
Get the book
A Brief History of Pasta
on Guardian Bookshop
In Bologna, ordering spaghetti bolognese is a social experiment. The dish doesn't officially exist there, yet it feeds schoolchildren across Britain, fills jars in Australian supermarkets, and answers to the name of a city that refuses to claim it. That paradox is the engine of Luca Cesari's piece, adapted from his Brief History of Pasta, and it's a good one: a food whose origin story is both more complicated and more interesting than the folklore that replaced it. The Bolognese case against spaghetti bolognese is partly aesthetic, partly territorial, and mostly wrong. Cesari demonstrates this by simply following the recipe trail. Pellegrino Artusi's 1891 maccheroni alla bolognese — the ur-text of ragù — was written for dried durum wheat pasta, not egg tagliatelle. Spaghetti appeared by 1898, in a Turin hotel advertisement. Tagliatelle only became ragù's official partner later, retroactively canonised by the city's food institutions as the authentic vessel. The spaghetti version isn't a corruption of tradition. It's the older pairing. What Cesari does particularly well is trace the two engines that made the dish globally famous. The first is the name. Bologna had been a European byword for quality pork products since the Renaissance — mortadella above all. Thomas Nashe was making Bologna sausage jokes in 1596. English cookbooks were copying mortadella recipes by 1660. The city's name carried prestige across borders centuries before anyone thought to put its ragù on spaghetti. When the pasta dish needed a shorthand that would travel, the brand was already built. The second engine is structural: Bolognese ragù was a genuine democratisation of a richer dish. Neapolitan ragù braised whole joints of veal, the pasta course depending on the drippings while the meat came separately. The Bolognese version swapped the joint for mince — cheaper, faster, no long braise required. Cesari's hamburger analogy is exact: you lose the steak's prestige, gain something everyone can cook on a Tuesday. That practical genius is why the dish spread. It wasn't a dumbed-down imitation of something finer. It was a better-designed product for the actual world. The piece is sharpest when it catches official Italian food culture in its own contradictions. The Accademia Italiana della Cucina's 2018 attempt to register a 'real' spaghetti bolognese — a tinned tuna dish — as a corrective to the ragù version is genuinely funny. In trying to deny that ragù-on-spaghetti exists, they officially handed Bologna a dish that actually comes from Rome and has nothing to do with the city. The cure was more embarrassing than the disease. And the 2019 mayor asking citizens to tweet him spaghetti bolognese sightings in foreign cities — framing tourist menus as a kind of municipal insult — captures exactly how food identity politics can curdle into something a little absurd. Cesari closes with a diplomat's offer: maybe one day Bologna will decide that global name recognition matters more than gatekeeping who gets to use it. It's a generous read. The more structural point, which the piece implies without quite stating, is that popular dishes don't belong to the cities that name them. They belong to the people who cook and eat them, and spag bol has been feeding the world long enough to have earned its own standing. The heresy, it turns out, predates the orthodoxy.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
64
/100
Anyone who has ever been told they're eating or making something 'wrong' by someone who considers themselves a custodian of a food culture — which is most people who cook.
Cultural Placement
Like Mary Beard dismantling classical mythology from the inside, but applied to pasta: Cesari uses archival receipts to make the heretic's case while standing in the heretic's kitchen. Closer in spirit to the revisionist food history of Ken Albala than to the romantic localism of Elizabeth David — this piece argues against terroir-fetishism with dates and primary sources rather than nostalgia. The closest formal cousin is Harold McGee on the gap between culinary folklore and kitchen chemistry: same move of using real evidence to make the official story look sentimental.
Honest assessment
This is a well-executed corrective history that does exactly what it sets out to do: demolish a food myth with primary sources while remaining readable. It doesn't reshape the genre or risk anything structurally, but the core argument is genuinely surprising and the evidence is solid. For food writing, that's a reasonable ambition and Cesari meets it.
What Is NOVEL?
64
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
2/5
Originality
3/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
4/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
No structural risk taken. The argument is counterintuitive but the form is a standard corrective-history essay. Nothing here could have collapsed.
Permission slip
Consensus says: Food press tends to treat pieces like this as charming trivia. We think the structural argument — that popular dishes outgrow their origin cities and deserve independent standing — is the more interesting claim and deserves to be taken seriously.
What they're missing: Most coverage of spag bol debates treats it as a fun culture-clash story. Cesari is actually making a case about how food canonisation works and who benefits from it. That argument is worth following.
Lineage tree
Pellegrino Artusi — Science in the Kitchen (1891)
primary source and direct ancestor of the dish under discussion
Ken Albala — Food in Early Modern Europe
methodological ancestor — using archival sources to overturn food folklore
Harold McGee — On Food and Cooking
tonal influence — amused precision, evidence over romanticism
Mary Beard — SPQR
structural influence — insider using scholarship to dismantle official mythology
Verified Facts (10)
In Bologna, spaghetti bolognese does not exist.
In February 2019 the then mayor, Virginio Merola, asked his fellow citizens on Twitter to send him photos of spaghetti bolognese spotted abroad.
He told journalists it was 'embarrassing to be known around the world for something that doesn't exist'.
In 1596 the pamphleteer Thomas Nashe mocked the poet Barnabe Barnes for strutting about court in 'a codpisse as big as a Bolognian sawcedge'.
By 1660 Robert May's The Accomplisht Cook was already giving a recipe for 'Bolonia Sausages'.
Ragù entered the cookbooks in 1891, when Pellegrino Artusi published his 'Maccheroni alla bolognese' in Science in the Kitchen and the Art of Eating Well.
Spaghetti first appear in 1898, in an advertisement for the Hôtel Ville et Bologne in Turin offering 'Spaghetti di Napoli alla bolognese'.
In 1952, at a fair held at the Royal Festival Hall in London, even the Queen Mother recognised spaghetti bolognese with interest.
When Julia Lovejoy Cuniberti translated Artusi's recipe in 1917 she was already suggesting the sauce for 'macaroni or spaghetti'.
The Accademia Italiana della Cucina had formally registered with Bologna's chamber of commerce a recipe for spaghetti in a tinned tuna sauce, billed as 'Bolognese style'.
More latest news
Read all