
Get the book
Jane Grigson's Fruit Book
on Guardian Bookshop
Standing on a London Tube platform, Rachel Roddy watches a grey creature dart under the tracks and delivers a small urban-myth autopsy before pivoting, with characteristic precision, to plums. The move is not random. The whole point of this recipe — and of Gianluca Gorini's La Cucina Radicale from which it draws — is that proximity matters: to ingredients, to history, to the idea that the thing in your hedgerow and the thing in your pantry are more alike than you assumed. Gorini, chef at DaGorini in San Piero in Bagno, Emilia-Romagna, found that wild plums and tomatoes share more than a smooth, thin skin. Jane Grigson clocked the same symmetry in her Fruit book years earlier. What Gorini did was cook from the observation rather than just note it: wild plums plus tomato water, pushed through a mill, simmered with chilli and garlic, produces a sauce that behaves exactly like a good pomodoro — sweet, acidic, clingy, assertive. Roddy's domestic version pares the technique back to what a home kitchen can support. Red onion softened in olive oil, firm red plums and a single ripe tomato collapsed into a chunky sauce over fifteen minutes, finished with a splash of red-wine vinegar, then passed through a food mill. The chilli and garlic go in separately, in a sizzle of oil, before the smooth plum sauce joins them. It is a two-pan dish that runs about thirty minutes start to finish and demands nothing except that you use plums that are firm enough to hold some acidity. The historical argument underneath the recipe is worth sitting with. When Italian cooks first encountered the tomato — a gold or red fruit from the Americas, arriving in meaningful culinary quantities by the early 1800s — they made a sweet, gently acidic sauce from it. What they were doing, Roddy implies, was treating it like a plum: same flesh logic, same flavour logic. Gorini's inversion runs the film backwards. The plum-as-tomato is not a novelty stunt; it is a reminder that the tomato was always a kind of plum that happened to arrive from the wrong continent. Roddy heads off the obvious objection herself: yes, this does taste like pasta with fruit sauce. So does pasta with tomato sauce, once you think about it. The sweetness is met by vinegar, chilli, and parsley; the parmesan is optional but recommended. Use penne, mezze maniche, rigatoni, or fusilli — anything with ridges or tubes that will hold the sauce. The recipe serves four and the ingredient list is short enough to memorise. The piece works as well as it does because Roddy never oversells the idea. She does not claim this is radical home cooking or that you will never look at tomatoes the same way again. She locates the recipe in a real chef's real book, cites a real food writer's observation, recounts a real (if misremembered) London anecdote, and gives you a dish. The writing earns its digressions because they are load-bearing: the rat-and-mouse opening is about proximity and misperception, which is exactly what the recipe is about.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
72
/100
Home cooks who want to understand why a dish works, not just how to execute it; readers interested in food history; anyone who already makes arrabbiata and wants a genuinely different take on the same flavour logic.
Cultural Placement
Like Elizabeth David's Mediterranean essays but rooted in a single recipe rather than a region, with the structural curiosity of Harold McGee and the domestic plainness of Nigel Slater. Roddy occupies the same lane as the best British-Italian food writing — Marcella Hazan filtered through a Roman market — but her best pieces, like this one, work as provocation: the cooking is the argument, not the illustration.
Honest assessment
This is a column-length piece doing essay-level work inside a recipe format. The Gorini connection elevates it beyond the weekly slot; Roddy's restraint keeps it from tipping into pretension. If you cook it without reading it, you get a good dinner. If you read it without cooking it, you get a good argument. Ideally do both.
What Is NOVEL?
72
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
3/5
Originality
4/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
4/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Modest formal risk — a fruit-as-tomato arrabbiata could read as gimmick, and Roddy anticipates the objection rather than avoiding it. The urban-myth opening earns its keep rather than coasting on charm.
Lineage tree
Jane Grigson's Fruit Book
direct ancestor — cited explicitly; the plum-tomato symmetry observation originates here
Marcella Hazan
tonal influence — the authority of simplicity, refusal to over-explain
Elizabeth David
formal ancestor — the essay-within-a-recipe structure
Gianluca Gorini, La Cucina Radicale
immediate source material — the original Gorini dish and the radical-roots philosophy
Verified Facts (6)
Dr David Cowan's research estimated proximity to rats at anything from 10ft to 164ft, not the mythologised six feet
Gianluca Gorini is chef at his restaurant in San Piero in Bagno, Emilia-Romagna
The recipe is included in Gorini's book La Cucina Radicale (Radical Cuisine)
Jane Grigson compares plums and tomatoes in her Fruit book, specifically their flesh and smooth, thin skins
The recipe serves 4 and uses 300g firm red plums, 400g pasta, 1 ripe fleshy tomato, 1 tbsp red-wine vinegar
Italian cooks turned tomatoes into sweet, gently acidic sauce in the early 1800s
More latest news
Read all