
Chen Sicheng is best known for the Detective Chinatown franchise, a series that wraps crowd-pleasing genre energy in a glossy commercial package. Traces of Justice operates on a different register — more sober, more structurally ambitious, and more explicitly invested in institutional legitimacy. The film follows Cui Xun, a fictional composite of real forensic pioneer Cui Daozhi, across three decades and three cases: a child killing in the 1970s, a multiple murder in the 1980s, and a bus bombing in the 1990s. The anthology structure is the film's first smart choice — it lets Chen track the evolution of forensic science as a living discipline, where each case introduces techniques that become routine background detail in the next. Zhang Yi plays Cui across all three eras, ageing up with notable restraint. What the performance captures is professional absorption: this is a man whose inner life has been almost entirely colonised by the job. Personal relationships blur at the edges; the fingernails stay in focus. It's a type of performance that could read as thin, but Zhang makes the narrowness feel like characterisation rather than omission. The 1970s segment, in which improvised potato-based dental casting gives way to researchers biting each other's cheeks to generate comparison samples, is both genuinely funny and unexpectedly touching — scientists literally scarred by their dedication. Chen's storytelling is at its most confident in the forensic puzzle sequences. He follows the science procedurally, without dumbing it down or mystifying it, and the period texture is carefully maintained across all three settings. By the third segment, with Cui running a large, well-resourced team, the aesthetic shift is deliberate and effective: we have arrived, unmistakably, at something that rhymes with prestige Western procedurals — the same cool institutional competence, the same faith in method over intuition. The bus-bombing case brings the film's most unsettling material. The perpetrators are explicitly compared to Leopold and Loeb — a rare gesture toward international cultural referencing that briefly opens the film to something darker and more psychologically complex than state mythology usually permits. It doesn't last. The film snaps back to its reassuring structural arc: persistence wins, science prevails, justice lands. And this is where any honest account has to name the thing. Traces of Justice is sincere propaganda for the Chinese law-enforcement apparatus — not incidentally, but structurally. The end titles explicitly connect Cui's work to China's current mass-surveillance architecture. Chen doesn't obscure this; he frames it as the natural endpoint of fifty years of scientific progress. Whether you read that as unsettling, banal, or simply true about how most national cinema functions, it shapes what the film is doing and why. The craft is real. The agenda is real. They are not in conflict — they are collaborating.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
56
/100
Viewers who enjoy slow-burn forensic procedurals and are either unbothered by or analytically curious about state-sanctioned national cinema. Not for those who need ideological clean hands in their genre entertainment.
Cultural Placement
Like David Fincher's Zodiac in its faith in procedure over revelation, but more interested in institutional evolution than individual obsession — closer in spirit to the long-arc of Terence Davies' autobiographical films, with the episodic structure of an anthology repackaged as a single biography. The CSI aesthetic Chen invokes in the third act is a knowing wink to the form's global DNA, while the biographical scaffolding places the film in a specifically Chinese tradition of heroic professional hagiography. The film it most resembles temperamentally is a sober Michael Mann picture stripped of romanticism: craft as ideology, methodology as morality.
Honest assessment
Traces of Justice is a well-made, structurally intelligent film that delivers real procedural pleasure while doing real ideological work — and the film makes no pretence that these are separable. Zhang Yi's performance is the film's best asset; the anthology structure is its most original choice. It won't challenge you, but it will hold your attention across its full runtime.
What Is NOVEL?
56
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
2/5
Originality
3/5
Voice
3/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Limited nerve. The anthology-biopic structure is an elegant choice, but Chen never risks the film's core thesis — the state apparatus is never seriously interrogated. Safe within its own ideological perimeter.
Permission slip
Consensus says: Critical consensus is likely to position this as a prestige genre film with 'problematic' state messaging. We say: the messaging is inseparable from the craft — treat it as a coherent text, not a compromised one.
What they're missing: Most Western criticism of Chinese state cinema performs discomfort with the propaganda while praising the execution as though the two can be evaluated separately. They cannot. Chen is building the same thing in both registers simultaneously, and understanding that is what makes the film interesting rather than merely enjoyable.
Verified Facts (7)
The latest from Chen Sicheng, prime mover behind the hit Detective Chinatown franchise
Its hero is Cui Xun, a fictional stand-in for the venerable Cui Daozhi, a still-extant real-life figure who so revolutionised forensic science he became known as 'China's Sherlock Holmes'
Three-and-a-bit tales from the casebook – involving a 1970s child killer, a grisly 1980s multiple murder and a 1990s bus bombing
A rookie Cui (played here by Zhang Yi, ageing up subtly) uses boiled potatoes to take dental imprints
The bus bombers are an Asian equivalent to Leopold and Loeb
End titles also cite the centrality of Cui's work to China's current surveillance schemes
Traces of Justice is out on 6 November in the UK, 12 November in Australia and 13 November in the US
More latest news
Read all