
Watch
When a Witness Recants
on The New Yorker
In November 1983, 14-year-old DeWitt Duckett was shot and killed in a hallway of Harlem Park junior high school in West Baltimore — the first child killed inside a Baltimore public school — by a teenager who stole his blue satin Georgetown jacket. Three boys, Alfred Chestnut, Ransom Watkins, and Andrew Stewart, were arrested, tried, and convicted. They each served 36 years. They were innocent. The mechanism of their conviction is as simple as it is enraging. DeWitt's friend Ron Bishop, also 14 and walking beside him when he was shot, was pressured by detective Donald Kincaid to change his initial witness statement. Bishop's account of what happened in that interrogation room is unbearable: 'I know I am not leaving alive if I don't tell him that Alfred shot Dewitt, Alfred had the gun, Andrew and Ransom were pulling the jacket off of him.' The actual perpetrator — another teen named Michael Willis, who wore Duckett's jacket to a roller rink and bragged about the crime — was never questioned. The police files documenting multiple reports about Willis were buried. Chestnut obtained them via public records request in 2018. Willis was shot and killed in 2002. Prosecutor Jonathan Shoup died in 2016; his obituary listed the Georgetown jacket case as a noteworthy accomplishment. Detective Kincaid, asked in a 2022 deposition what he would have changed about his investigation, answered: 'Nothing.' The film's first half works as procedural horror — a meticulous accounting of how every safeguard failed simultaneously. The judge, Robert M Bell, did not question grand jury testimony riddled with inconsistencies. Shoup brushed off Bishop's protestations and pressured him back onto the stand. Courtroom sketches from the trial depicted the three 16-year-olds as adults. 'The police department showed about as much regard for DeWitt Duckett's life as the person who killed him,' says Ta-Nehisi Coates, who serves here as participant and executive producer rather than narrator, and whose personal connection to the story — Duckett's murder was the first time the eight-year-old Coates understood that danger in America was racially distributed — gives the film an autobiographical charge that keeps it from feeling like a legal procedural. What Porter does that most wrongful-conviction documentaries don't is follow the story past the exoneration. Chestnut, Watkins, and Stewart were released in 2019. By 2021, they had agreed to participate in this film. They function as a unit — separated in prison for 27 years, they still finish each other's thoughts. The final third of the film documents the long-awaited meeting between the three men and Bishop, now a mental health counsellor, and it goes wrong in every way a viewer might hope it would go right. Bishop rambles into self-justification. The men respond with blisteringly honest anger. Watkins explains why he stopped trying to be 'politically correct': 'If I don't tell this man how I feel, and I've been waiting on this for 36 years… you ain't going to never in your life get a chance to do it again. So I just let it flow.' There is no rapprochement. There is no forgiveness. The film does not flinch. This is where Porter earns her score. The meeting scene is the kind of documentary moment that most filmmakers would have shaped toward resolution — the form demands it, the audience expects it, the funders probably hoped for it. Porter holds the camera steady and lets it fall apart. The result is a scene that will stay with viewers longer than any tidy conclusion could. As Chestnut says of the moment he realized no satisfying apology was coming: 'It made us all angry to listen to him talk' — knowing freedom had been 36 years away, delayed for want of a single honest word. Life goes on: Watkins, Stewart, and Chestnut are each partnered, building lives in middle age. Chestnut has a young daughter. But Porter's final frame insists that what was taken cannot be restored. 'You can't fix this,' she says. 'Money doesn't fix it. Nothing fixes it. You have to just not do it.'
Worth reading?
ESSENTIAL
Score
76
/100
Anyone who watches true-crime documentaries and wants to see the form used with real moral seriousness; viewers of When They See Us, 13th, or Making a Murderer who felt those films still pulled their punches at the end.
Cultural Placement
Like Errol Morris's The Thin Blue Line but emotionally closer to its subjects, with the institutional accountability of Ava DuVernay's 13th and the refusal of When They See Us to offer easy redemption arcs. Porter's closest formal ancestor is probably Kirsten Johnson's Cameraperson — not in subject but in the ethics of what a camera owes the people in front of it. What makes When a Witness Recants distinctive within the wrongful-conviction genre is its decision to follow the story past exoneration into the unresolved emotional wreckage, treating the lack of catharsis not as a failure of the film but as its point.
Honest assessment
This is a tightly made, emotionally honest documentary that earns its runtime by refusing to give the audience what it came for. The legal procedural first half is good; the meeting scene in the final third is extraordinary. Porter's formal restraint — especially the choice to let the confrontation with Bishop fall apart rather than shape it toward closure — is the best decision in the film and the reason it will outlast the news cycle.
What Is NOVEL?
76
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
4/5
Originality
3/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
4/5
Lineage
4/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Genuine nerve: Porter holds the meeting scene open as it collapses, refusing the resolution the form demands. That choice — no rapprochement, no editing toward comfort — is where the film risks and earns.
Lineage tree
The Thin Blue Line
direct ancestor — established the wrongful-conviction documentary as a form with forensic rigour
13th
tonal influence — systemic indictment of racial injustice embedded in the American legal structure
When They See Us
extends the form of — post-exoneration focus on psychological damage rather than legal vindication
Between the World and Me
argues against easy closure — Coates's presence explicitly carries this argument into the film
Verified Facts (12)
DeWitt Duckett was shot and killed on 18 November 1983 at Harlem Park junior high school in Baltimore
Duckett was 14 years old at the time of his death
Alfred Chestnut, Ransom Watkins, and Andrew Stewart each spent 36 years in prison
Ron Bishop recanted his testimony officially in 2019
Jennifer Gonnerman published an article on the case in The New Yorker in November 2021
Michael Willis wore Duckett's jacket to a roller rink and bragged about the crime; he was never questioned by police
Willis was shot and killed in 2002
Prosecutor Jonathan Shoup died in 2016; his obituary listed the Georgetown jacket case as a noteworthy accomplishment
Detective Kincaid, asked in a 2022 deposition what he would have changed, answered: 'Nothing'
Chestnut obtained buried police files via public records request in 2018
The three men were separated in prison for 27 years
When a Witness Recants premieres on HBO on 18 November and will be available on HBO Max in the US and UK
More latest news
Read all