
TONS CDR REMOVED
2M
TONS NEEDED · CENTURY
320Bn
CCS LOBBYISTS · COP31
700
TONS/YR · REFORESTATION
~2Bn
Carbon dioxide removal has spent decades living inside climate models as a convenient assumption — the deus ex machina that makes temperature pathways add up on paper. At Cop31 in Antalya, Turkey, its advocates are trying to drag that assumption into reality. For the first time, both CDR (pulling CO2 from the atmosphere) and CCS (capturing it at source) appeared in a draft negotiating text that will shape the summit's final deal.
Extraction Map
The numbers, however, are savage. Technological CDR has removed roughly 2 million tons of CO2 to date. The UN estimates 320 billion tons must be removed this century to return below 1.5C. That is a factor of 160,000. Nearly all current removal — about 2 billion tons annually — comes from reforestation, not the engineered direct-air-capture systems that dominate the hype. Leading DAC companies are, per the article, "badly underperforming and struggling financially," starved of capital that is instead flowing to AI. The political economy is revealing. A record 700 CCS lobbyists are credentialed at this Cop — more delegates than the smallest 50 national delegations combined, according to the Center for International Environmental Law. CCS, which captures emissions at the smokestack rather than from ambient air, is explicitly backed by oil and gas majors as a way to extend fossil fuel operations. CDR advocates at the "Think Negative" pavilion want a new global agency to coordinate removals and insist this is the "only tool" to reverse overshoot. Environmentalists counter that both CDR and CCS serve a "diversionary role from mitigation" — giving governments permission to delay the hard work of cutting emissions. The structural tension is clear. CDR is real physics: you can pull CO2 from air, mineralize it, store it. But as a policy instrument, it functions as an IOU written against technologies that do not yet exist at meaningful scale. Every climate plan that pencils in future removal reduces present-day pressure to cut fossil fuels. CIEL's Rachel Kennerley calls the overshoot-and-return pathway "hypothetical" and, bluntly, "impossible" at the scale required. The Cop31 presidency — jointly held by Turkey and Australia — is under pressure from CDR proponents like CDR Türkiye to include removal language in the final decision. Injy Johnstone of the Max Planck Institute argues CDR must reach a footprint "that rivals the global energy industry." That framing reveals the ambition's scale: building an entirely new global industry from near-zero, in decades, while the existing energy industry resists displacement. What makes this story structurally important is the normalization of overshoot. Once 1.5C exceedance is accepted as inevitable — and it increasingly is — CDR shifts from nice-to-have to load-bearing pillar of the entire climate architecture. If that pillar remains hollow, the temperature doesn't come back down. If it fills, it will require land-use changes and ocean interventions with their own ecological costs. Either way, the political convenience of assuming future removal is doing real work in present-day negotiations. The honest read: CDR will almost certainly be part of any realistic climate response. The question is whether its inclusion in negotiating texts accelerates genuine deployment or merely provides diplomatic cover for continued fossil fuel extraction. At Cop31, the answer appears to be both — simultaneously.
Worth reading?
SKIP
Score
24
/100
Extractive — CDR inclusion in negotiating text currently functions more as a political pressure valve for fossil fuel incumbents than as a generative deployment framework, given the 160,000× gap between current removal and stated need.
What Is GRIN?
GRIN stands for Generativity, Resilience, Innovation efficiency, and Novelty openness. These four dimensions capture the essential characteristics of any memetic intelligence — whether a nation, a corporation, a religion, or a movement.
About GRINGenerativity
1/5
Resilience
1/5
Efficiency
1/5
Novelty
2/5
Extractive
4/5
Inverted
Does this create new capability or just redistribute existing value?
Near-zero generative output today. 2M tons removed vs 320Bn needed — a 160,000× gap. The policy text creates diplomatic vocabulary, not industrial capacity. Capital is flowing to AI, not DAC.
Verified Facts (8)
A record 700 lobbyists at this Cop are advocating for carbon capture and storage, according to the Center for International Environmental Law
This is more delegates than from the smallest 50 national delegations combined
Around 2bn tons of carbon removed a year, almost all of it via reforestation
Technological efforts to vacuum CO2 from the air has removed just 2 million tons
The UN recently estimated that an enormous 320bn tons of CO2 will have to be removed this century in order to get back under 1.5C
For the first time, both CCS and CDR were included in a text that will inform the basis of a final deal at the climate talks
CDR Türkiye's Göker Avci: 'We spoke with the presidency about making it into the final decision and they have started to realize the potential'
Rachel Kennerley, CIEL: 'That return element is at the moment hypothetical. I mean, I think it's impossible'
More latest news
Read all