
The standout new release this week is Prima Facie, Suzie Miller's stage-to-screen adaptation with Cynthia Erivo carrying the entire film on her back. Peter Bradshaw's phrase 'classical drama' is exactly right — this is the kind of performance that makes you forget there's a camera. The legal procedural frame (a barrister who defends accused rapists until she becomes a victim herself) is a vessel for something much older: the witness who cannot be believed. Whispers in the Woods and 1 in 2 occupy adjacent emotional territory — both are documentary-adjacent works about mortality and inheritance, one ecological, one medical. Vincent Munier's forest film is the quieter achievement: the kind of nature documentary that trusts silence. David Wilkinson's bowel cancer film earns its confessionalism through self-awareness rather than sentimentality. Neither is easy, but both are honest. A Fox Under a Pink Moon is the week's most formally interesting film. Soraya Akhlaghi shot her own refugee journey on a phone over five years, then worked with animators to process what the footage couldn't hold. The result is something between diary, witness testimony, and illustrated memoir — a category the documentary form is still figuring out how to accommodate. Soul Patrol and Give Me the Ball! are more conventional documentary work, competently executed, worth your time if the subject draws you. In the mid-tier, Traces of Justice is the most surprising entry — a Chinese forensic thriller that's honest about its own propaganda content and gripping anyway. Peter Berg's Mosquito Bowl is the most competently made of the three-star group: Berg knows how to stage chaos, and the football-to-combat thematic rhyme lands better in image than in dialogue. Ebenezer is the week's trickiest recommendation — Depp is genuinely funny as Scrooge, the film knows what it is, and that's enough. Fjord and How to Rob a Bank are the week's clear disappointments. Mungiu's child-abuse drama (his second Palme d'Or) is the more painful miss because the talent is undeniable and the material is serious — but Bradshaw's verdict, that it neither blazingly delivers nor intriguingly withholds, is exactly right. The film occupies no position. How to Rob a Bank is simpler: a two-hour anti-capitalist caper that isn't funny or exciting enough to earn either label. The re-releases are the week's real event. The Man Who Fell to Earth (1976) and Female Perversions (1996) are both five-star pieces and both centre on performers — Bowie and Swinton — who were simply doing something that didn't have a category yet. Bradshaw's observation that Bowie's vulnerability looks more authentic now than it did in 1976 is a sharp critical point: some performances age into themselves. Sofia Coppola's Marie Antoinette, also re-released, is the more contested three-star: the anachronistic pop soundtrack is an idea, not a provocation, and the film coasts on that idea without fully committing to it. The week as a whole skews toward documentary and adaptation — only a handful of original fictions in the mix. The strongest work (Prima Facie, A Fox Under a Pink Moon, the two re-releases) is unified by one thing: a performer or creator who had no choice but to make exactly this, in exactly this form.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
72
/100
Cinemagoers who want to spend one evening well this week: see Prima Facie for Erivo, seek out A Fox Under a Pink Moon if you can find it, and prioritise The Man Who Fell to Earth or Female Perversions if you haven't seen them.
Cultural Placement
Like a Sight & Sound annual shortlist filtered through a broadsheet's Friday listings — the week's range runs from Roeg-and-Bowie auteur cinema to a Dickens adaptation starring Johnny Depp. The strongest new work (Prima Facie, A Fox Under a Pink Moon) sits in the tradition of theatre-to-screen adaptations that foreground the performer's body as the primary text, closer to Cassavetes than to prestige television. The re-releases (Roeg, Lizzie Borden) are the week's real argument: 1970s and 1990s outsider cinema that the mainstream is still catching up to.
Honest assessment
This is a strong week anchored by one exceptional performance (Erivo in Prima Facie), one formally interesting documentary (A Fox Under a Pink Moon), and two essential re-releases (Roeg, Borden). The mid-tier is genuine three-star work — worth seeing if the subject draws you, skippable if not. Fjord is the week's real loss: Mungiu's talent produces a film that occupies no position.
What Is NOVEL?
72
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
4/5
Originality
3/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
4/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Prima Facie and A Fox Under a Pink Moon take genuine formal risks — solo performance as film and phone-diary-plus-animation as refugee testimony. The Roeg and Borden re-releases retroactively validate risks that were dismissed on release.
Permission slip
Consensus says: Critical consensus awards Fjord significant prestige on the basis of Mungiu's reputation and Palme d'Or. We score it two stars and say the reputation is not doing enough work here.
What they're missing: A second Palme d'Or is a data point, not a verdict. Bradshaw's review is honest that the film neither delivers nor withholds — that is not a sustainable critical position for a serious subject. Mungiu's best work (4 Months, R.M.N.) is ruthlessly committed. Fjord isn't.
Lineage tree
The Man Who Fell to Earth (1976)
direct ancestor — outsider-performance as auteur text
Female Perversions (1996)
direct ancestor — Swinton's pre-mainstream register
Suzie Miller's stage Prima Facie
direct source — theatrical monologue adapted for screen
Waltz with Bashir (2008)
extends the form of — animation as trauma testimony in documentary
Verified Facts (15)
Prima Facie stars Cynthia Erivo as a lawyer whose career defending rape suspects is undermined by experience
Whispers in the Woods: Director Vincent Munier takes his father and son into the Vosges forest in France
1 in 2: David Wilkinson's film deals with his own bowel cancer treatment
A Fox Under a Pink Moon: Refugee Soraya Akhlaghi filmed her perilous flight from Iran and precarious new life over five years on her phone
Soul Patrol: Story of the US army's first Black special ops team at work in Vietnam
Give Me the Ball! is a documentary about tennis ace Billie Jean King
Ebenezer: Johnny Depp stars as Scrooge in a new version of Dickens' A Christmas Carol
Traces of Justice: Forensic scientist Cui Daozhi, the 'Chinese Sherlock Holmes', is the central figure; directed by Chen Sicheng
The Mosquito Bowl: Peter Berg directs a second world war drama about an American football game before the battle of Okinawa
100 Sunset: Kunsang Kyirong's debut feature follows Kunsel through Toronto's Tibetan community
Fjord: Cristian Mungiu won his second Palme d'Or with this film starring Renate Reinsve and Sebastian Stan
How to Rob a Bank stars Nicholas Hoult, Anna Sawai and Pete Davidson
The Man Who Fell to Earth (1976): David Bowie plays an intergalactic visitor who becomes a successful tech entrepreneur; directed by Nicolas Roeg
Female Perversions (1996): Tilda Swinton's first US film, in which she plays a lawyer in a rework of Madame Bovary
Marie Antoinette: Sofia Coppola's biopic combining dazzling visual tableaux with new wave chart hits from the 1970s and 80s
More latest news
Read all