
Get the book
Under the Changing Skies: The Best of the Guardian's Country Diary, 2018-2024
on Guardian Bookshop
The form is the Guardian's Country Diary — one of the longest-running nature columns in English-language journalism, dating to 1906. This entry from northern Iceland does what the best diary entries do: it earns its awe through accumulated sensory detail rather than announcing it upfront. Half an hour of empty water, then a spout. Then fifteen whales. The patience of the setup mirrors the patience of the observation itself. The Céline Dion moment is the structural gamble here, and it works precisely because the writer doesn't oversell it. The captain plays My Heart Will Go On over the boat speakers; two whales surface alongside as if on cue. The writer lets the coincidence land without claiming causation, which is the right instinct. It's funny, it's slightly absurd, and it doesn't undermine the serious observation that follows. The 'perhaps' in the headline does real work. The best passage is the technical middle section — fluke pigmentation as fingerprint, the oval 'flukeprints' of calm water left by deep-diving whales, the stubby dorsal fins breaking the surface at unpredictable intervals. This is nature writing that teaches you how to look. The writer isn't performing sensitivity; they're reporting what they saw with the vocabulary of someone who has done this before and knows what matters. The ecological signal buried in the sixth paragraph is the most important sentence in the piece: increasing numbers of humpbacks are remaining in Icelandic waters year-round rather than migrating to Caribbean breeding grounds. The explanation offered — population growth producing more non-migratory juveniles — is plausible but hedged appropriately. Climate-driven prey redistribution is the unspoken alternative hypothesis, and the writer's restraint in not reaching for it is respectable. The closing image — a fluke slipping beneath the surface against reflected sunlight — is earned rather than manufactured. It works because the preceding 500 words built a visual grammar that makes the reader see it. This is a short column doing exactly what a short column should do: one clear experience, carefully rendered, with enough ecological context to anchor it beyond the personal. As a standalone piece it's modest in ambition — this is a diary entry, not an essay. But within its form it's quietly excellent. The book collection it promotes, Under the Changing Skies, compiles the best of these columns from 2018-2024, and if the selection maintains this standard, it's a worthwhile object.
Worth reading?
OPTIONAL
Score
48
/100
Readers who enjoy short, precise nature writing and want a 3-minute break that teaches them something about whale behaviour and Icelandic marine ecology.
Cultural Placement
Like Robert Macfarlane's landscape writing compressed to 600 words, with the diaristic modesty of Gilbert White's Natural History of Selborne and the ecological alertness of Isabella Tree's Wilding. The form is the Guardian Country Diary — micro-essays where the constraint is the point. Think of it as nature haiku in prose: the best entries achieve density through restraint, not expansion. This particular entry sits closer to the Amy Liptrot end of the tradition — personal encounter first, ecological implication second — than to the Mark Cocker data-rich school.
Honest assessment
A well-crafted Country Diary entry that earns its moments of wonder through observational patience rather than rhetorical inflation. It won't change your life, but it will make you better at noticing whales — and that's exactly what the form promises. The book collection it promotes is the real product here.
What Is NOVEL?
48
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
2/5
Originality
2/5
Voice
3/5
Endurance
2/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Low structural risk — it's a diary column, not a manifesto. The Céline Dion beat is the one moment where the piece could have collapsed into kitsch, and the writer handles it deftly.
Verified Facts (7)
Eyjafjörður is Iceland's longest fjord
About 15 individual humpback whales were observed
Fluke pigmentation patterns are unique as fingerprints and used by researchers to identify and track individual whales
Humpbacks typically migrate between Iceland's subpolar feeding grounds and warm breeding waters in the Caribbean and Gulf of Mexico
Increasing numbers of humpbacks are remaining in Icelandic waters year-round
Humpbacks reach sexual maturity between four and 10 years of age
Under the Changing Skies: The Best of the Guardian's Country Diary, 2018-2024 is available at guardianbookshop.com
More latest news
Read all