
Take That have spent the years since their last album industriously documenting themselves — documentaries, candid-ish memoirs, a revival of their 2009 Circus blockbuster tour. All that retrospection was supposed to feed the new record. Instead it has drowned it. Dreamers, the band's tenth album, arrives so marinated in its own history that even the genuinely good moments feel like they're competing with a museum exhibit. The good moments are real. Wonderkids, the string-laden opener, earns its stirring quality through genuine emotional specificity — Gary Barlow's lyric about forgiving and being forgiven feels lived-in rather than performed. Sweet July has the loose, slightly louche energy of a great Shine B-side, and Change of Season is genuinely strange in ways that suggest Take That still know how to push themselves when they decide to. These three tracks alone justify the existence of the album. The problem is they share space with the other eight. Best Heartbreak and Higher represent the album's pallid disco revivalism — Higher in particular lands closer to S Club 7 circa 2001 than anything resembling contemporary dance music. Feel My Love is a folk-stomp that would have felt dated when Mumford & Sons were actually in the charts, delivered here with the confidence of a band that stopped checking the calendar around 2013. These aren't experimental failures; they're not trying anything that could fail. They're just tired. Mark Owen's My Love Is Yours is the low point — a raspy ballad with nothing behind the rasp, the kind of track that exists because an album needs ten songs and someone ran out of better ideas. Who Do You Think You Are, by contrast, works: it has a wounded lounge-singer quality, finger-clicking and genuinely felt, that suits where the band actually are in their lives. The gap between these two ballads is the gap between Take That choosing to be honest and Take That choosing to coast. The structural problem with Dreamers is legible once you read the context: the band is simultaneously releasing a vintage Circus tour revival. When you are professionally trading on 2009, the incentive to make 2025 sound genuinely new is structurally undermined. The album reads like a companion to that tour — comfort food for people who want reassurance that Take That still exist, not a statement about why they should. That's a viable commercial posture. It's just not one that produces great records.
Worth reading?
OPTIONAL
Score
36
/100
Committed Take That fans who want reassurance the band still functions; casual listeners should queue up Wonderkids, Sweet July, and Change of Season and stop there.
Cultural Placement
Like late-era Pet Shop Boys — formally proficient, emotionally sincere in spots, but audibly aware of their own legacy in ways that constrain rather than liberate. More Robbie Williams' Swing When You're Winning (a career valediction dressed as a present-tense album) than a third act. The British boyband-grown-up tradition runs from Take That's own Nobody Else through Westlife's late balladry to this — a lineage defined by survival rather than reinvention, and Dreamers doesn't argue with that tradition so much as confirm it.
Honest assessment
Dreamers is exactly what a band running a nostalgia tour produces: an album with the energy of a curtain-call rather than a performance. It has three genuinely good tracks — Wonderkids, Sweet July, Change of Season — that demonstrate real capability. The rest demonstrates a band that has decided not to use it. Worth a targeted listen; not worth an album commitment.
What Is NOVEL?
36
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
1/5
Originality
1/5
Voice
3/5
Endurance
2/5
Lineage
2/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
No nerve here. The vintage Circus tour is running simultaneously — the commercial context actively punishes risk. Change of Season is the one exception, and it proves the band could swing harder if they chose to.
Permission slip
Consensus says: Critical consensus will likely be warmer — 'solid return,' 'veterans delivering the goods.' We're less impressed. The good tracks are genuinely good; the album frame around them is weak.
What they're missing: Consensus reviews of legacy acts tend to grade on a survival curve — 'still vital at 50-something' becomes the implicit benchmark. Measured against what this band is capable of (as Change of Season demonstrates), Dreamers underdelivers.
Verified Facts (14)
Take That's new album is their 10th album
The band describes three remaining fiftysomething boybanders
The opening track is Wonderkids, described as string-laden
Gary Barlow sings 'Forgiving you, forgiving me / This vicious circle is now complete' on Wonderkids
The band and former member Robbie Williams have laid out the trials and tribulations of 35 years of Take That in several documentaries
Earlier this year they embarked on a revival of their blockbuster 2009 Circus tour
Dreamers is described as the band's 10th album
Tracks mentioned: Wonderkids, Best Heartbreak, Higher, Feel My Love, Who Do You Think You Are, Sweet July, Change of Season, My Love Is Yours
Higher described as more S Club 7 than Dua Lipa
Feel My Love described as a guitar-bothering folk stomper
Sweet July described as like Shine's sleazy little sibling
Mark Owen performs My Love Is Yours
Who Do You Think You Are described as having a finger-clicking, wounded lounge singer lilt
My Love Is Yours described as the band's weakest song in years
More latest news
Read all