
NYT LEGAL SPEND
$20M
COMPLIANCE WINDOW
9 MO
SPUR PUBLISHERS ADDED
20+
GOOGLE SEARCH SHARE
90%+
The UK Competition and Markets Authority has issued conduct requirements to Google under its new digital competition powers, ordering the search giant to decouple AI-powered search features from traditional organic listings. Publishers will now be able to block their content from appearing in AI Overviews and AI Mode — Google's Gemini-powered summarisation tools — without sacrificing their placement in conventional search results. Google has nine months to comply.
Extraction Map
The core problem is structural bundling. Until now, publishers wanting to appear in Google's traditional search — which remains the dominant driver of online readership — were automatically defaulted into AI Overview responses. This gave publishers no negotiating leverage: refuse AI use and you vanish from search entirely. The CMA's intervention breaks that forced coupling, creating for the first time a genuine opt-out that doesn't carry an existential penalty. Google has already begun testing new controls that let website owners manage how their content appears in AI features, starting with a subset of UK sites before global rollout. The company will also be required to provide clearer attribution and linking in AI-generated summaries, and to let publishers block their content from being used to train underlying models. This global deployment — triggered by a UK regulator — underscores the extraterritorial reach of the CMA's new strategic market status powers. The New York Times has spent $20m on lawsuits against OpenAI and Perplexity over copyrighted content. The Guardian, FT, and Washington Post have signed licensing deals with various AI firms. A coalition called SPUR — described as a 'Nato for news' — now includes the BBC, Guardian, Financial Times, Telegraph, Sky, and 20 additional publishers, attempting to establish common standards for AI content licensing. The gap between leverage and revenue remains wide. Tim Cowen, competition lawyer and co-founder of the Movement for an Open Web, notes the CMA's move establishes that Google cannot simply take content — but provides no monetisation mechanism and little enforcement detail. Google's required 'periodic reporting' to the CMA lacks specifics on frequency or content. The concern, voiced by multiple observers, is that Google will slow-roll compliance while publishers struggle to determine what their content is actually worth in AI contexts. Publishers have already seen dramatic falls in Google traffic since AI summaries began absorbing their content into synthesised answers that reduce click-through. A mass opt-out from AI Overviews remains unlikely — the collective action problem is obvious. Each publisher that opts out loses AI visibility while competitors who stay in continue to be surfaced. SPUR's formation is an attempt to solve this coordination problem, but coalition bargaining against a monopoly platform is slow and uncertain. The CMA has signalled it will wait to see how this first wave of interventions plays out before deciding on further action. This is a regulatory framework, not a market mechanism. The conduct requirements create a right to refuse, not a right to be paid. Whether that right translates into actual licensing revenue depends entirely on whether publishers can coordinate effectively enough to make Google's AI products noticeably worse without their content — and whether Google decides the reputational cost of degraded results exceeds the cost of paying up.
Worth reading?
OPTIONAL
Score
40
/100
Weakly generative — the CMA creates opt-out rights that didn't exist, but the absence of any monetisation mechanism means value extraction continues by default, just with a new permission layer that most publishers can't afford to exercise.
What Is GRIN?
GRIN stands for Generativity, Resilience, Innovation efficiency, and Novelty openness. These four dimensions capture the essential characteristics of any memetic intelligence — whether a nation, a corporation, a religion, or a movement.
About GRINGenerativity
2/5
Resilience
2/5
Efficiency
2/5
Novelty
3/5
Extractive
4/5
Inverted
Does this create new capability or just redistribute existing value?
Creates a new right (opt-out without penalty) but no new revenue channel. Leverage without a market mechanism is a half-built bridge — it enables negotiation but doesn't guarantee generative outcomes.
Verified Facts (7)
AG Sulzberger revealed the New York Times had spent $20m on lawsuits against OpenAI and AI startup Perplexity
Google will have nine months to implement the changes
SPUR coalition includes the BBC, Guardian, Financial Times, Telegraph and Sky; added another 20 major publishers this week
The Guardian has signed deals with OpenAI, Google, Amazon and Microsoft
FT and Washington Post have reached agreements with OpenAI
Tim Cowen is a co-founder of the Movement for an Open Web (MOW) and competition lawyer at Preiskel
CMA complaint about Google's AI Overviews filed last July by MOW, Independent Publishers Alliance, and Foxglove
More latest news
Read all