
Get it
Not AI's To Take
on Official site
CREATIVE INDUSTRY AT RISK
$70B
WORKERS AFFECTED
600,000
ELTON'S FIRST ARIA
1987
LEGISLATION EXPECTED
Late 2026
The Not AI's To Take campaign launched this week with a rare coalition: News Corp and Guardian Australia on the same billboard, Peter Garrett and Paul Kelly on the same stage, Elton John on video at the Aria awards. The campaign is demanding that the Albanese government protect existing copyright law rather than carve out exceptions for AI companies seeking to train on creative works without payment or consent. When a campaign successfully unites outlets that normally oppose each other on nearly everything else, the underlying interest alignment is structural, not political.
Extraction Map
The numbers at stake are not trivial. The campaign warns that changes demanded by AI companies could put a $70 billion creative industry and 600,000 workers at risk. That figure covers recording, writing, publishing, film, television, and media industries — the full stack of creative production. What the campaign is actually protecting is the licensing infrastructure that makes professional creative work economically viable: the system by which creators are compensated when their work is used commercially. The industry's ask is straightforward: reimbursement and consultation before AI companies use Australian creative works for training. AI companies have pushed back with two arguments. First, that individual licensing deals are operationally too difficult under existing copyright law. Second, that they need 'legal certainty' on copyright before investing in Australian infrastructure. Anthropic has floated an opt-out model — scrape everything unless a rightsholder explicitly objects. That inverts the standard consent framework, shifting the burden of protection from the user of the work to the creator of it. Prime Minister Albanese has said publicly that failing to pay creators would constitute 'theft' and that artists 'need to be compensated.' His attorney general's office pledged that any changes would 'deliver meaningful control and fair compensation.' But the legislative package is not expected until late 2026 or early 2027, and the gap between political language and enforceable law is precisely where opt-out models and weaker protections tend to get inserted. The campaign's urgency is partly about preventing that gap from being filled by industry lobbying before Parliament acts. The deeper structural argument was made most sharply by Dobby at the Aria ceremony: 'It is not just lyrics and songs from Yothu Yindi, Missy Higgins, Gurrumul and Jimmy Barnes — you'll be handing over Elton John, Beyoncé and the Beatles' work too.' Australia is not being asked to decide only about Australian artists. It is being asked whether its copyright framework will serve as a global precedent — a 'weak link,' in Dobby's framing, that AI companies can exploit to establish training norms that then propagate worldwide. If Australia legislates an opt-out model, that becomes a template other jurisdictions face pressure to match. Miss Kannina's red-carpet comments cut to the political economy underneath: 'The Australian government doesn't care about anybody but the billionaires, and they don't care about artists especially.' That framing reflects a reasonable prior about whose interests tend to win when large technology companies with significant capital lobby governments for regulatory carve-outs. The campaign's coalition-building — getting industry bodies, legacy media, and musicians onto the same platform — is a direct counter to that dynamic, raising the political cost of a quiet capitulation. The Albanese government now faces a decision with 20-year consequences. Legislate meaningful prior consent and licensing requirements and Australian creative workers maintain the economic floor that makes professional creative work possible. Accept an opt-out model or create copyright exceptions under AI industry pressure, and the precedent is set: creative output is a training commons, compensation is optional, and the value flows to model owners rather than the humans whose work made those models useful. Tim Minchin's formulation at the Aria podium — 'This will only remain true if we assert it as true and act accordingly' — is the accurate description of what is at stake.
Worth reading?
OPTIONAL
Score
44
/100
Extractive — AI companies seek to absorb the accumulated creative output of 600,000 workers as a free input, concentrating the resulting value in model owners while externalising the cost onto creators.
What Is GRIN?
GRIN stands for Generativity, Resilience, Innovation efficiency, and Novelty openness. These four dimensions capture the essential characteristics of any memetic intelligence — whether a nation, a corporation, a religion, or a movement.
About GRINGenerativity
2/5
Resilience
2/5
Efficiency
2/5
Novelty
4/5
Extractive
4/5
Inverted
Does this create new capability or just redistribute existing value?
No new creative capacity is generated by removing consent requirements. Value is redistributed from creators to model owners. The generative upside of AI exists regardless of whether training is paid or free.
Verified Facts (8)
Elton John hosted the very first Aria awards ceremony in 1987
The Not AI's To Take campaign warns that changes demanded by AI giants could put the $70bn creative industry and its 600,000 workers at risk
Anthropic has put forward an 'opt-out' model to scrape creative works unless a rightsholder objected
The government is expected to unveil a long-awaited legislative package on AI in late 2026 or early 2027
Australian musicians Jack River, Dobby, Josh Pyke and KLP addressed the room at Sydney's Hordern Pavilion on behalf of Not AI's To Take
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has declared it would be 'theft' if creatives weren't paid for their work
Bluey composer Joff Bush won the award for best children's album
The campaign is supported by News Corp, Foxtel, Seven Media and Guardian Australia
More latest news
Read all