
Listen
Not All Those Who Wander Are Lost
on Spotify
Anna Lapwood's *Not All Those Who Wander Are Lost* began with a fan request and ended with a year of ear transcription, a Norwegian cathedral, and a choir singing in Elvish. That backstory is worth knowing because it shapes what the album is — a genuinely personal project, not a licensed prestige release. Lapwood transcribed nearly the entire Howard Shore score by ear, reshaped it into a three-movement symphony, and performed it live on the Nidaros Cathedral organ in Trondheim. The ambition is real and the commitment is total. The album works best where the organ works best: in darkness. The music of Sauron and the Ringwraiths slots into the Widor–Boëllmann–Vierne gothic tradition as if it was always meant to be there, because structurally it kind of was. Shore's chromatic, modal writing for the forces of Mordor translates to the instrument's natural menace without strain. Lapwood's finger- and foot-work are precise throughout, and the Nidaros Cathedral Girls' Choir provide ethereal texture that earns its place. The Shire is harder. Shore's folky, pentatonic warmth — built for strings, tin whistle, and acoustic intimacy — resists the organ's weight and scale. Lapwood performs a handful of songs live while playing, in Tolkien's Elvish, which is a feat worth acknowledging, but the results in these passages are convincing rather than transporting. The reviewer's note that she could afford to let rip more often rings true: the instrument's full dynamic range isn't always deployed where the story calls for it. The fillers complicate the picture. A suite from *Pirates of the Caribbean* lands as curiously sedate — odd given that franchise's appetite for bombast — and a *How to Train Your Dragon* number leans heavily into emotional obviousness. These tracks suggest the album is partly padding a runtime rather than completing an argument. At 38 minutes for the main symphony, the case for including them is thin. So: who is this for? Soundtrack completists probably pass — the organ introduces enough tonal displacement that this isn't a substitute listen for Shore's original. Classical organ enthusiasts may find the material too populist. What remains is a genuine niche: Lapwood fans and Tolkien devotees who want to hear a skilled, committed organist make a personal statement about music she loves. That's a real audience. The album earns its place for them without pretending to be for everyone else.
Worth reading?
OPTIONAL
Score
56
/100
Lapwood fans and committed Tolkien devotees who want to hear Howard Shore's score reclaimed for the instrument its darkest passages already belong to. Casual soundtrack listeners and classical organ purists should look elsewhere.
Cultural Placement
Like Marcel Dupré's transcriptions of Bach for organ but pointed at a 21st-century film score instead of the Baroque canon — Lapwood situates herself in the long tradition of organists claiming non-organ repertoire for their instrument. The closest parallel is Keith Jarrett's classical crossover projects: technically immaculate, personally felt, and built for a specific fan overlap rather than a broad audience. The gothic register owes its success to the same late-Romantic lineage (Widor, Vierne, Boëllmann) that Shore himself drew from when scoring Mordor — Lapwood is effectively returning the music to its ancestral home. The Shire material is where that homecoming breaks down.
Honest assessment
This is a passion project that earns its ambition in its strongest moments — the Mordor and Ringwraith sequences feel genuinely right on this instrument — and reveals its limits in the softer ones. The filler tracks dilute the central argument. Worth hearing for the audience it's actually made for; not trying to be anything beyond that.
What Is NOVEL?
56
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
3/5
Originality
3/5
Voice
3/5
Endurance
2/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Real but bounded risk. Transcribing Shore by ear and performing live in Elvish while playing organ is genuinely hard. The nerve is in the execution, not the concept — no structural form is threatened.
Permission slip
Consensus says: The review is warmer than this verdict. We're more skeptical of the filler tracks and the Shire limitations than the source text's 'Lapwood fans need not hesitate' framing implies.
What they're missing: The filler tracks (Pirates of the Caribbean, How to Train Your Dragon) represent a real coherence problem the review acknowledges but doesn't weight heavily enough. This isn't an OPTIONAL for all Lapwood fans — it's essential for the subset who want this specific Tolkien argument.
Verified Facts (7)
Lapwood transcribed all but one segment by ear
The symphony spans 38 minutes across three movements
Songs performed live in Tolkien's Elvish dialect
Recorded on the Nidaros Cathedral organ in Trondheim, Norway
The Nidaros Cathedral Girls' Choir performed on the album
Filler tracks include a suite from Pirates of the Caribbean and a number from How to Train Your Dragon
The project began when a fan requested she play Concerning Hobbits from The Lord of the Rings
More latest news
Read all