
Listen
BBCSO/Oramo – Enescu, Bartók, Brahms
on BBC Sounds
Inmo Yang is the kind of violinist critics reach for superlatives to describe, and mostly those superlatives are earned. His opening paragraph of Bartók's Violin Concerto No. 1 — a long, winding statement for solo violin — arrived with exactly the poise and suppleness his reputation promises. The tone was sweet, tender, almost retro in its lyricism. He is, without question, still on the rise. But here's the thing: Yang played the concerto in cursive. Lovely, immaculate cursive — and nothing else. The performance was monochromatic in its earnestness. Every phrase was beautiful; none of them bit. Humour, darkness, the sudden flash of something feral — these came not from Yang but from the orchestra behind him. Oramo's brass flurries, the bright harp pinpricks, the deliciously unbuttoned rustic string playing: these were the charismatic moments in a concerto that has plenty of room for them. The BBCSO stealing the limelight from a headline soloist is not an accident — it is, in fact, the story of the whole evening. When Yang left the stage, the orchestra had still more room, and used it. The Brahms First Symphony under Oramo was gleamingly translucent: contrabassoon and double basses audible at the bottom end in ways that rarely happen, woodwind solos sculpted, the string pizzicato at the finale's opening landing with the kind of precision that stops an audience cold. The opener, Enescu's Romanian Rhapsody No. 1, was a different animal entirely — which is to say, Oramo was visibly possessed. The review's description of his conducting manner is worth quoting in full: head bobs and hip wiggles, arms whirling like windscreen wipers in a downpour, hands rippling like jellyfish, nursery-school marching shading into full air traffic control. This is a conductor who commits. The music matched the gesture: ultra-lush strings one moment, tipsy village band the next, trumpets sounding as if they'd escaped from a local big top. Ten minutes of kitsch, and absolutely correct. The BBCSO is one of those institutions the British classical music ecosystem depends on while mostly forgetting to notice. Evenings like this are worth marking not just as good concerts but as evidence of what a fully resourced, long-tenured chief conductor relationship looks like when it's firing. Oramo has been with the orchestra since 2013. That shows — not in familiarity's comfort but in the ability to take risks together. The Bartók rubato, the Brahms transparency, the Enescu abandon: these are choices you make when you trust each other.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
60
/100
BBC Sounds subscribers with a passing interest in whether British orchestras still have something to say; anyone who wants to hear what a twelve-year conductor-orchestra relationship actually sounds like in performance.
Cultural Placement
Like a Carlos Kleiber concert film more than a Perlman recital — this evening was about the ensemble intelligence behind the soloist, not the soloist themselves. Oramo's BBCSO sits in the tradition of Haitink's Concertgebouw and Rattle's Berlin Philharmonic partnerships: long-tenured, trust-built, capable of taking the room somewhere a pick-up ensemble cannot. Yang's Bartók lands closer to Hilary Hahn's immaculate formalism than to Isabelle Faust's interpretive restlessness — polished to a shine, but not argumentative.
Honest assessment
This was a very good concert that became notable for the wrong reasons — Yang's restraint left the BBCSO room to show what they can do, and they took it. The Brahms sounds like a recording worth seeking out if it materialises; the Bartók is a pleasant evening that could have been more. The Enescu opener is ten minutes of unambiguous joy.
What Is NOVEL?
60
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
3/5
Originality
3/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
2/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Oramo's physical commitment and the decision to let the orchestra dominate a concerto night is a real interpretive risk. Yang's choice to stay lyrical and not bite back is either restraint or a missed chance — the review reads it as the latter.
Permission slip
Consensus says: The review headline positions Yang as phenomenal; we're saying the orchestra was the story. The critical consensus around Yang is very warm.
What they're missing: Yang's technique is not in question. The interpretive choice — lyrical cursive throughout, no darkness or bite — is a limitation in this repertoire on this night, and the review's own prose makes the case while hedging the verdict.
Verified Facts (5)
Korean violinist Inmo Yang made his UK debut with the BBC Symphony Orchestra and their chief conductor Sakari Oramo three years ago
The programme included Bartók's early Violin Concerto No 1, Brahms' Symphony No 1, and Enescu's Romanian Rhapsody No 1
The concert is available on BBC Sounds until 9 December
Oramo's podium manner described as: head bobs and hip wiggles, arms whirling like windscreen wipers in a downpour and hands rippling like jellyfish
Yang's first major competition win was more than a decade ago
More latest news
Read all