
When Dame Felicity Lott died in May this year, the lieder world lost its most reliable intelligence. Not the most thrilling voice of her generation, not the most dramatic — but the most consistently trustworthy. You could follow her into any song in any language and know that nothing would be faked, nothing exaggerated, nothing wasted. That is rarer than it sounds. This 10-CD Hyperion boxset, curated by Graham Johnson — who first recruited Lott for The Songmakers' Almanac in 1976 — covers roughly fifty years of recording and amounts to an argument: that Lott was one of the great song interpreters of the twentieth century, not merely a distinguished soprano. The case is convincing. The opening Brahms and Schumann disc from 1981 sets the terms immediately. Listen to Nachtwandler and you hear a technique so clean it disappears, leaving only the music. That is the trick. That is what she did. The German lieder sequence that follows moves composer by composer through Schubert, Schumann, Wolf, and Strauss. The Schubert selections are quietly extraordinary — Der Liebliche Stern, Suleika II, and a Auf dem Wasser zu Singen that is more fervent than you'd expect, with Johnson's piano line doing real structural work beneath it. The Strauss section may be the high point of the whole set: his operatic miniatures expose everything about a soprano's breath control and phrase architecture, and Lott handles Ruhe, meine Seele! and Morgen with the kind of affectless emotional accuracy that makes less disciplined singers sound theatrical by comparison. The comedic range is here too, and it matters. Der Hochzeitsbraten with Anthony Rolfe Johnson and Richard Jackson is properly funny — Lott lands the sparky wit without ever mugging. The English song discs, ranging from Quilter and Warlock through Noël Coward, demonstrate her idiomatic ease across registers that trip up singers who treat English as a second-class language for art song. The 2005 Wigmore Hall live recital, Fallen Women and Virtuous Wives, closes the set and is worth the price of admission alone. But it is the three French mélodies discs that are the revelation, particularly if your acquaintance with Lott was primarily through German repertoire. Her Chausson has real melancholy depth; her Fauré and Gounod are lightly perfumed in exactly the right degree. The Poulenc is something else: La Dame de Monte-Carlo is a masterclass in performed numbness, the despair delivered as understatement and all the more devastating for it. Lott understood that the French mélodie is not lieder with an accent — it is a different animal, and she hunted it differently. Johnson's sleeve notes are erudite, specific, and genuinely fond without tipping into hagiography. They deepen the listening rather than substituting for it, which is what good liner notes do and most don't. The whole package — curation, documentation, repertoire spread — is a model for how to honor a career in recorded form.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
72
/100
Serious art song listeners who want a career-spanning document of one of the great song voices of the late twentieth century; also anyone approaching French mélodie for the first time who wants a guide who treats it as its own animal, not Germanified lieder.
Cultural Placement
Like the best Schwarzkopf EMI recital compilations but more intellectually organized, with the curatorial intelligence of the Fischer-Dieskau Deutsche Grammophon retrospectives and the cross-language range of Elly Ameling's Philips survey recordings. What distinguishes this set is not breadth alone but editorial coherence: Johnson builds a case for a specific kind of singing — text-first, affect-honest, technically invisible — the way a scholar builds an argument. The closest analogue in terms of curatorial ambition is the Graham Johnson / Hyperion Schumann song cycle series, except here the organizing intelligence is turned on a single singer across a fifty-year arc.
Honest assessment
This is not a set that will convert people who find lieder slow or precious — it offers no entry ramp for the uninitiated and makes no apology for its demands. For those already inside the form, it is indispensable: fifty years of a voice that never once chose effect over truth, documented across five languages with curatorial intelligence that explains why each disc is here. The Poulenc and Strauss discs alone justify the price.
What Is NOVEL?
72
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
2/5
Originality
2/5
Voice
5/5
Endurance
5/5
Lineage
4/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
No formal risk here — this is a posthumous compilation, not a new artistic statement. The nerve was Lott's, taken decades ago; the boxset inherits it without adding any of its own.
Lineage tree
Elisabeth Schwarzkopf
direct ancestor — the benchmark for text-intelligence in German lieder and Strauss
Elly Ameling
parallel practitioner — same cross-language range and affect-honest approach
Pierre Bernac / Francis Poulenc
lineage source for the French mélodie tradition Lott inhabits
Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau
male counterpart tradition — the same text-first interpretive philosophy applied to baritone repertoire
Verified Facts (14)
Dame Felicity Lott died in May this year
This 10-CD boxset from Hyperion brings together recordings from a career that spanned half a century
Curated by Graham Johnson, who in 1976 recruited Lott for The Songmakers' Almanac
The set opens with a 1981 Brahms and Schumann disc
Brahms' Nachtwandler and Schumann's Singet nicht in Trauertönen are included
Schubert works include Der Liebliche Stern, Suleika II, and Auf dem Wasser zu Singen
Schumann includes sparkling duets with Ann Murray
Wolf features excerpts from the Italienisches Liederbuch with the late Peter Schreier
Richard Strauss works include Ruhe, meine Seele! and Morgen
Der Hochzeitsbraten features Anthony Rolfe Johnson and Richard Jackson
Noël Coward's A Bar on the Piccola Marina included alongside English songs by Quilter, Walton, Warlock and Britten
Fallen Women and Virtuous Wives is a live 2005 Wigmore Hall recital
Three discs of French mélodies include Chausson, Gounod, Fauré, and Poulenc
La Dame de Monte-Carlo described as a masterclass in understated despair
More latest news
Read all