
NICK HARKAWAY VIKING
£22
WROBEL MICHAEL JOSEPH
£18.99
NICOLA UPSON FABER
£16.99
Nick Harkaway's second Smiley continuation, The Taper Man, is the most ambitious thing in this roundup and the one that demands the most patience. Set in 1965, it plants early-career versions of Tinker Tailor's key players into a plot that spans Helsinki, California, and Moscow, anchored by a sleeper-agent hunt that matters precisely because Harkaway has absorbed his father's methodology, not just his furniture. The cold war apparatus is rendered with the density le Carré always insisted on — meaning you have to do some work before the story accelerates. That density is a feature, not a bug, though readers who want their spy fiction lean will find the first third demanding. Mick Herron's Watch the Quiet Snow is the most reader-friendly package here — a lovingly produced collection of five previously published novellas set in the Slow Horses universe. Two entries deepen Jackson Lamb's relationship with MI5 archivist Molly Doran, adding texture to a character who already has more texture than most genre protagonists. The other three follow John Bachelor, the alcoholic 'milkman' who tends retired assets, stumbling into double and triple-agent complications with Diana Taverner waiting at the other end. If you've never read Herron, don't start here — this is fan service, generously executed. If you have, it's exactly what a dark December evening calls for. Stephanie Wrobel's Revenge Plot is the tightest construct in the group. A remote Catskills treehouse, a snowbound Christmas, a literary agent with a secret-identity client, and an uninvited guest who knows too much. The publishing-industry satire embedded in the thriller mechanics is sharp without overpowering the suspense — Wrobel has genuine fun with the gap between literary prestige and commercial anxiety. The pacing is disciplined in a way that distinguishes professional thriller craft from the many books that set up an interesting premise and then fumble the second half. Nicola Upson's The Voices of the Dead arrives as the latest in her Josephine Tey series, relocating the real-life mystery writer to Portmeirion in 1941, where the blitz's displaced National Gallery paintings and a 40-year-old skeleton intersect. Upson's sustained achievement in this series is atmospheric rather than mechanical — the wartime texture is genuinely evoked, and the procedural slowness (no body until a third of the way through) is compensated by prose that makes period immersion feel effortless. It's the Downton effect without the smugness. Leonora Nattrass's The Bells of Fortune is the least conspicuous entry and the most purely enjoyable for readers who want period wit rather than suspense architecture. Susan Bell — wry, sharp-eyed, stuck in Leicestershire with a parrot called Cuthbert and a canal dispute — is exactly the kind of narrator who can carry a slow-burn Gothic historical mystery. The 18th-century parliamentary and rural politics are well-researched without becoming homework. Nattrass trusts her narrator's voice to do the heavy lifting, and mostly it holds.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
60
/100
Readers who like their genre fiction literary-adjacent — patient with atmosphere and period texture, invested in character over puzzle mechanics, and already warm toward at least one of these franchise universes.
Cultural Placement
This is the gold-standard British crime and espionage winter crop: more Graham Greene than Agatha Christie in its wartime entries, more Len Deighton than James Bond in its spy fiction, with Herron and Harkaway occupying the precise literary-genre overlap that le Carré mapped and that relatively few successors have navigated without slipping into either pastiche or prestige cosplay. Wrobel sits closer to Tana French than to Patricia Highsmith — psychological pressure inside a closed space, with an industry context that doubles as satire. Upson and Nattrass are working the Josephine Tey / Barbara Pym register: manners, period texture, detection as a social act rather than a procedural one.
Honest assessment
Four of these five books are genuinely good at what they set out to do, with Watch the Quiet Snow and The Taper Man the strongest cases for immediate purchase. The slate risks nothing formally and doesn't pretend to — but within its ambitions, voice and craft are consistently above genre baseline. The right Christmas list for anyone who reads seriously inside the form.
What Is NOVEL?
60
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
2/5
Originality
2/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
4/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
No formal risk-taking here — these are genre-confident works executing within established templates. Harkaway's continuation gamble is the boldest move; the rest are professionally safe.
Lineage tree
John le Carré (Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy, Smiley's People)
direct ancestor — Harkaway continues character and world
Josephine Tey (The Daughter of Time)
subject and method — Upson uses Tey as both detective and lineage
Len Deighton (Spy fiction tradition)
tonal influence on Herron's institutional cynicism
Barbara Pym (manners fiction)
register influence on Nattrass's social observation
Verified Facts (14)
The Taper Man by Nick Harkaway (Viking, £22) is the second George Smiley continuation novel from John le Carré's son
Set in 1965 and features early iterations of several characters who appear in Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy and Smiley's People
Watch the Quiet Snow by Mick Herron (Baskerville, £22) is a collection of previously published novellas
Jackson Lamb described as 'a grubby Santa, putting the grot into grotto'
John Bachelor works as a 'milkman', looking after retired assets
Revenge Plot by Stephanie Wrobel (Michael Joseph, £18.99) — literary agent Claudia Conley rents a remote Catskills treehouse
Aspiring writer Arnie Tenderton deliberately crashes his car on Christmas morning
The Voices of the Dead by Nicola Upson (Faber, £16.99) is the latest instalment in Upson's Josephine Tey series
Set in May 1941, moving from the London blitz to Portmeirion in north Wales
Noël Coward is finishing his latest comedy, Blithe Spirit, in this novel
The National Gallery's precious paintings are being hidden in a nearby slate mine
The Bells of Fortune by Leonora Nattrass (Viper, £18.99) is the second 18th-century outing for Susan Bell, daughter of the former dean of Westminster
Set after a minor royal scandal in 1774, Reverend Bell is tutor to Francis, the wayward son of prime minister Lord North
Susan Bell's parrot is named Cuthbert
More latest news
Read all