
Get the book
The Hill
on Guardian Bookshop
Harriet Clark's first novel opens a question most coming-of-age fiction refuses to ask: what if the protagonist simply declines the arc? Suzanna is being raised by her grandparents in a shabby urban apartment while her mother serves a life sentence — the getaway driver for a botched bank robbery financing revolutionary political activism. The prison visit is her calendar. The hill is her horizon. She is not trying to escape this. She is holding on. The structural gamble is real and Clark executes it with quiet discipline. The novel is shaped by the tension between its own need for forward movement and Suzanna's refusal to move. Prison visits structure the chapters — the rituals of search, permission, and constrained touch marking time without the usual developmental milestones. When the grandfather dies and the visits become more restricted, it registers as loss in reverse: not the loss of freedom but the loss of the last remaining channel toward confinement. The grandmother and her circle of aging Jewish radical thinkers carry much of the novel's energy, and they are its liveliest material. These are war-weary, darkly funny women comparing notes on bad mothers, estranged children, and husbands who didn't stay. Their elliptical monologues demand patience — a lot of rambling, half-anecdotes from decades gone by — but they coalesce, and when they land, they land hard. The grandmother's memory of her own mother weeping elegantly 'in Stalin's starving land' is the kind of line that earns the surrounding pages. Clark writes incarceration as accumulation rather than spectacle. The low-key humiliations pile up: smelly bedding, mucky floors, stale food, the strip-lit solitary that leaves a woman asking 'what time is this' on release. Avoiding the horror-show version means the horror registers more accurately — as a permanent weather system, not an event. Suzanna's arrested stasis mirrors this: the worst punishment is the physical manifestation of the timelessness she is simultaneously drawn to and destroyed by. The animals are the novel's wildcard and its most distinctive move. Semi-feral cats enact the child's repressed rage. Guide dogs are fiercely loved in prison. And finally, magnificently, a parrot that cannot fly paces the aisle of an aeroplane beside a shackled mother. These are not symbols doing obvious work — they carry the emotional load Clark refuses to place directly on her protagonist. Clark earns that final image. It is the crack where the light gets in. The novel takes a few chapters to teach you how to read it. That patience requirement is real — not everyone will grant it. The elliptical conversational style and the deliberate non-progression will read as shapeless to readers who don't clock that the shapelessness is the point. But those who stay will find something genuinely unusual: a novel about immobility that doesn't feel static, a protagonist who refuses agency whose refusal is itself a form of agency, a first book that knows exactly what it is doing and trusts you to catch up.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
76
/100
Literary fiction readers who liked Marilynne Robinson's patience, Ferrante's domestic precision, or Balle's temporal loops — and who can sit with a protagonist who declines to progress.
Cultural Placement
Like Elena Ferrante's early novels but quieter and more airless, with the structural patience of Marilynne Robinson and the dark generational comedy of Grace Paley's short stories. Where Ferrante's protagonists rage against their circumstances, Clark's Suzanna withdraws from hers — a refusal of the arc that calls to mind Solvej Balle's On the Calculation of Volume, in which time loops for the same people in the same place. The lineage is realist literary fiction about women trapped by circumstances beyond their choosing, but Clark's specific contribution is the protagonist who is complicit in her own trap and knows it.
Honest assessment
This is a debut that knows what it is and executes it with discipline — a small-world novel that earns its smallness, with a grandmother's circle that provides the dark comedy the protagonist refuses to supply. It will not work for everyone: the deliberate non-progression and elliptical dialogue require patience that some readers won't grant. For those who will, it's genuinely unusual work.
What Is NOVEL?
76
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
4/5
Originality
4/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
4/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Real structural risk. Building a novel around a protagonist who refuses the Bildungsroman arc could collapse into inertia. Clark holds it — the stillness generates tension rather than killing it.
Permission slip
Consensus says: The Guardian review is enthusiastic and recommends reading 'playfully, slowly, with an open mind.' We agree on the recommendation but want to be more explicit that the first-chapters patience requirement is a real barrier, not a minor caveat.
What they're missing: The review undersells how much work the reader has to do before the novel clicks. That's not a criticism of the book — it's an accurate description that helps the right readers commit and saves the wrong ones from frustration.
Lineage tree
Grace Paley — Collected Stories
tonal influence — dark Jewish-American generational comedy, elliptical working-class women's voices
Marilynne Robinson — Housekeeping
direct ancestor — small-world female stasis, domestic precision, refusal of conventional arc
Elena Ferrante — Troubling Love
extends the form of — intimate female domestic realism, constrained circumstances, absent/damaged mother
Solvej Balle — On the Calculation of Volume
explicit structural parallel — same-day repetition, same people, same space, time marking without progressing
Prison literature / incarceration realism
argues against — Clark refuses the horror-show mode in favor of cumulative, low-key humiliation
Verified Facts (8)
Suzanna is being raised by grandparents while her mother serves a life sentence for driving the getaway car for a botched bank robbery intended to fund revolutionary political activism.
The grandmother is described as 'a sometime communist with vivid memories of a trip to Russia as a young mother.'
A woman newly released from months of strip-lit solitary confinement keeps asking 'what time is this.'
The novel includes 'a parrot that can't fly pacing the aisle of an aeroplane beside a mother in shackles.'
The Hill by Harriet Clark is published by Sceptre (£16.99).
The reviewer explicitly compares the novel to Solvej Balle's On the Calculation of Volume.
The grandmother's friends are described as 'war-weary Jewish radical thinkers in old age.'
The grandmother's line about her own mother: 'There was nothing like this ridiculously elegant woman weeping into a handkerchief to make life in Stalin's starving land seem both manageable and promising.'
More latest news
Read all