the legacy it could have examined.
Permission slip
Consensus says: The Guardian review is warmer than we are on the political passages, treating discretion as understandable rather than as a structural failure of the book's ambition.
What they're missing: The strategic silences aren't just understandable personal choices — they shape what the book is as a historical document. A memoir from someone who held this much power for this long, that cannot name her father's politics or interrogate the 1984 pogrom honestly, is a managed artifact. The reviewer names this but softens it. We don't.
Lineage tree
Daughter of the East — Benazir Bhutto
structural parallel: foreign-educated woman inheriting South Asian dynasty through grief and duty
Long Walk to Freedom — Nelson Mandela
argues against: Mandela's willingness to indict his own side has no equivalent here
New Yorker profile (French, 1998)
direct predecessor: the most honest prior account of the Gandhi family, briefly a Belonging collaboration
Annie Besant's Congress presidency
historical lineage: first foreign-born female Congress president, cited in text
Verified Facts (11)
the deal with Penguin Random House India fell through at the last minute over what it termed 'an impasse over a particular issue' in the text, with HarperCollins stepping into the breach
the Nehru-Gandhi family has been in charge of India for about half the eight decades since independence
A 1998 New Yorker profile by Patrick French, briefly a collaborator on Belonging, had him down as 'an unrepentant fascist' until his death
The 21 tumultuous months of the 1975 Emergency – which saw members of the opposition arrested, civil liberties curtailed, the press censored, while a despotic nepo-baby (Sanjay, Indira's younger son) ran amok
Indira was slain by her Sikh bodyguards in revenge for ordering the army into the Golden Temple, Sikhism's holiest site
Gandhi eventually leading it [Congress] for a staggering 22 years
In 2004, she leads an alliance of parties to victory
Instead she handpicks a candidate, Manmohan Singh, while keeping charge of the party
Rajiv's eventful term… starts with a pogrom against Sikhs, spearheaded by Congress leaders
At a rally in Tamil Nadu in 1991, a Tamil Tiger operative makes to place a garland around Rajiv, then 46, with explosives strapped around her body
Belonging: A Journey of Love by Sonia Gandhi is published by William Collins (£25)
More latest news
Read all