
Nathan Fielder has spent his career building elaborate traps for reality — sets that look like life, rehearsals for conversations that haven't happened yet, situations in which the gap between sincerity and performance becomes impossible to locate. Elizabeth Holmes, who convinced billionaires, regulators, and patients that a blood-testing box could do what it cannot do, is the most consequential practitioner of the same trick. Putting them in a room together is either the obvious move or the most dangerous one. What Fielder and co-director Lance Oppenheim actually capture in those pre-prison weeks in San Diego is a stare-down between two people who have each built their identity on the proposition that believing something hard enough makes it real. Holmes maintains, with the wide-eyed vacancy of someone who has rehearsed innocence until it became reflexive, that the Theranos technology works — or will work, or could work, which she treats as equivalent. Fielder probes this with the patience of Gitta Sereny interviewing Albert Speer: not frontal assault, but the sustained, sympathetic pressure of someone who wants to understand how the lie was built from the inside. The first half operates as a genuinely tense character study. Holmes's partner Billy Evans — Charlie Kirk enthusiast, alpha-dog entrepreneur manqué — provides a kind of comic counterweight, his bluster a cruder version of the same reality-distortion field. The conversations with Evans carry identical tension to those with Holmes: both are waiting for Fielder to blink first, and Fielder never blinks. When Holmes switches from contact lenses to glasses for the final drive to prison, the film earns its one moment of unguarded feeling, and it lands because nothing before it has been unguarded. Then Holmes goes to prison and the film does something that most documentaries would refuse to do. Fielder and Oppenheim call Amanda Seyfried — who played Holmes in the Hulu dramatization The Dropout — and ask her to re-enact conversations they were never able to film. Seyfried arrives like a pressure valve releasing: openly delighted by the absurdity, visibly feeling every emotion that Holmes withholds. The juxtaposition is the argument. Holmes may have been performing a role all along; Seyfried, performing Holmes, is the only person in the film who shows you her whole hand. The uncanny-valley mirage of the actress-playing-the-fraudster-who-played-the-visionary refracts the question of authenticity until it dissolves. The comparison to Andrew Jarecki's Capturing the Friedmans is apt: both films execute a mid-story pivot that retroactively changes what you thought you were watching. Here, the pivot isn't just structural — it's philosophical. The film isn't ultimately about Holmes's guilt or innocence (the courts have settled that). It's about the mechanism by which a person can be genuinely unable to locate the boundary between belief and fabrication, and what it means to try to document that from the outside. Much of the narrative mystery is frankly editorial — created in the cut, shaped by the score — and the film doesn't pretend otherwise. That honesty about its own construction is rarer than it looks.
Worth reading?
ESSENTIAL
Score
88
/100
Anyone interested in documentary form, the Holmes story, or Fielder's work — but specifically viewers who want a film that earns its formal risks rather than performing them.
Cultural Placement
Like The Act of Killing in its willingness to collapse the boundary between documentation and re-enactment, but with the dark comic precision of The Rehearsal and the structural patience of Errol Morris's The Fog of War. Fielder operates in the Morris tradition of the sympathetic interrogator who never raises his voice, but where Morris uses the interview as a machine for excavating memory, Fielder uses it as a machine for locating the point where self-deception becomes indistinguishable from performance. The closest precedent for the Seyfried move is probably The Arbor (2010), Clio Barnard's film in which actors lip-sync to recordings of real people — but You Can See Everything pushes the conceit further, into territory where you can no longer tell whether the meta-layer clarifies or obscures.
Honest assessment
You Can See Everything is the best film yet made about Elizabeth Holmes, but that's almost incidental — it's really a film about what happens when the documentary form meets a subject who has immunized herself against truth-telling. The Seyfried pivot is either a masterstroke or a cop-out depending on your tolerance for meta-construction, but the film is honest enough about its own editorial choices that the question feels productive rather than evasive. See it before the discourse flattens it.
What Is NOVEL?
88
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
5/5
Originality
4/5
Voice
5/5
Endurance
4/5
Lineage
4/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Hiring the actress who played your subject to re-enact scenes you couldn't film is a move that could have destroyed the film's credibility entirely. It doesn't. That's the nerve.
Permission slip
Consensus says: The Guardian calls this 'unmissable' in the headline; we agree with the verdict but want to be clear it's not a thriller in the conventional sense — it withholds the satisfactions a thriller would deliver.
What they're missing: Critical consensus is clustering on the Seyfried twist as a spectacle. The more durable case for the film is its formal argument about documentary epistemology, which the 'unmissable' framing undersells.
Lineage tree
The Fog of War (2003)
direct ancestor — the sympathetic interrogator extracting self-justification
Capturing the Friedmans (2003)
structural parallel — mid-film pivot that reframes the entire preceding documentary
The Arbor (2010)
formal precedent — actors re-enacting real speech to expose documentary's limits
The Act of Killing (2012)
tonal influence — perpetrators performing their own story as a route to self-revelation
The Rehearsal (2022)
direct predecessor — Fielder's own practice of building elaborate fictions to access real feeling
Verified Facts (13)
Holmes's US biotech firm Theranos, run jointly with her then partner Sunny Balwani, in 2003 notoriously claimed to have invented a little box that could diagnose all manner of illnesses from a single drop of blood
Its corporate prestige pumped by credulous board members including George Schultz and Henry Kissinger
Fielder was invited by Holmes to spend intimate time with her in 2023 in the weeks before prison
In the rented San Diego beachfront home she shared with her protective new partner Billy Evans
Evans described as a Charlie Kirk enthusiast, with whom she has two small children
Holmes still claims to be innocent
When she switches from contact lenses to glasses for the final car ride to prison
Fielder shows her a clip of Abbott and Costello performing the legendary 'Who's on first' bit
Holmes flinches and sobs when Fielder shows her clips of Amanda Seyfried playing her in the dramatised miniseries The Dropout
Fielder and Oppenheim call up Seyfried and get her to re-enact for the camera conversations with Holmes and Evans which they haven't been able to film
The comparison is made to Andrew Jarecki's Capturing the Friedmans from 2003
The New York Times made the suggestion that Holmes could be playing a role, which she rejects
You Can See Everything is in UK and Irish cinemas from 20 November
More latest news
Read all