
Hannah Lillith Assadi's Paradiso 17 is the kind of novel that arrives already marked by the weight it carries. Her father, Sami Abdul-Fattah Al-Assadi, fled the Nakba as a child in 1948 — one of more than 700,000 Palestinians expelled or displaced by Israel — before eventually settling in New York. Assadi wrote the book at his deathbed, and finished it inside what she described, in a tearful acceptance speech, as "unimaginable collective grief." The National Book Foundation judges called it "a visionary, finely wrought portrait of rupture and endurance," praising its "elegant lyricism" and "ambitious bending of time and space." Those aren't throwaway phrases — they're pointing at real formal choices, the kind of temporal dislocation that displaces the reader alongside its displaced characters. Assadi beat a genuinely strong shortlist: Edwidge Danticat, Valeria Luiselli, and Julián Delgado Lopera are not soft competition. That the win felt unforced rather than merely timely is worth noting. Awards for politically resonant work sometimes reward the subject over the craft; the judges here went out of their way to anchor their praise in the writing itself. Whether the novel lives up to that assessment — and it appears it does, based on its structural ambition — is what separates a National Book Award winner from a National Book Award statement. The ceremony at Cipriani Wall Street carried its own political weather. Egyptian memoirist Abdelrahman ElGendy won the nonfiction prize for Huna, about six years as a political prisoner in Egypt, then was denied a US visa and couldn't attend his own award ceremony. Syrian author Samar Yazbek, a finalist in translation, was also turned away. The State Department, via Marco Rubio's office, offered a boilerplate about "lawful travel" and visa privileges. The National Book Foundation called both denials "unjust." The New York Times had already raised questions about ElGendy's eligibility after he fled the US amid ICE deportation activity — questions the Foundation publicly dismissed. His acceptance speech, read by his editor, described a dream of turning imprisonment into memoir, practiced under a prison duvet. The speech described an "oppressive regime with a fascist ideology" preventing his attendance — language that landed in a room that had just celebrated literary freedom. Salman Rushdie received the medal for distinguished contribution to American letters, and used the platform gracefully: thanking the late Ursula K. Le Guin for being "just about the only one" who liked his first novel, and reflecting on arriving in the US literary scene after years under police protection in London following the fatwa over The Satanic Verses. "It has been quite a ride," he said. His presence at a ceremony where two writers from Muslim-majority countries were blocked from entering the country was not a symbolism the room missed. The full prize list — Brenda Hillman's eco-elegy Still House in the Desert for poetry, David Levithan and Gabriel Duckels' AIDS history The Fight of Our Lives for young people's literature — sketches a coherent picture of what the Foundation values this year: witness, grief, endurance, the long view. Michelle Zauner, author of Crying in H Mart, performed. Kyle MacLachlan hosted. The evening had the texture of a literary community taking stock of itself under pressure — and mostly holding together.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
72
/100
Honest assessment
Paradiso 17 appears to be the real thing — a novel where the formal ambition (bent time, lyrical displacement) is structural, not decorative, and where the biographical origin gives the grief weight without collapsing into memoir. The National Book Award field was genuinely competitive this year, which makes the win meaningful. Whether the novel sustains its ambition across its full length, or whether the lyricism occasionally tips into abstraction, is a question only reading it answers.
What Is NOVEL?
72
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksVerified Facts (20)
Palestinian-Jewish author Hannah Lillith Assadi has won the National book award for fiction for her novel Paradiso 17
Paradiso 17 is Assadi's third novel
The story was inspired by her father, Sami Abdul-Fattah Al-Assadi, who fled the Nakba as a child with his family, before studying in Italy and moving to New York
The 1948 Nakba saw more than 700,000 Palestinians flee or be expelled from their homes by Israel
Assadi won the $10,000 prize against Edwidge Danticat's Dèy, Julián Delgado Lopera's Pretend You're Dead and I Carry You, Valeria Luiselli's Beginning Middle End and Morgan Thomas' Mad Eden
Egyptian author Abdelrahman ElGendy won the $10,000 nonfiction prize for his debut Huna: A Memoir of Revolution, Prison, and Becoming
ElGendy was unable to attend the ceremony after being denied a visa to the US
ElGendy's prize was collected by his editor Helen Thomaides
Samar Yazbek of Syria, a finalist for the books in translation category, was also denied a visa
The National Book Foundation described both visa denials as 'unjust'
The New York Times speculated that ElGendy was not even eligible for the award as he did not meet its citizenship or residency requirements after fleeing the US due to Ice deportations
The National Book Foundation said it did not 'have any concerns regarding the eligibility of his title'
Publishers submitted 1,912 books to the National book awards this year
Brenda Hillman won the $10,000 poetry category for Still House in the Desert: An eco-contemplation
David Leviathan and Gabriel Duckels won the $10,000 young people's literature category for The Fight of Our Lives: AIDS in America
Salman Rushdie was presented with a medal for 'distinguished contribution to American letters'
Rushdie thanked the late Ursula K Le Guin for liking his first novel
Actor and author Kyle MacLachlan hosted the ceremony, held at Cipriani Wall Street
Singer Michelle Zauner, author of the bestselling memoir Crying in H Mart, performed onstage
Secretary of State Marco Rubio said 'a visa is a privilege, not a right'
More latest news
Read all