
Get it
Take9
on Official site
PAUSE WINDOW
9 sec
NEWMARK · CRAIGSLIST
30 yrs
AARP MEMBER
24 yrs
POST-RETIREMENT
8 yrs
Craig Newmark, who founded Craigslist and retired eight years ago, is now channeling personal capital and accumulated influence into Take9, a public awareness campaign built around a single behavioral nudge: pause nine seconds before responding to any unsolicited communication. The premise is that most social-engineering scams exploit urgency — force a snap decision and extract money or credentials before the target can think. A nine-second delay disrupts that pressure cycle.
Extraction Map
The campaign partners with AARP to reach older Americans, who remain disproportionately targeted by fraud. Newmark's wife monitors her parents' credit card transactions as a manual layer of defense — a low-tech intervention that works but adds unpaid labor to caregiving. Take9's public-facing advice stays deliberately simple: use a password manager, enable single sign-on through Google or Apple, adopt passkeys where available, block ads aggressively. Newmark himself pays a managed security provider to monitor his DNS records. Behind the consumer tips sits a more interesting play. Newmark describes quiet conversations with technology vendors about deploying on-device small language models that flag scam patterns in real time. Scammers use predictable linguistic markers — euphemisms, urgency phrases — and simple keyword matching already catches some of it. But scammers adapt quickly, rotating phrasing once detection patterns become known. LLMs, Newmark argues, can identify broader pattern clusters that survive this cat-and-mouse cycle. The specifics remain proprietary. Newmark explicitly says the vendors he works with won't discuss implementation details because "bad guys are listening." This is reasonable operational security, but it also means there's no public accountability for whether these tools actually reduce fraud or introduce new problems like false positives that lock legitimate users out. Newmark frames the effort as a civic middle layer: government is in flux and not hospitable to tech policy work, corporations need nudging, and he has enough social capital and cash to serve as an informal broker through institutions like the Aspen Institute. He's also hired Bully Pulpit International, a comms firm, to study which public campaigns actually change behavior — citing Smokey the Bear's decades-long arc as the benchmark. The structural limitation is clear. Take9 is a behavioral intervention layered on top of a system that generates scams at industrial scale. Deepfake voice cloning, AI-generated phishing, and compromised business databases create attack surfaces that no amount of individual caution can fully cover. Newmark acknowledges this implicitly by investing in platform-side detection, but the public campaign focuses almost entirely on individual responsibility. The honest question is whether a "count to nine" meme can achieve Smokey-the-Bear penetration in a threat environment that evolves monthly, not over decades. Newmark's behind-the-scenes vendor work may matter more than the public campaign, but we can't evaluate what we can't see.
Worth reading?
OPTIONAL
Score
44
/100
Mildly generative — the behavioral nudge and industry coordination create some new protective capacity, but the core model puts the burden on individuals rather than restructuring the platforms that enable fraud at scale.
What Is GRIN?
GRIN stands for Generativity, Resilience, Innovation efficiency, and Novelty openness. These four dimensions capture the essential characteristics of any memetic intelligence — whether a nation, a corporation, a religion, or a movement.
About GRINGenerativity
2/5
Resilience
2/5
Efficiency
2/5
Novelty
2/5
Extractive
2/5
Inverted
Does this create new capability or just redistribute existing value?
Modest new capability. A 9-second pause is a real behavioral tool, but it doesn't create infrastructure or systemic defenses. The vendor AI work could be generative if it ships — but it's invisible and unverifiable today.
Verified Facts (9)
Craig Newmark is the founder of Craigslist
Newmark retired from Craigslist 8 years ago
Take9 campaign advises pausing 9 seconds before responding to unknown communications
Take9 partners with AARP
Newmark has been an AARP member for nearly 24 years
Newmark hired Bully Pulpit International for public campaign research
Newmark works with the Aspen Institute on government engagement
Newmark's wife monitors her parents' credit card transactions
Newmark uses a password manager, single sign-on, passkeys, DNS monitoring, ad blocking, and a managed security provider
More latest news
Read all