
Get the book
Under the Changing Skies: The Best of the Guardian's Country Diary, 2018-2024
on Guardian Bookshop
The piece opens with a scene that earns its drama honestly: an ash tree groaning in the wind, a trail camera set to catch its fall, and the tree stubbornly refusing to oblige. Two storms pass through Norfolk. Other trees go down. The ash stays. The question — why this tree and not that one — is the engine of the whole essay, and it's a good one. What follows is a miniature education in fungal ecology delivered without a single moment of textbook stiffness. The fallen ash is hollow, colonised by golden scalycap and honey fungus. The rhizomorphs — those bootlace tendrils spreading underground from root to root — get a Stranger Things comparison that lands because it's specific rather than decorative. You see the mechanism: fungus reaches root, grows beneath bark, rots from within. The tree that looked strong was already dead inside. The best passage is on spalting — the ink-dark patterning created when two fungi compete for the same piece of wood, each sealing off territory with melanised hyphae. It's battlefield cartography at the cellular level. The timber industry hates it (weak wood), craftspeople prize it (unique art). That single material fact — same pattern, opposite valuations depending on whether you need strength or beauty — does more work than most nature essays manage in a thousand words. There's a lovely domestic thread running underneath. Dad is banned from chainsaw use (blood thinners and power tools don't mix) but cuts up a spalted ash trunk anyway. The spalting runs through like writing through a stick of rock. It's a small, warm detail that keeps the piece from becoming a lecture. The structure is deceptively tight for a diary entry. It begins with a tree that won't fall, moves through the hidden reasons trees do fall, passes through the art that emerges from decay, and returns to the swaying ash — still standing, for now. The circularity feels earned rather than forced. This is nature writing in the tradition of the Guardian's Country Diary column: compressed, observant, rooted in a specific place on a specific day, carrying more ecological knowledge than it advertises. It doesn't reach for grand themes about mortality or resilience. It trusts the reader to find them in the spalting.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
56
/100
Readers who like their nature writing compressed and specific — the kind of person who picks up Merlin Sheldrake or browses the Country Diary column over morning coffee. Also anyone who works with wood and has wondered about those dark lines.
Cultural Placement
Like Robert Macfarlane's landscape prose compressed to diary-entry scale, with the fungal specificity of Merlin Sheldrake's Entangled Life and the domestic warmth of a Roger Deakin notebook. The mechanism is observation-as-education: each sensory detail carries an ecological fact without announcing itself as pedagogy. Closer in feel to the quiet accumulation of Alice Oswald's nature poetry than to the grand sweep of contemporary 'new nature writing.'
Honest assessment
A well-crafted nature diary entry that punches above its word count. The spalting material is genuinely illuminating and the domestic details are warm without being twee. It's not trying to be more than it is — a short, observant column — and within that form it's very good.
What Is NOVEL?
56
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
2/5
Originality
2/5
Voice
3/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
4/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Low structural risk — the Country Diary format is well-established and safe. The risk is in trusting mycology to carry the emotional weight without reaching for sentimentality. It works, but the form protects the writer.
Lineage tree
Gilbert White's Natural History of Selborne
direct ancestor — the parish-observation tradition
Roger Deakin's Wildwood
tonal influence — domestic warmth meets tree knowledge
Merlin Sheldrake's Entangled Life
extends the form of — fungal ecology as narrative material
Robert Macfarlane's The Wild Places
tonal influence — landscape prose compressed to diary scale
Verified Facts (9)
An ash tree swayed, audibly groaning, a split in the trunk opening and closing like a mouth
Suffering from ash dieback
Two storms have churned through Norfolk
Golden scalycap and honey fungus found within the hollow cavity
Black rhizomorphs of the honey fungus, also known as bootlace fungus
Two different fungi colonise the same piece of wood, they compete for territory, sealing off with darkly pigmented fungal threads, known as melanised hyphae
This ink-dark patterning is called spalting
Dad is supposed to be banned from chainsaw use – blood thinners and power tools don't mix
Under the Changing Skies: The Best of the Guardian's Country Diary, 2018-2024
More latest news
Read all