
Listen
These Premises Are Alarmed
on Faber Music
When did orchestral programming last feel dangerous? The Hallé's evening at the Bridgewater Hall — Thomas Adès conducting, Pekka Kuusisto soloing, Gabriella Smith getting a world premiere — answered that question by simply ignoring the usual risk calculus. Average composer age across the programme: around 30. That is not a gimmick. That is a thesis. The concert opened with Adès's own These Premises Are Alarmed, written for the Bridgewater Hall's 1996 inauguration when the composer was 25. It announces itself the way a confident young composer announces themselves: noisy, knowing, structurally packed, allergic to padding. Rattles and twitches barrel into a brief lyrical sweep before high shrieks and low brass slabs close it down. The Hallé's performance was taut throughout — every edge made to matter, nothing blurred in the name of comfort. Asyla followed, premiered when Adès was 26, and the forces required tell you everything about the ambition: bass oboe, ten double basses, contrabass bassoon. Adès marshalled this extravagant ensemble through geological rumbles and raucous angularity with the authority of someone who has lived inside the score for three decades. The orchestra was instantly responsive; the details remained crystalline even in the wildest passages. This was his debut as the Hallé's principal guest conductor, and it sounded like a relationship that already knows how to argue. The world premiere of Gabriella Smith's Violin Concerto: How to Be a Bird (Smith is 34) featured Kuusisto's characteristically unorthodox presence — lines silvered by harmonics, creaking under bow pressure, woven through the orchestral fabric rather than placed above it. Smith's language is built from almost ubiquitous tremolo and trilling, a forensic study of colour more than line. Occasional moments of tonal blandness punctuated the exploration — not fatal, but audible — before Kuusisto trilled into the stratosphere and the hall fell completely silent. That silence was earned. Stravinsky's Firebird Suite (revised when the composer was 36, keeping the evening's demographic commitment intact) closed the programme, and by most accounts it was the peak. Adès conducted with physical intensity — reportedly holding his baton in two hands to slice downbeats as if at Wimbledon — and the result was fierce, unbuttoned, achingly elegant in quieter passages, and fast where fast was the right choice. A suite performed countless times managed to sound utterly fresh. That is the hardest trick in classical music, and they pulled it off. What this concert demonstrated is that youth in composition is not a novelty category — it is a different relationship to risk. Adès at 25 was not writing like a junior version of an established composer; he was writing like someone who had not yet learned what you are not supposed to attempt. Smith at 34 is building a tonal language that prioritises texture over melody in ways that conservative programming committees tend to defer on until a composer is safely established. Giving these works a stage together, with Stravinsky as the elder statesman at a youthful 36, made the argument structurally rather than rhetorically. The Hallé and Adès did not need to explain that young composers matter. They just played the music.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
72
/100
Listeners who find most orchestral programming timid, fans of Adès's compositional work curious to hear him as interpreter, and anyone tracking where post-millennial art-music composition is actually going. Available on BBC Radio 3 / BBC Sounds — no ticket required.
Cultural Placement
Like a Pierre Boulez programme at the BBC Symphony but warmer and more physically committed, with the structural boldness of a Gustavo Dudamel debut and the curatorial nerve of the early Southbank Sinfonia. Adès conducting Adès has the specific intensity of a writer directing their own screenplay — total authority over the material, no distance between intent and execution. Smith's concerto lands somewhere between Kaija Saariaho's orchestral textures and Caroline Shaw's interest in bodies and breath, without being derivative of either.
Honest assessment
This concert works as a curatorial argument more than as a neutral programme, and that is a compliment. Smith's new concerto has a moment of tonal blandness the reviewer rightly notes, which keeps it short of a clean triumph. But the Adès performances — both his own works and the Firebird — deliver exactly what they promise: interpretive authority with no distance between composer-knowledge and conductor-execution.
What Is NOVEL?
72
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
4/5
Originality
3/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
4/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Real nerve: an entire programme built around composers averaging 30 is a programmable argument that most concert halls refuse to make. A world premiere anchors it rather than decorates it.
Permission slip
Consensus says: Critical consensus will likely focus on the Adès-as-conductor debut and treat the Smith premiere as a supporting curiosity. We rate the curatorial argument — the generational thesis — as the main event, with Adès's interpretive choices as evidence for it rather than the story itself.
What they're missing: The concert's real achievement is structural: proving that a programme built around young composers can be more urgent than one built around repertoire safety. That argument is bigger than any single performance, and reviews that lead with the Firebird miss what made the evening significant.
Lineage tree
Stravinsky – Firebird (1910/rev.)
direct ancestor — closes the programme as proof of concept that young composers can produce lasting work
Britten
tonal influence on Adès's approach to orchestral colour and English modernism
Ligeti
structural influence on Adès's rhythmic angularity and textural layering
Saariaho
spectral-texture lineage that Smith's concerto extends and personalises
Boulez as programmer
curatorial model — programming as argument, not museum curation
Verified Facts (9)
These Premises Are Alarmed was composed for the Hallé's inauguration of the Bridgewater Hall in 1996 by the then 25-year-old Thomas Adès
Asyla was premiered when Adès was 26
Asyla requires bass oboe, 10 double basses, contrabass bassoon
Gabriella Smith is 34
The Violin Concerto: How to Be a Bird was a world premiere
The soloist was Pekka Kuusisto
Stravinsky revised the Firebird Suite when the composer was 36
This was Adès's first outing as the Hallé's new principal guest conductor
The concert will be broadcast on Radio 3 on 1 December, then available on BBC Sounds for 30 days
More latest news
Read all