
SUPERMAN DELIVERED
$618M
BUSINESS TAKING AROUND
$111M
REPORTED
$40M
Warner Bros. had a simple theory in 2022: hire the one filmmaker in Hollywood who demonstrably understood comic book weirdness from the inside out, give him CEO authority alongside producer Peter Safran, and let him build something coherent over time. James Gunn — the man who made audiences care about a talking raccoon and a sentient tree — was the entire thesis. Not a piece of the thesis. The thesis. Four years later, that thesis has been cancelled by a billionaire who bought Warner last month and apparently decided the slow-build approach was costing him money. Jeremy Latcham is now running DC Studios. Latcham's credential is real — he produced Guardians of the Galaxy and Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves — but his stated editorial philosophy is the grandmother test: would his grandparents in Oklahoma get it? That filter produced some decent Marvel films. It is a poor fit for a studio whose best recent work involves exploding torsos and heroes who swear. The numbers Ellison apparently found unsatisfying deserve honest scrutiny. Superman delivered $618 million globally last summer and decent reviews — a strong opening for a rebooted universe. Supergirl underperformed, that is true. But Clayface, a horror spin-off on a $40 million budget, cleared $111 million worldwide. That is a profitable film by any measure. The DCU was not on fire. It was doing what shared universes are supposed to do in their early phase: establish tone, build character foundations, and occasionally swing at something strange. The strangest and most damning part of this story is how precisely it repeats the mistake that created the DCEU's collapse in the first place. Warner Bros. rushed Zack Snyder's universe toward Justice League before it had properly set up its individual heroes, and the resulting pile-up of Batman v Superman and a studio-rebooted Justice League destroyed audience trust for half a decade. The Hollywood trades now report that Ellison wants the big guns back — Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman — immediately. This is the same map. The studio has set it on fire again. Gunn's DCU was building something genuinely rare in franchise filmmaking: a recognizable aesthetic sensibility. Peacemaker and Lanterns were doing the connective tissue work that Marvel spent ten years developing, with a tonal coherence that Marvel's current output has largely lost. The Gunn-Safran DCU felt like it had a nervous system. The concern now is not just that Latcham will sand off the eccentric edges — it is that there are no edges left to sand once you've made the grandmother test your editorial north star. The twenty-year view here is bleak if the pattern holds. Hollywood's superhero cycle has been driven by one dynamic above all others: the difference between studios that give filmmakers a coherent mandate and time, and studios that chase quarterly returns into tent-pole pile-ups. Marvel's decade of dominance was built on exactly the patience Ellison seems unwilling to extend. The irony is that the DCU was just beginning to earn genuine fan investment — not nostalgia, not IP familiarity, but actual interest in where these specific stories were going. Latcham will inherit an audience that is now actively wondering whether to show up. What we are watching is the structural logic of private equity applied to creative infrastructure. Skydance has now absorbed Paramount and Warner within twelve months. The incentive is not to build a durable franchise universe — it is to generate recognizable returns on a compressed timeline. Gunn's fatal mistake, apparently, was having a plan that required patience. In the current Hollywood ownership environment, patience is the one thing the map doesn't show.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
64
/100
Anyone who has followed the DCU reboot with any investment, or who is interested in how private-equity acquisition logic interacts with creative franchise management. Not essential for casual fans who just want to know if the next Superman film will be good.
Cultural Placement
Like Peter Biskind's Easy Riders, Raging Bulls applied to the IP era — an autopsy of creative vision meeting institutional impatience — but written at the speed of a trade break and with the structural clarity of someone who has watched this exact disaster before. The piece's mechanism is diagnostic: it uses the Gunn firing to illustrate how private-equity ownership logic serially destroys the conditions that make franchise filmmaking work. Closest tonal predecessor is the kind of Guardian long-form that Stuart Heritage does at his best: specific, argumentative, slightly furious, grounded entirely in named facts rather than vibes.
Honest assessment
This is a sharp, well-voiced piece of trade analysis dressed as cultural criticism. It makes its core structural argument — that Ellison is repeating the DCEU's exact original error — clearly and with enough specific numbers to be credible. Its limits are that the thesis isn't new and the analysis doesn't go much deeper than a well-informed fan forum post, albeit written considerably better.
What Is NOVEL?
64
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
3/5
Originality
3/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Moderate nerve. The piece names Ellison directly and the grandmother-test critique of Latcham is pointed. But it stays well within Guardian opinion comfort zones — no structural argument that would genuinely alienate the readership.
Permission slip
Consensus says: Critical consensus treats this as a straightforward 'studio makes bad creative decision' story. We're reading it as a private-equity acquisition logic story — the creative decision is the symptom, not the disease.
What they're missing: The piece almost gets there itself in its final paragraph, but pulls back from naming Skydance's ownership model as the structural cause. The consensus framing lets Ellison off as impatient rather than incentive-misaligned.
Verified Facts (6)
Superman delivered $618m at the global box office
Clayface has quietly done respectable business, taking around $111m worldwide on a reported $40m budget
Jeremy Latcham is the new boss
David Ellison's Skydance empire has now gobbled up two of the former big five Hollywood studios (Paramount last year and Warner last month)
Warner Bros Discovery CEO David Zaslav spoke of a 'bold 10-year plan'
Latcham's credits do include Guardians of the Galaxy and Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves
More latest news
Read all