
CREDITS ISSUED
60M+
CREDIT VALUE
$2B
AREA COVERED
38M ha
CREDITS REJECTED
6.7M
A coalition of academics led by Prof Andrew Macintosh — the former chair of Australia's federal carbon credit integrity scheme — has published findings through the Australian Conservation Foundation claiming that "phantom forests" in the semi-arid outback northwest of Bourke are generating carbon credits for forest regrowth that isn't happening. The researchers examined 50 human-induced regeneration projects and found only minimal increases in forest and tree crown cover over five years, despite favorable wet conditions.
Extraction Map
The numbers are staggering in their disproportion. Since 2013, more than 430 human-induced regeneration projects have been registered across 38 million hectares — an area larger than Japan. These projects have collectively generated more than 60 million carbon credits valued at up to $2 billion. Each credit is supposed to represent one tonne of CO₂ removed from or prevented from entering the atmosphere. Prof David Eldridge, a former principal research scientist with the NSW environment department and report co-author, said he was "gobsmacked" that areas which "have never grown forests" and "will never grow forests" could earn carbon credits for forest regrowth. The mechanism enabling this is Australia's safeguard mechanism, the federal policy requiring industrial polluters to cut emissions. Under current rules, companies covered by the scheme can purchase an unlimited number of carbon credits to count as their own cuts while continuing to pollute at previous levels. The report argues this creates a perverse incentive: a "flood of cheap, low integrity" credits makes it cheaper for big polluters to buy offsets than to invest in direct emissions reductions. The system is designed to reduce emissions; instead it may be functioning as a price-discovery tool for continued pollution. Project developers pushed back firmly. Green Collar, which manages carbon credit projects, said these are "some of the most closely examined carbon projects in the country" and that ground evidence shows they are working. The company criticized the report for not being peer-reviewed and for relying on "satellite pictures and a single field visit," arguing that satellite canopy imagery misses carbon stored in stems, branches, roots, and dead timber. Climate Friendly CEO Skye Glenday called the criticisms "at odds with the facts and the extensive independent scientific and regulatory scrutiny" applied to projects. The Clean Energy Regulator, which manages the scheme, said it had confidence in the forest regeneration method and noted that projects must demonstrate increasing canopy cover every five years. It said it had rejected non-complying areas that could have received 6.7 million carbon credits — a number that simultaneously demonstrates enforcement capacity and the scale of potential over-crediting. The researchers counter that their findings are consistent with previous peer-reviewed studies reaching the same conclusions. The structural question is whether offset markets as currently designed can ever function as genuine climate policy or whether they inevitably become a compliance arbitrage mechanism. The Australian Conservation Foundation wants coal and gas companies banned from claiming offsets as their own emissions cuts. Adam Bandt, the foundation's CEO and former Australian Greens leader, argued the safeguard mechanism "is not working" and that atmospheric emissions "can't be offset." The federal government is currently reviewing the safeguard policy as required under legislation. What makes this case study instructive beyond Australia is that it reveals the fundamental tension in market-based climate mechanisms: the moment you create a tradeable instrument representing something as hard to verify as forest carbon sequestration across 38 million hectares of remote land, you create an incentive gradient that rewards credit generation over actual carbon removal. The cheaper the credit relative to direct abatement, the more the system selects for volume over integrity.
Worth reading?
SKIP
Score
16
/100
Extractive. The system converts unverified environmental claims on remote semi-arid land into tradeable financial instruments worth $2B, allowing fossil fuel companies to buy compliance while continuing to emit, with costs borne by the atmosphere and future populations.
What Is GRIN?
GRIN stands for Generativity, Resilience, Innovation efficiency, and Novelty openness. These four dimensions capture the essential characteristics of any memetic intelligence — whether a nation, a corporation, a religion, or a movement.
About GRINGenerativity
1/5
Resilience
1/5
Efficiency
1/5
Novelty
1/5
Extractive
5/5
Inverted
Does this create new capability or just redistribute existing value?
Net-negative generativity. Credits generate financial value from phantom sequestration, destroying the credibility of carbon markets without producing real emissions reductions. Value created for intermediaries, not the climate.
Verified Facts (8)
Researchers examined 50 forest regeneration projects used to create carbon credits
Led by Prof Andrew Macintosh, former federal government carbon credit scheme integrity chair and director of ANU's Centre for Environmental Markets
More than 430 human-induced regeneration projects in Australia since 2013, covering an area of 38m hectares – larger than Japan
Projects had created more than 60m carbon credits worth up to $2bn
Clean Energy Regulator said it had rejected non-complying areas that could have received 6.7m carbon credits
Prof David Eldridge, former principal research scientist with the NSW environment department
Adam Bandt, the foundation's chief executive and a former Australian Greens leader
Research published in a report released by the Australian Conservation Foundation
More latest news
Read all