
CCS LOBBYISTS
700
UK EV MANDATE AT RISK
80%→?
PETROL vs EV FILL
£100 vs £10
OVERSHOOT ACKNOWLEDGED
1.5°C
The second week of COP31 in Antalya opens with the central fracture of modern climate diplomacy fully exposed: Global North countries are attempting to defang the Belem Action Mechanism (Bam), the Just Transition institution agreed at COP30 in Belém last year. A draft text published Friday would strip the mechanism of its intended financing and capacity-building functions, reducing it to a dialogue-and-reporting body housed within the existing UNFCCC secretariat. Japan and Norway are leading the resistance. The split is, as advocacy manager Devina Shah put it, "an almost neat north-south divide."
Extraction Map
The original Bam agreement was supposed to create a permanent institution embedding economic, social, and racial justice into the fossil fuel transition — with real money attached. What's on the table now is a shell: something that "merely dialogues, reports and sends messages," in the words of Sinéad Magner of the Women and Gender Constituency. The practical consequence is visible in cases like Portugal's planned Fernando Pessoa Solar Park, which would rank among the world's five largest solar farms but was developed without meaningful community consultation. The transition is happening. The question is whether it happens to people or with them. Meanwhile, carbon dioxide removal and carbon capture and storage have, for the first time, been included in a text that will inform the basis of a final COP31 deal. A record 700 CCS lobbyists are present in Antalya — more delegates than the smallest 50 national delegations combined, according to the Center for International Environmental Law. CDR advocates want a new global agency to coordinate carbon removals and have been pressing the Turkish-Australian co-presidency to embed CDR in the summit's final outcome. The two technologies occupy very different positions in the environmental community: CDR (pulling CO2 from the atmosphere) has broader support; CCS (capturing emissions at the source) faces criticism for its costs, mixed track record, and potential to prolong fossil fuel dependence. In the UK, the Climate Change Committee is set to write to ministers Wednesday about Labour's reported plans to weaken the zero emissions vehicle mandate, which currently requires 80% of new car sales to be electric by 2030 and 100% by 2035. CCC chair Nigel Topping has a two-decade track record in automotive advocacy and views decarbonization as an economic growth driver. Campaigners frame the numbers starkly: filling a petrol car costs over £100; fully charging an EV costs under £10. Weakening the mandate would slow EV market growth and raise consumer costs — the opposite of its stated intent. The Australian delegation contributed an unforced error when Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Climate Change Minister Chris Bowen were caught on a hot microphone engaging in what Australian media dubbed "dick-gate" — banter about mobile phone radiation and anatomical proximity. Albanese apologized from Manila; Bowen redirected to substance, noting: "What's not a joke is climate change, and that's what I'm completely focused on this week." The episode is trivial but illustrative: the gap between the gravity of the negotiations and the ambient culture of the negotiating class. The structural picture entering week two is this: the mechanisms that would distribute transition costs fairly are being hollowed out by the countries best positioned to fund them, while the technologies that could extend fossil fuel lifespans are gaining institutional recognition. The 700 CCS lobbyists are not a bug in the system — they are the system working exactly as designed for incumbents. The UN has acknowledged the world will soon surge past 1.5°C, and even with reduced emissions, temperatures will not fall below that threshold for thousands of years without active carbon removal. The question is whether removal becomes a complement to decarbonization or an alibi for delay. Every major COP produces a version of this dynamic: ambitious language at one summit, institutional dilution at the next. The Bam mechanism is the current test case. If it emerges from Antalya as a reporting body rather than a financing institution, the precedent is set: agreements with developing nations are provisional, subject to revision when implementation costs arrive.
Worth reading?
SKIP
Score
24
/100
Extractive — value is being concentrated toward fossil fuel incumbents and Global North governments while transition costs and climate impacts are borne disproportionately by developing nations and local communities.
What Is GRIN?
GRIN stands for Generativity, Resilience, Innovation efficiency, and Novelty openness. These four dimensions capture the essential characteristics of any memetic intelligence — whether a nation, a corporation, a religion, or a movement.
About GRINGenerativity
1/5
Resilience
1/5
Efficiency
2/5
Novelty
1/5
Extractive
4/5
Inverted
Does this create new capability or just redistribute existing value?
Little new capacity created. Just Transition mechanism is being gutted from institution to talk-shop. CCS/CDR inclusion may extend fossil infrastructure rather than build clean alternatives.
Verified Facts (8)
A draft text was published by the chairs of the Just Transition Work Programme on Friday
A record 700 lobbyists at this Cop are advocating for carbon capture and storage, according to the Center for International Environmental Law
This is more delegates than from the smallest 50 national delegations combined
The current mandate stipulates that 80% of new car sales will have to be electric from 2030, and 100% from 2035
Filling up a petrol-fuelled car can currently cost more than £100, while an electric vehicle can be fully charged for less than £10
For the first time, both CCS and CDR were included in a text that will inform the basis of a final deal at the climate talks
Global north countries, led by Japan and Norway, were the main barriers
The planned Fernando Pessoa Solar Park in Portugal would be the fifth biggest solar farm in the world
More latest news
Read all