
The Guardian letters page has always operated as a kind of distributed commons — a place where readers with no platform other than a stamp (or now an email) land genuinely good observations next to genuinely unhinged ones, and the mix is the point. This particular selection from November 2024 is a small masterclass in the form at its best. Lynne Scrimshaw's opener is the purest version of what letters do well: a single deflection, one sentence of setup, one of payoff. Ray Bradbury's 1962 short story 'Boys! Raise Giant Mushrooms in Your Cellar!' is a real thing that exists, it is exactly as alarming as the title suggests, and invoking it in response to a straight news story about invasive species risk is a genuinely funny act of lateral thinking. The letter doesn't explain the story. It doesn't need to. 'If it doesn't send you screaming out of the house' is enough. Caroline Westgate's contribution on cat ownership is the most philosophically precise thing in the section. The observation that you can own a dog but not 'be a cat owner' because a cat will simply relocate if conditions are unsatisfactory is not new — this joke has been made many times — but the second sentence lifts it. 'Putting its food in an inaccessible transparent box will certainly accelerate it relocating to where the humans are more compliant.' That word 'compliant' is doing a lot of work. The cat is not leaving because it is unhappy. It is leaving because you have failed to meet its standards of service. Dave Harris, also 83, delivers the section's most purely nostalgic entry: stink bombs, the words 'The biggest stink since Hitler' on the packet, and the phrase 'antisocial but hilarious,' which is both an accurate description and a minor work of self-awareness. The 'also 83' is the joke. Someone else wrote in at 83 and Dave wants you to know the cohort is well-represented. Mark Newbury's letter — four lines about why he has read the Guardian for nearly 50 years, prompted by a previous letter suggesting that Bungo the Womble might also have been Led Zeppelin's drummer — is the section's most formally perfect entry. It performs the exact thing it describes. And Cherry Weston closes with a crossword setter joke that lands clean: the evidence of 'choo choo,' 'gee gee,' and 'moo cow' as puzzle solutions points not to old age but to developmental infancy. The logic is airtight.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
56
/100
Anyone who reads newspapers and has ever wondered why the letters page is the last thing they read before closing the tab. Also: Bradbury completists who somehow missed the mushroom story.
Cultural Placement
Like the best of the New Yorker's 'Briefly Noted' section crossed with a pub conversation that somehow keeps getting funnier, with the structural economy of Clive James at his most compressed. The letters page as a form owes something to Samuel Johnson's correspondents and something to Twitter's ratio of terrible-to-brilliant, but it operates on different rules: the editor curates, the reader trusts the curation, and the result is a collective voice no single writer could produce. This particular selection sits closer to the Alan Bennett diary-entry end of the British wit tradition than to anything polemical — small observations, maximum compression, earned laugh.
Honest assessment
Five short letters, none longer than four sentences, collectively funnier and more precise than most 1,500-word features published the same day. The form rewards exactly this — no one letter could carry a full piece, but together they perform something a column cannot. The Bradbury reference alone is worth the thirty seconds this takes to read.
What Is NOVEL?
56
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
2/5
Originality
2/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
No formal risk taken. Letters to a newspaper are the safest possible form. The nerve is in the compression, not the ambition — each writer risked only mild embarrassment.
Verified Facts (7)
Ray Bradbury's 1962 short story is titled 'Boys! Raise Giant Mushrooms in Your Cellar!'
Letter writers identified as: Lynne Scrimshaw (London), Caroline Westgate (Hexham, Northumberland), Dave Harris (also 83, Potters Bar, Hertfordshire), Mark Newbury (Farndale, North Yorkshire), Cherry Weston (Wolverhampton)
Dave Harris describes himself as 'also 83', referencing a previous correspondent Bob Hely (Letters, 15 November)
Mark Newbury references a previous letter suggesting 'Bungo the Womble might also have been Led Zeppelin's drummer' (Letters, 12 November)
Cherry Weston references a previous letter surmising the quick crossword setter is older than 85 (Letters, 12 November)
Crossword solutions cited as evidence: 'choo choo,' 'gee gee,' and 'moo cow'
The original news report referenced is dated 16 November: 'Mushroom lovers in UK told to avoid grow kits owing to invasive species risk'
More latest news
Read all