
Nothing Compares 2 U is the problem and the point. It is so total a performance — whisper to fury to despair, all in four minutes, delivered straight to camera with two tears and no flinching — that it functions less like a song and more like a weather event. Everything else in O'Connor's catalogue lives in its shadow for people who weren't paying attention, and in its company for people who were. The Guardian's ranked list does the right thing by making that tension explicit. The editors admit upfront that placing a cover at number one is uncomfortable when O'Connor wrote so relentlessly and so well, then place it there anyway, because the argument holds: 35 years of familiarity haven't dulled it. Prince wrote the song. She made it hers. That's a defensible call, not a lazy one. What the list reveals, song by song, is a catalogue defined by formal restlessness. O'Connor didn't have a sound so much as a method: take the most emotionally loaded material she could find — her abusive childhood (Fire on Babylon), her divorce (The Last Day of Our Acquaintance), Cobain's death (All Apologies), institutional racism in Thatcher's Britain (Black Boys on Mopeds) — and find the arrangement that maximizes exposure rather than shelter. The reggae backing on Fire on Babylon sweetens the pill; the acoustic strum on The Last Day of Our Acquaintance strips everything away until there's nowhere to hide. Both moves are right for their material. The genre-hopping that sometimes drew critical dismissal reads differently at distance. Am I Not Your Girl? (1992) covered Broadway and jazz standards before that became reliable pop-star territory. I Am Stretched on Your Grave welded a 17th-century Irish poem to a baggy-era breakbeat — a genuinely improbable idea that somehow worked by amping up the grief rather than aestheticizing it. The Faith and Courage opener The Healing Room stacks radio static, Indian-inspired beats, dub bassline, and whispered vocals into something the list calls trip-hop but acknowledges O'Connor's intensity makes unlistenable for relaxation. These aren't genre exercises. They're a singer who took the material seriously enough to find the right container each time. The list handles her public life with appropriate restraint — a note that Black Boys on Mopeds arrived two years before the SNL appearance, a mention of the death of her son that ended her final album project — without letting biography swamp the music. That's the right call. The SNL moment and the tabloid years matter as context, not as verdict. The verdict is in the songs, and the songs hold. What's missing from a ranked list format is any real reckoning with the mid-career albums — Sean-Nós Nua, Throw Down Your Arms, Theology get a single parenthetical acknowledgment as having 'fine moments' before the list pivots to 2012's How About I Be Me. That's a gap. The reggae and gospel detours of the 2000s deserve more engagement than 'fine moments.' But ranked lists make their trade-offs visible, and this one at least names the trade-off rather than pretending it isn't there. The honest summary is this: O'Connor's catalogue is what a great singer's catalogue looks like when she refuses to repeat herself and doesn't care if the market follows. The list earns its number one, earns its number two (The Last Day of Our Acquaintance is devastating), and earns its case that you're missing something if you only know the hit.
Worth reading?
REVISIT
Score
88
/100
Anyone who knows Nothing Compares 2 U and nothing else — the catalogue below it rewards serious attention.
Cultural Placement
Like a Pitchfork career retrospective but with the structural honesty of a Robert Christgau Consumer Guide entry — this list operates closer to Nick Hornby's High Fidelity mode of ranking-as-argument than to obituary tribute. O'Connor's catalogue sits in the tradition of Kate Bush and PJ Harvey in that it demands formal variety as a condition of emotional seriousness, but her vocal instrument is rawer than Bush's and her politics more direct than Harvey's. The closest analogue for her method might be Van Morrison's early Island Records run: deeply Irish, formally restless, and allergic to the comfortable read.
Honest assessment
O'Connor's body of work is what happens when a genuinely great vocal instrument is paired with an artist who treats personal and political extremity as the only material worth working with. The catalogue is uneven by design — formal restlessness produces failures alongside breakthroughs — but the breakthroughs are real and the voice is irreplaceable. This list makes the case clearly enough that it functions as a decent entry point.
What Is NOVEL?
88
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
5/5
Originality
4/5
Voice
5/5
Endurance
4/5
Lineage
4/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Bet-the-farm nerve across an entire career. The SNL Pope incident, the genre pivots, the public breakdowns — she staked everything repeatedly and kept recording anyway.
Permission slip
Consensus says: Critical consensus treats Nothing Compares 2 U as the singular achievement and the rest of the catalogue as footnotes. This list argues the footnotes are the point.
What they're missing: The consensus is shaped by the size of the hit and the noise of the biography. The list is correct that The Last Day of Our Acquaintance, Fire on Babylon, and Mandinka are not footnotes — they're what the hit was drawing on.
Lineage tree
Van Morrison (Astral Weeks)
tonal influence — Irish emotional directness in pop form
The Clash
structural influence — Mandinka's guitar swagger is explicitly Clash-adjacent
Irish folk tradition (I Am Stretched on Your Grave)
direct ancestor — 17th-century poem reworked with contemporary production
Prince
argues against and absorbs — Nothing Compares 2 U taken from him and remade
Emmylou Harris / Linda Ronstadt tradition
extends the form of — This Is to Mother You later covered by both
Verified Facts (17)
Nothing Compares 2 U is a cover; the author was Prince
The Healing Room opens Faith and Courage (2000)
The Voice of My Doctor is from I'm Not Bossy, I'm the Boss (2014), O'Connor's final album
O'Connor abandoned an almost-complete follow-up with producer David Holmes after the death of her son
Am I Not Your Girl? (1992) is a collection of covers of American Broadway, jazz and film standards
All Apologies is a Nirvana cover, stripped to acoustic guitar following Kurt Cobain's death; O'Connor was a friend of Cobain
Black Boys on Mopeds (1990) references Thatcher-era Britain; O'Connor's SNL appearance followed two years later
I Am Stretched on Your Grave has roots in a 17th-century poem
Thank You for Hearing Me was apparently inspired by O'Connor's relationship with Peter Gabriel
Emma's Song was co-produced by Brian Eno
You Made Me the Thief of Your Heart was co-written by Bono and produced by Tim Simenon of Bomb the Bass, for the In the Name of the Father soundtrack
This Is to Mother You was subsequently covered by Emmylou Harris and Linda Ronstadt, and reworked in 2009 as a charity duet with Mary J Blige
My Special Child stalled just outside the UK Top 40
John Reynolds co-produced Fire on Babylon
O'Connor's Troy debut single arrived in autumn 1987
4th and Vine and The Wolf Is Getting Married are from How About I Be Me (and You Be You)? (2012)
Nothing Compares 2 U: 'It's my song now,' O'Connor once remarked
More latest news
Read all