
Get the book
Hollow Bones
on Guardian Bookshop
The form is familiar — the Guardian's 'Books That Made Me' template — but Picoult uses it more honestly than most. She doesn't reach for prestige picks. Where the Wild Things Are, Gone With the Wind, a mid-list Susan Isaacs novel she re-read obsessively in high school: these are the actual books of her actual life, not the books she wishes she'd read. The most interesting admission is structural, not sentimental. Picoult names Gone With the Wind twice — once as the book that made her want to be a writer, once as the book she could never read again. The gap between those two entries is the essay's real argument: that the same imaginative power that made Mitchell's prose smell like burning Atlanta also carried a portrait of Black people she should have interrogated at 13 and didn't. Ta-Nehisi Coates's Between the World and Me is what closed that distance, shifting her from 'not a racist' (passive) to actively antiracist — a distinction she makes crisply and without self-congratulation. The Coates entry is the best-written passage here, partly because it's the only one where she tracks causation: reading the book → attending social justice workshops → understanding the difference between two positions she'd conflated. That's how reading actually changes people, and she's one of the few writers in this format who shows the mechanism rather than just gesturing at the transformation. Elsewhere the piece is warmer and looser. The Dostoevsky entry — tried three times, still no — is quietly funny and refreshingly undefensive. The Book Thief section reveals that she's spent eight years adapting it as a musical, which reframes the 'book I discovered later in life' category entirely: this isn't passive admiration, it's a working relationship with a text. The Alice Hoffman comfort-read note ('makes writing look easy when it's never easy') is the kind of thing only a working novelist would say. The Almost Paradise / Princeton passage is the most personally revealing: she was the outsider among trust-fund kids, used a novel about class-crossing romance as a template for the life she wanted, and married the Princeton Wasp she'd imagined. She flags this herself — 'maybe this book was not just a comfort read, but a how-to primer' — with enough self-awareness that it lands as funny rather than strange. What the piece doesn't do is argue about books. Picoult notes influences and comforts but never puts two works in conversation with each other, never says what a book got wrong, never uses one reading to critique another (except the implicit Gone With the Wind / Coates pairing, which she leaves the reader to complete). That's partly the format's constraint and partly temperament. The result is generous and readable but stays in the register of testimony rather than criticism. Hollow Bones, her new novel, sits in the background of this whole piece without being mentioned — presumably it deals with similar territory to the books she's drawn to: outsiders, class, moral reckoning, the machinery of prejudice. Whether the book earns the influences she's describing here is a different question, but the reading life she sketches is coherent and genuinely her own.
Worth reading?
OPTIONAL
Score
48
/100
Picoult readers curious about her formation; readers who liked her novel Small Great Things and want to understand the reading that informed it; anyone who has thought about the Gone With the Wind problem and wants to see a novelist work through it in public.
Cultural Placement
Like the Paris Review's 'By Heart' series but less curated, with the confessional directness of Anne Lamott's Bird by Bird. Picoult works in the tradition of the 'books that made me' essay — Orwell's 'Bookshop Memories,' Nick Hornby's Polysyllabic Spree — but without their critical register. The closest analogue is probably Roxane Gay's Bad Feminist reading memoir sections: a writer owning the gap between the books that formed her and the reader she later became.
Honest assessment
This is a good version of a minor form — the literary autobiography as promotional interview. Picoult is more honest than the format requires, particularly in naming the book she can't re-read and explaining why. The Coates passage earns its place. But the piece doesn't generate new ideas about literature; it generates honest testimony about one writer's reading life, which is a smaller and less durable thing.
What Is NOVEL?
48
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
2/5
Originality
2/5
Voice
3/5
Endurance
2/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Low risk. The format is a Guardian template; every choice is within the convention. The Gone With the Wind double-entry is the one structural move, and it's modest.
Permission slip
Consensus says: The piece will likely receive warm reception as candid and relatable. We'd push back slightly: the candor is real, but the form does most of the work. The Gone With the Wind move is the essay's one genuine insight, and it's buried rather than developed.
What they're missing: What the warm reception misses is that Picoult stops exactly where it gets interesting — she tells us Coates changed her, but doesn't tell us what specifically in Between the World and Me she hadn't been able to see before. That gap is where the real essay lives.
Verified Facts (7)
Ta-Nehisi Coates, Between the World and Me, read in 2015 while Picoult was working on Small Great Things
Picoult has been adapting The Book Thief by Markus Zusak as a musical for eight years
Picoult read Gone With the Wind at age 13 and memorised large sections of it
Picoult read A Tree Grows in Brooklyn by Betty Smith at around age 12 or 13, given to her by her mother
Picoult attended Princeton and re-read Almost Paradise by Susan Isaacs every other year in high school
Picoult's current book is Everything Was Beautiful and Nothing Hurt by Ben Reeves
Hollow Bones by Jodi Picoult is published by Michael Joseph
More latest news
Read all