
Get the book
The Modern Pie Maker
on Guardian Bookshop
The question is deceptively simple: why does the base stay wet? The honest answer is that there are four independent causes, any one of which will wreck your pie alone, and most soggy-bottom sufferers are committing at least two simultaneously. Start with the filling. Apples contain substantial water already, and that water has to go somewhere during the bake. Calum Franklin — author of The Modern Pie Maker — makes the point plainly: you do not need to add liquid to an apple filling. Cook the apples down with sugar, let them break down, and you've removed the main source of excess moisture before the pastry ever meets it. If you want an additional line of defense, Dee Rettali of Fortitude Bakehouse in London offers her mother's trick: a dry crumble of sugar and flour scattered on the base before the fruit goes in. No fat — just the two dry ingredients — to act as a moisture absorber. It's a belt-and-suspenders approach, and it works. Then there's the heat-conduction problem, which is where most home bakers quietly fail. Ceramic and Pyrex dishes look right for the job but actively work against you: they insulate the base instead of conducting heat into it. Metal tins — perforated ones especially — conduct heat directly to the pastry. The perforations do double duty: they let steam escape rather than trapping it against the base. Rettali also bakes on a preheated baking stone for additional bottom heat. Franklin disagrees: he argues that placing the stone under the tin actually creates a barrier between the tin and the oven's direct heat, and simply puts the tin straight on the rack. Both are credible. Try the rack first. Don't underestimate time. Franklin's observation that published pie recipes consistently understate cooking times is worth taking seriously — home ovens vary, and a large apple pie needs at least 40 minutes. The visual cue that tells you it's done: mahogany color, not pale gold. Pale gold means undercooked pastry. Mahogany means caramelization, which means crispness. And if you're doing an egg wash — Franklin recommends pure yolk, not whole egg, because the white dulls the finish — add demerara sugar on top for crunch. The resting step matters too. Rettali freezes her pastry-lined tin until firm before baking. This sets the dough and allows a longer, more even bake — which, again, is what the base needs most.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
56
/100
Home bakers who have made apple pie at least once and been disappointed by the result — especially those following recipes faithfully and still getting wet pastry.
Cultural Placement
Like the best columns in Samin Nosrat's Salt Fat Acid Heat — where the goal is teaching mechanism, not just transmitting technique — this piece works because it sources expert disagreement honestly. It sits closer to Harold McGee's On Food and Cooking than to a standard recipe column: the question isn't 'what do I do' but 'why does this fail,' and the answers reach into heat conduction and moisture chemistry. The format — reader question answered by multiple practitioners — is as old as newspaper cookery, but it functions here more like a structured debate than a Q&A.
Honest assessment
This is a well-executed piece of practical food journalism — more useful than most recipe headnotes because it explains why failures happen rather than just prescribing steps. The genuine value is in the expert disagreement: Franklin and Rettali diverge on baking stone use, and the piece doesn't fake a resolution. For the total beginner it may feel like too much to hold at once; for the experienced baker it delivers exactly the diagnostic framework needed.
What Is NOVEL?
56
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
2/5
Originality
2/5
Voice
3/5
Endurance
4/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
No formal risk — a newspaper Q&A format with named chefs. The editorial nerve is in letting the two experts contradict each other on baking stone placement rather than papering over it.
Verified Facts (11)
Calum Franklin is the author of The Modern Pie Maker
Dee Rettali is co-founder of Fortitude Bakehouse in London
Franklin recommends pure egg yolk for egg wash, not whole egg, because white makes pastry dull
Franklin tops egg wash with demerara sugar for crunch
Franklin says a large pie will take at least 40 minutes
Franklin recommends looking for a mahogany colour as the doneness cue
Rettali's mother used a dry crumble mix of just sugar and flour, no fat, on the base
Rettali rests dough in the freezer until firm
Rettali bakes on a baking stone in the oven
Franklin disagrees with the baking stone, arguing it puts a barrier between the base and direct heat, and slides the tin straight onto a rack
Franklin says he never thinks pie recipes give the right cooking times and recommends an extra 10 minutes
More latest news
Read all