
Get the book
Love is a Pink Cake
on Guardian Bookshop
There's a particular kind of food writing that works by invitation rather than instruction, and this piece does it well. The author — a Brit who has no ancestral claim to Thanksgiving — builds her argument not through cultural theory but through the specific pleasures of brining a bird and agonising over marshmallow-versus-praline on sweet potato casserole. The holiday becomes a vessel for something simpler: a November dinner with friends when the days have turned dark and you need a reason to lay a table. The recipe choices are genuinely considered. Margot Henderson's buttermilk and harissa brine is a smart left turn from American convention — aromatic and North African-inflected where the original tends toward salt and sugar. Joël Robuchon's mashed potatoes are, as advertised, the most buttered thing you can legally serve, and citing him here is a little joke the reader is in on: Robuchon's recipe calls for roughly one-to-one potato-to-butter, a ratio that takes courage to commit to at the table. Hetty McKinnon's green bean tahini casserole is the shrewdest pick. The classic American version — cream of mushroom soup from a can, french-fried onions from a tin — is the dish most likely to confuse a British guest. McKinnon's version swaps the industrial base for tahini and lemon, keeping the structural logic (creamy, topped, baked) while making it something you'd actually want to eat. Meera Sodha's vegan pumpkin pie with maple caramelised pecans handles the dessert slot without martyrdom, which is harder than it sounds. The writing is warmest in the asides. The author's preference for cockerel at Christmas freeing her up to do turkey at Thanksgiving is a nice bit of domestic logic, the kind of detail that tells you this person actually cooks. Brian Levy's Derby date pie — bourbon, bitter chocolate, medjool dates, pecan — is slipped in almost parenthetically, as if she doesn't want to oversell it, which makes you want it more. The 'My Week in Food' section at the end shifts register to newsletter column mode, and the seams show slightly. Anja Dunk's reissued Advent baking book, Claire Ptak's tequila pumpkin pie from Violet Cakes (London-centric, she acknowledges), and Barti Welsh cream liqueur (dairy-free, coconut-based, serve over ice) are all fine recommendations. But they sit in a different key from the essay above — less argued, more listed. The piece is better when it's making a case than when it's doing a round-up.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
48
/100
Home cooks in the UK (or anywhere outside the US) who want a coherent, non-clichéd approach to a Thanksgiving-style dinner without the nostalgia baggage — especially those already familiar with Meera Sodha, Hetty McKinnon, or the broader Guardian feast universe.
Cultural Placement
Like Nigel Slater's Kitchen Diaries but more pragmatic, with the cross-cultural recipe promiscuity of Yotam Ottolenghi and the warm-but-unsentimental hosting philosophy of April Bloomfield. This isn't food writing as memoir or as performance — it's the kind of column that functions as a well-curated friend's recommendation list, light on ego and heavy on specifics. The Thanksgiving frame is a vehicle for a broader argument about seasonal eating and the arbitrary lines we draw around which traditions belong to us.
Honest assessment
This is a well-executed food column doing exactly what it sets out to do: make Thanksgiving feel accessible and reclaimable by non-Americans, with recipe suggestions specific enough to actually use. It doesn't transcend the form, and the newsletter tail is visibly thinner than the essay head. But the core argument — borrow the best bits, make them yours, don't overthink it — is delivered with enough warmth and specificity to earn its November slot.
What Is NOVEL?
48
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
2/5
Originality
2/5
Voice
3/5
Endurance
2/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
No structural risk taken. The 'outsider embraces foreign holiday' frame is well-worn Guardian territory. The move is to make it warm and specific rather than conceptually bold.
Lineage tree
Nigel Slater — Kitchen Diaries
tonal influence: seasonal, diary-mode, domestic specificity
Nigel Slater — Tender
tonal influence: cosy, British, produce-led
Felicity Cloake — Perfect column
direct ancestor: Guardian food, recipe testing as editorial form
Yotam Ottolenghi
extends the form of: cross-cultural ingredient promiscuity normalised for British readers
Verified Facts (10)
Margot Henderson's buttermilk and harissa brine cited for turkey
Joël Robuchon's mashed potatoes described as 'best mashed potatoes in the world'
Hetty McKinnon's green bean tahini casserole cited
Felicity Cloake's perfect sweet potato casserole with pecan praline and marshmallow topping cited
Meera Sodha's vegan pumpkin pie with caramelised maple pecans cited
Brian Levy's Derby date pie described as containing bourbon, bitter chocolate, medjool dates and pecan topping
Benjamina Ebuehi's miso pecan cookies recommended as giftable treat
Anja Dunk's book Advent reissued with new festive red cover, described as filled with daily Christmas bakes and lino prints
Claire Ptak's tequila pumpkin pie available to pre-order from Violet Cakes; recipe also in Love is a Pink Cake
Barti cream liqueur described as Welsh, coconut-based, dairy-free, with gentle spices and vanilla
More latest news
Read all