
Listen
Vogue
on YouTube
The Confessions II video opens on a chair. Not a throne, not a prop — a chair with a posture that says 'I'm listening, but I'm bored by most of what I hear.' That tension — between openness and dominance, between vulnerability and absolute control — is what the whole 10 minutes is running on. The satin corset and pointy stilettos are the classic dominatrix shorthand, but the body language complicates it deliberately. This is not power as intimidation. It's power as indifference to your opinion of her power. The shorthand nickname — 'the vagina laser video' — will stick the way 'pointy tits' stuck to Vogue, and for the same reason: the image is both irreducibly silly and completely correct. The green lights shooting from vulvas and occasionally butts are orgone energy, life force, desire as the primary mover. The argument is the same one Madonna has been making since 1984 — power lives in wanting, not in being wanted — but the visual vocabulary has been updated from Jean Paul Gaultier's military hardware bra to something that looks like a rave crossed with a gynecology textbook. The upgrade works. The casting is the structural move. Sabrina Carpenter appears not as heir apparent but as a figure in the same strobe-lit space — the choreography creates genuine confusion about who you're watching, amplified when Julia Garner is spliced in looking like Madonna's Marilyn-era self. This is not a baton pass. It's a meditation on the metaphysics of clubbing: the dissolution of self in the crowd, the bliss of 'I'm completely here and I don't know whose face that is.' Kate Moss does her lipstick as 'Hide the cocaine' plays. Nobody explains anything. You're not meant to ask. Gwendoline Christie's presence is the video's subtlest move. The setup — prim figure introduced into debauched scene — should produce mockery, the classic mechanism for containing the transgressive by making the shocked observer the audience's surrogate. It doesn't work that way here. Christie is fully absorbed into the organism. Nobody is mocking Brienne of Tarth. The communitarian atmosphere is genuine: there is room for the Glyndebourne crowd and the G-string crowd and they are not in opposition. Odessa A'Zion's gen-Z grumpiness, Debi Mazar looking more snatched than ever, the unisex-or-not toilets — same principle. The film's politics are enacted, not stated. Benedict Cumberbatch looks like a man who got dressed thinking he was going to show a couple round an overpriced two-bedroomed flat. Whether this is acting or genuine disorientation doesn't matter — Madonna grabs him by the jaw in long blue gloves and makes him dance anyway. The film ends with Lourdes, maskless among the futuristic gimp-masked camera crew, deploying her boredom as a weapon: 'Cut, bitch.' Then everyone eats bananas. The Guardian's read — that the banana is the universal parenting language for a daughter in a bad mood — is probably right. It's also funnier than anything suggestive would have been.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
72
/100
Anyone who has ever argued about whether pop can be art, and anyone who was there for the 1990s Madonna and wants to see the argument 30 years later, refined and unrepentant.
Cultural Placement
Like the Vogue video (1990) but more communitarian and less hierarchical, with the controlled provocation of Matthew Barney's Cremaster cycle compressed into a club-night runtime. The mechanism is the same as Björk's Homogenic-era videos: imagery that operates as philosophical argument rather than narrative illustration. Where Vogue was a manifesto about aspiration and transformation, Confessions II is a manifesto about desire as generative force — and it's made by someone who has had 35 years to sharpen the argument.
Honest assessment
Confessions II is not a reinvention — Madonna is not trying to invent a new form, she's executing a very specific and very hers version of an existing one at a high level. The 10-minute runtime earns itself: there's no filler, the casting choices are all doing work, and the central argument (desire as life force, power as indifference to judgment) lands. What it achieves is rarer than novelty: total, unmistakable authorial voice in a medium that usually dissolves it.
What Is NOVEL?
72
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
3/5
Originality
3/5
Voice
5/5
Endurance
4/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Moderate risk for a mainstream pop release, high risk for a 66-year-old artist in 2026. The 10-minute runtime and Tribeca debut bypass the algorithmic pop machine entirely. It could have been dismissed as self-indulgent. It wasn't.
Permission slip
Consensus says: Critical consensus treats this primarily as a cultural event and a statement about Madonna's longevity. We're treating it as a craft object with a specific argument.
What they're missing: The longevity framing ('she's still got it') undersells what's actually happening. The video isn't evidence of survival — it's evidence of a consistent 40-year philosophical project about desire and power, executed here with more compositional control than most of the coverage acknowledges.
Verified Facts (10)
Madonna's new video is called Confessions II because it's the follow-up to her album Confessions on a Dance Floor, released in 2005
a 10-minute video that brought the house down at the Tribeca festival and has since been watched more than a million times on YouTube
the Vogue video came by 'pointy tits' after the Jean Paul Gaultier bra, itself modelled on the 40s bullet bra
Sabrina Carpenter appears giving off very much her own vibe
Julia Garner gets spliced in, looking very like Madonna in her Marilyn days
Kate Moss doing her lipstick coincides with the line 'Hide the cocaine'
Debi Mazar is there looking more snatched than ever
One cameraperson is maskless and it is Lourdes
ending the film with a magisterial: 'Cut, bitch.'
Daniel Bergner's book about the omnivorous female libido, What Do Women Want
More latest news
Read all