
The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth is set almost a decade after Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, in the Los Angeles of 1977 — the same time and place as Boogie Nights, though Paul Thomas Anderson gets no namecheck. Cliff has grown a moustache, quit stuntwork after sustaining an injury that gives him a limp, moved in with his cantankerous pawnshop-proprietor father Gus (Peter Weller), and assembled a portfolio of side-hustles: movie theatre projectionist at the New Beverly Cinema, bartender across several joints, demolition derby hand, and discreet fixer for people being extorted. Rick Dalton, his old pal, is apparently making a TV show in Australia. Sharon Tate appears on TV advertising cigarettes. The central case arrives when talent agent Karen Crosby (Elizabeth Debicki) — smart, willowy, a former movie critic once mentored by Pauline Kael — contacts Cliff out of the blue. He falls passionately in love with her. Through Karen he meets her client Charlie Peters (Scott Caan), a TV actor working alongside blaxploitation star 'Hot' Rod Harrison (Yahya Abdul-Mateen II), who is fascinated by Cliff's Second World War military record. Cliff's heart is additionally softened by a former tendresse for Charlie's worldly wife Toni (Carla Cugino). The job pulls Cliff back into violent crime. Fincher's direction noticeably tightens the chapter-by-chapter prolixity that Tarantino favors. Scene transitions move faster. Female characters, pointedly, keep their shoes and socks on. The switch in director creates a more propulsive machine — less digressive wallowing, more procedural momentum — and it mostly serves the material, though a Tarantino purist might feel robbed of the deliberate sprawl. The two sensibilities aren't perfectly fused, but the friction is productive more often than not. The film earns most of its pleasures in texture: a genuinely funny pastiche-montage of Charlie Peters's B-picture and TV credits (like the Rick Dalton sequence in the first film), some loathsome hitmen bickering about the illogical house-numbering on Mulholland Drive, and the ambient comedy of Cliff being recognized all over Los Angeles despite having no visible career. The Elmore Leonard urban-crime-pastoral is fully intact; so is the Ed Bunker brutality when the film needs it. The Karen Crosby character also absorbs Tarantino's apparently shelved idea for a movie-critic protagonist, though the reviewer notes some disappointment that the mentoring figure is Pauline Kael rather than the LA Times's Kevin Thomas. The one shadow the film refuses to step out of is the Cliff-killed-his-wife question. Addressed only in Tarantino's novel adaptation of the first film, it goes tactfully unexamined here — clearly held in reserve for the forthcoming Cliff Booth crossover novel, with which this film is designed to form a multimedia narrative event. It's a legitimate artistic choice and also a commercially convenient one; the result is that the film's moral center has a hole in it. We're asked to root for a man whose most defining act we're not permitted to scrutinize. The ending is truncated, as the review of the first film observed of Kill Bill: Volume 2 — a function, clearly, of the story being distributed across film and book rather than resolved in either. This is a genuine structural problem, not a stylistic choice, and it will frustrate viewers who come to the cinema expecting a complete narrative arc. What they get instead is a very long, very entertaining first act to something bigger. None of this diminishes Brad Pitt's performance, which is the reason to be there. Cliff's battle-hardened easygoing carapace — the man who is essentially surprised by nothing — provides the ironic torsion the whole film runs on. Pitt has built something genuinely unusual: a comic creation whose comedy derives entirely from stillness and imperturbability rather than from gags. When the violence comes, the calm makes it more shocking. When the romance comes, the calm makes it more touching. It's a sphinx performance in the best sense, and no other actor alive would do it the same way.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
64
/100
Fans of the first film who can tolerate an unresolved ending and are willing to meet the story halfway across novel and screen; Pitt completists; anyone who enjoys Elmore Leonard-flavored LA crime with a high style quotient.
Cultural Placement
Like Kill Bill: Volume 2 in its relationship to its predecessor — repeating characters and ideas with deliberate, slightly pedantic fidelity — but filtered now through David Fincher's procedural momentum rather than Tarantino's chapter-sprawl. The tonal DNA is Elmore Leonard crime-pastoral crossed with the Ed Bunker gutter-realism that runs through the first film, with the pacing discipline closer to Zodiac or Se7en than to anything in Tarantino's own catalogue. The Karen Crosby subplot channels the kind of smart-woman-in-a-man's-genre energy you'd find in a Walter Hill picture, while the multimedia novel-film architecture borrows more from prestige TV season-finale logic than from traditional cinema. The result is something that feels less like a standalone film and more like the second episode of a very expensive limited series.
Honest assessment
This is a film that delivers on atmosphere, performance, and scene-level pleasure while deliberately withholding narrative resolution — a structural choice that works as multimedia strategy and frustrates as cinema. Pitt's Cliff Booth is a genuinely great comic creation and the film is worth watching for him alone. But viewers expecting a complete story will leave with a tab still open.
What Is NOVEL?
64
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
3/5
Originality
2/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
4/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Moderate nerve: commissioning Fincher to direct Tarantino's script is a real structural gamble. But the multimedia novel-film split diffuses risk commercially while blunting the film's standalone punch.
Permission slip
Consensus says: Early consensus positions this as a crowd-pleasing win; we score it more cautiously as a film that earns its pleasures but structurally cannot land its own ending.
What they're missing: The multimedia architecture is being treated as an artistic innovation when it's also a commercial hedge — the film is incomplete by design, and that incompleteness should be named, not absorbed into the hype.
Lineage tree
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
direct ancestor — same character, same moral universe, explicit sequel
Kill Bill: Volume 2
structural parallel — Tarantino revisiting characters with deliberate pedantry
Elmore Leonard's crime fiction
tonal influence — urban crime-pastoral, bickering criminals, laconic cool
Ed Bunker's crime writing
tonal influence — brutality and gutter-realism beneath the comedy
David Fincher's Zodiac / Se7en
directorial lineage — procedural momentum, controlled transitions
Verified Facts (15)
The film is scripted by Tarantino and directed by David Fincher
The setting is the Los Angeles of 1977
Cliff Booth has sustained an injury that gives him a slight limp and has quit the stunt business
Cliff lives with his cantankerous old pawnshop-proprietor dad Gus, played by Peter Weller
Cliff works as a movie theatre projectionist at LA's historic New Beverly Cinema
Karen Crosby is played by Elizabeth Debicki and described as a former movie critic once mentored by Pauline Kael
Charlie Peters is played by Scott Caan
'Hot' Rod Harrison is played by Yahya Abdul-Mateen II and described as a blaxploitation star
Carla Cugino plays Toni, Charlie's worldly wife
Sharon Tate appears on TV advertising cigarettes
Rick Dalton is apparently making a TV show in Australia
The film runs 140 minutes
UK and US cinemas from 25 November; Australian cinemas from 26 November; Netflix from 23 December
Some loathsome hitmen argue about the illogical house-numbering sequence on LA's Mulholland Drive
The New Beverly Cinema is Tarantino's present-day owned venue
More latest news
Read all