
Get tickets
Mid Wales Opera – Puccini's Gianni Schicchi
on Borough Theatre Abergavenny
Puccini wrote Gianni Schicchi as the finale of Il Trittico — his only comedy, and a sharp one. The premise is a 13th-century con: a crowd of greedy Florentine relatives recruit a sharp-witted rogue to impersonate their just-deceased uncle and dictate a new will, only for the rogue to cut them all out and keep the best for himself. Dante condemned the historical Schicchi to hell for exactly this. Puccini let him walk free. The moral ambiguity is the whole point, and Mid Wales Opera's SmallStages production leans straight into it. Director Richard Studer's design makes a virtue of the intimate touring format. Deep purple drapes, tasselled upholstery, and a gilded bed signal medieval Florentine wealth; contemporary black suits on the cast cut an edge of mafioso cool. The commedia dell'arte DNA is played hard — Pavarotti handkerchiefs waved in theatrical mourning, relatives erupting in remonstration on discovering they'd been swindled out of their swindle. It borders on farce and doesn't apologize for it. Music director Jonathan Lyness's reduction of Puccini's orchestral score to piano trio, flute, and bassoon is the production's shrewdest move. It strips the opera to its structural wit and lets the ensemble breathe on stage alongside the singers, so the conspiracy feels genuinely intimate — like being locked in the room with these people. The score's playfulness survives the reduction intact. Timothy Nelson's Schicchi is flamboyantly roguish: the striptease out of his own clothes into the dead man's nightshirt, the baritone voice consciously dropped to a 94-year-old croak for the will-dictation scene. Georgia May Bishop's Zita is feisty and sharp. Wyn Pencarreg's Simone carries authoritative diction. Jennifer Clark's Lauretta is suitably demure. The ensemble is tight; the characterisations are outsized in precisely the right way for a comedy that's playing to church halls and small theatres on a touring circuit. The second half — a cabaret of Italian operatic numbers functioning as a musical grand tour — lets the company's voices stretch again individually. Samuel Pantcheff's closing Buona Sera is suave. Nelson reaffirms the charm he built through the main work. It's a crowd-pleaser structured as an encore, and Mid Wales Opera has earned the right to structure it that way. The context matters. This company has had half its funding summarily withdrawn and is still on the road, still producing work at this level. The sheer operational nerve of running a touring opera company in the Welsh Marches under those conditions is itself a kind of Schicchi move — finding a way through that the funders didn't anticipate. The guts of the production and the guts of the company's survival story are running in parallel, and both deserve attention.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
56
/100
Opera-goers in the Welsh Marches or Abergavenny area who want Puccini without a full-house budget — and anyone curious what intelligent small-scale touring opera looks and sounds like when the company pulls it off.
Cultural Placement
Like Peter Brook's stripped-back theatre experiments but applied to Puccini, with the comedic precision of a commedia dell'arte troupe and the resource discipline of a chamber ensemble. This sits in the tradition of intelligent touring reductions — closer to Glyndebourne on Tour's ethos than to full-house grand opera — where constraint is turned into a production argument. The five-instrument ensemble puts it in conversation with Opera North's small-scale touring work, though the cabaret second half gives it a warmer, more variety-hall feel than either.
Honest assessment
This isn't a production that reinvents Gianni Schicchi or breaks new staging ground — it doesn't need to. What it does is read the opera accurately (a moral comedy about a con artist conning a family of would-be con artists) and stage it with physical precision, genuine wit, and a vocal ensemble that holds up. The score reduction is smart, Nelson's Schicchi is legitimately charming, and the company's survival under funding cuts gives the whole evening an extra charge.
What Is NOVEL?
56
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
3/5
Originality
2/5
Voice
3/5
Endurance
2/5
Lineage
4/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Real risk in the reduction: stripping Puccini to piano trio, flute and bassoon could have gutted the score. It didn't — Lyness made the constraint a feature, not an apology.
Lineage tree
Puccini – Il Trittico (1918)
direct ancestor — this is the source opera, staged with fidelity to its comedic intent
Commedia dell'arte
structural ancestor — the character archetypes and physical comedy register derive directly from this tradition
Peter Brook's stripped theatre
tonal influence — the aesthetic of making constraint a production statement rather than an apology
Opera North small-scale touring
direct predecessor in the UK touring chamber-opera tradition
Verified Facts (11)
In Dante's Inferno, Gianni Schicchi de' Cavalcanti was consigned to the eighth circle of hell for having been an arch-impostor
Gianni Schicchi is the last of the Il Trittico triptych
Director Richard Studer's design mixed deep purple, tasselled drapes and a gilded bed with contemporary black suits for the cast of 10
Music director Jonathan Lyness's reduction was for piano trio, flute and bassoon
Timothy Nelson portrayed Schicchi, described as having a warmly expressive baritone
Georgia May Bishop played Zita
Wyn Pencarreg played Simone
Jennifer Clark sang Lauretta
Samuel Pantcheff closed the evening with Buona Sera
The company had half its funding summarily withdrawn
Performances at St Andrew's Church, Presteigne on 18 November and the Borough, Abergavenny on 19 November
More latest news
Read all