
Poh Si Teng quit her job at ABC News and emptied her savings account to make this film. That biographical fact is load-bearing: it explains why American Doctor feels nothing like institutional documentary filmmaking. There's no studied neutrality here, no both-sides scaffolding. Teng is not a journalist covering a story from outside — she's a filmmaker who decided the story was worth her own ruin to tell. The film follows three American doctors who sign up to volunteer at Nasser hospital in southern Gaza in early 2025. The trio never actually becomes a trio: Thaer Ahmad, an ER physician of Palestinian heritage from Chicago, is refused entry at the border the night before the others cross in. That detail — an American doctor, turned back because of his heritage — does more political work in one sentence than an hour of punditry could. What remains is Dr Feroze Sidhwa, a trauma surgeon, and Dr Mark Perlmutter, a Jewish-American orthopaedic surgeon, both of whom have been to Gaza before. Perlmutter's pre-departure ritual — antibiotics parcelled into a dozen small bags distributed through his luggage, so that border confiscation can't take all of it — is the film's first great image. It captures something precise about how experienced aid workers navigate a system designed to impede them: not defiance, exactly, but tactical persistence. Inside Nasser hospital, the film earns its emotional weight the hard way, through accumulation rather than spectacle. The camaraderie between medics of different nationalities, bantering in the shared dialect of dark medical humor, establishes normalcy before the mass casualty events arrive. When they do — patients with limbs blown off, no pain medication available — the contrast doesn't feel manipulative because the film has already shown you the people doing the work. All three doctors eventually leave the hospital and find themselves pulled into advocacy: podcasts, television news, congressional corridors. The transition from OR to media circuit is handled honestly — the film doesn't romanticize it, and it doesn't treat advocacy as a betrayal of medicine. It treats it as the logical next step for people who've seen what they've seen. The guilt Perlmutter and Sidhwa feel returning to their lives is stated plainly, without being milked. The cameras are present for one of the seven Israeli airstrikes on Nasser hospital since the war began. That sequence is in the film. And then, after filming wrapped, surgeon Rizk Abu Shaira — a Palestinian doctor who appears in the film — was killed in the most recent strike, among six reported fatalities. The documentary has an afterlife the filmmakers couldn't have planned, and it darkens everything that comes before it. This is not a comfortable film and it isn't trying to be. What it is, more precisely, is a film about the specific moral experience of going somewhere terrible by choice, doing what you can, and then having to come home. That experience — the gap between what you witnessed and what you're able to do about it — is what American Doctor captures best, and it stays with you.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
64
/100
Anyone who wants to understand what it actually looks like inside a war-zone hospital, and what the experience does to the people who choose to be there. Not a comfortable watch — actively so. Avoid if you've already made up your mind about everything and want that confirmed.
Cultural Placement
Like Matthew Heineman's Cartel Land or City of Ghosts — embedded, participant-adjacent documentary filmmaking where the director's personal commitment to access shapes the film's texture — but more intimate in scale and more focused on the psychological cost borne by the witnesses rather than the systems producing the violence. It shares DNA with Evgeny Afineevsky's Winter on Fire in its urgency, and with the best of Frontline's correspondent-driven work in its respect for the people it profiles. What distinguishes it is the double frame: the doctors are themselves a camera on the hospital, and Teng is a camera on the doctors.
Honest assessment
American Doctor is a morally serious piece of filmmaking that earns its anger through specificity rather than assertion. It won't change the mind of anyone determined not to look, but for everyone else it offers something rarer than outrage: a close study of conscience under pressure. The film's greatest limitation is formal — it's a well-executed version of an existing template rather than a documentary that pushes the form somewhere new.
What Is NOVEL?
64
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
4/5
Originality
2/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Real risk. Director quit her job, spent her savings, and embedded in an active war zone. The film could have failed on access, on ethics, or simply on the gap between footage and meaning. It doesn't.
Permission slip
Consensus says: Critical consensus will likely position this as essential Gaza-conflict documentary viewing. We'd call it recommended but not essential — the form is familiar, and the film's power is primarily testimonial rather than cinematic.
What they're missing: The moral urgency of the subject can inflate evaluations of the craft. This is a good documentary about important events; it isn't a formally significant one. Those are different things, and conflating them does a disservice to both the film and to viewers trying to decide whether to see it.
Verified Facts (9)
Director Poh Si Teng quit her job at ABC News and cashed in her savings to get the documentary off the ground
The film follows three American doctors who sign up to volunteer at the Nasser hospital in southern Gaza in early 2025
Thaer Ahmad, an ER doctor of Palestinian heritage from Chicago, is refused entry the night before they enter Gaza
Dr Feroze Sidhwa is a trauma surgeon; Dr Mark Perlmutter is a Jewish-American orthopaedic surgeon
Perlmutter packs antibiotics into a dozen or so little plastic bags dotted around his luggage
Perlmutter gets a will drawn up before he goes, given the high death rate of medics in the war
Nasser hospital has been attacked seven times since the start of the war
The latest Israeli airstrike killed Palestinian doctor Rizk Abu Shaira, who was among six reported fatalities
American Doctor is in UK and Irish cinemas from 20 November
More latest news
Read all