
There's a specific kind of institutional horror that belongs to Heysel — not the horror of a villain, but of a committee. No single monster ordered 39 people to die on 29 May 1985 at the European Cup final between Juventus and Liverpool. What happened was more banal and more damning: a stadium literally falling apart, policing that couldn't cope, barriers that stayed shut while people were crushed, and then — grimly, almost unbelievably — the match went ahead anyway. Heysel 85 is a film about that banality, and it is livid. Director Teodora Ana Mihai, Romanian-born and Brussels-based, brings a documentary nerve to the material. Her background as a collaborator of Cristian Mungiu would suggest a certain austere realism; the film the Guardian describes feels closer in temperament to Paul Greengrass — the tunnel acoustics turning crowd noise into something like lamentation, the institutional figures flinching and dithering like men who know exactly what they've done and are calculating the cover story in real time. The sport's officer class as a war room where the war has already been lost and nobody will admit it. The film has drawn criticism for two specific fictionalizations. First: players are shown unaware that fans had died before kick-off, when most were in fact largely aware. Second: the Brussels mayor is rendered as a drunken caricature — given the fictional name Marc Dumont (played by Josse De Pauw) — a depiction those familiar with the actual mayor Hervé Brouhon have found unfair. These are legitimate criticisms, and they're worth holding alongside the film's evident power. Historical drama always trades accuracy for legibility; the question is whether the distortion serves or betrays the truth of the event. Here the film's defenders would argue the core charge — catastrophic, complacent incompetence by civic authorities who should never have allowed this stadium to host this match — is not in dispute. The film's moral center is Paolo Calabresi as Giacomo Ferragni, a fictionalised Italian politician apparently modeled on Gianni De Michelis, Italy's real minister of labor who was present. Calabresi's performance is described as passionate and disturbing — the character functioning as the film's vessel of outrage, a man appalled not by evil but by the sheer self-satisfied mediocrity of administrators who look at the dead and calculate optics. It's a smart structural choice: the horror is not conveyed through victims (which risks exploitation) but through a witness with institutional standing whose fury reads as proportionate. The comparison to Hillsborough is unavoidable, and Mihai leans into it. Asif Kapadia's recent Kenny Dalglish documentary framed Heysel as Liverpool's shame and Hillsborough as the press and political establishment's shame. Mihai's film insists on a different accounting: Heysel's shame belongs to Brussels city authorities who permitted a major European event in a venue that was structurally unfit, and who kept the barriers closed when opening them to the pitch might have saved lives — a direct echo of the Taylor Report's findings about Hillsborough four years later. The film is not interested in apportioning fan blame. It is interested in asking who signed off, and why they still aren't answering for it. What Mihai appears to have made is a civic horror film — a genre that works best when it refuses catharsis. The match went ahead. The administrators were not held to account in any way commensurate with 39 deaths. The film's rage, per the review, is 'effectively ventriloquised' — controlled enough to remain disturbing rather than operatic. That discipline is the hardest thing to pull off in this kind of material, and it sounds like she pulls it off.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
68
/100
Viewers who want political cinema that works through anger rather than grief — fans of Bloody Sunday, Z, or the Hillsborough drama who can sit with a film that refuses catharsis and withholds justice.
Cultural Placement
Like Paul Greengrass's Bloody Sunday but angrier, with the institutional autopsy structure of Costa-Gavras's Z and the controlled grief of Mungiu's 4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days. Mihai maps mechanism not tragedy: this is less a memorial film than an indictment of how bureaucratic cowardice converts negligence into mass death. The closest recent comparison in feel is United 93 — the horror is in watching people who know what's happening refuse to act.
Honest assessment
Mihai has made a tightly controlled rage-document about institutional negligence, not a tragedy about football fans. The fictionalisation criticisms are real and shouldn't be waved away, but they don't invalidate the core charge the film prosecutes. If you go in wanting a Hillsborough-style victim narrative, this will feel cold; if you want to watch someone hold bureaucrats to account for 39 deaths, this is the film.
What Is NOVEL?
68
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
3/5
Originality
3/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
4/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Moderate risk: fictionalizing living figures and deferring fan-blame in a Liverpool/Juventus film invites backlash from both sides. The match-goes-ahead structure bets on sustained dread over resolution.
Permission slip
Consensus says: The Guardian's review is unambiguously enthusiastic ('fierce and intimately disturbing'). We share the enthusiasm but want to flag the fictionalisation controversy more prominently than the review does — it's a real tension, not a footnote.
What they're missing: The caricature of a named living official (Brouhon) is ethically meaningful in ways that go beyond craft, and viewers deserve to weigh it rather than have it bracketed as minor criticism. The film can be both powerful and legitimately contested on that point.
Lineage tree
Bloody Sunday (Greengrass, 2002)
direct formal ancestor — docudrama indictment of state violence
Z (Costa-Gavras, 1969)
structural ancestor — institutional complicity as thriller grammar
4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days (Mungiu, 2007)
tonal influence — controlled horror via bureaucratic obstruction
United 93 (Greengrass, 2006)
extends the form of — real-time institutional failure as horror
Verified Facts (7)
Crowd disorder before kickoff in a poorly maintained, badly policed venue resulted in the deaths of 39 fans.
The match was allowed to go ahead, despite the fatalities; the authorities believed the game itself would restore order on a bread-and-circuses basis.
Heysel 85 is directed and co-written by Romanian-born and Belgian-based film-maker Teodora Ana Mihai; she is a former collaborator of Cristian Mungiu.
The fictionalised mayor of Brussels is named Marc Dumont (Josse De Pauw), criticised as an unfair drunken caricature of the actual mayor, Hervé Brouhon.
Players are depicted as not being aware that fans had died before they took to the field — they were in fact largely aware.
Paolo Calabresi plays Giacomo Ferragni, evidently based on Italy's real life minister of labour Gianni De Michelis, who was present.
Heysel 85 is in UK and Irish cinemas from 20 November.
More latest news
Read all