
Listen
Aja
on YouTube
Adrian Chiles diagnosed a cultural ailment — the shuffle button as the original sin of fractured attention — and a reader named Bren Pointer wrote back with the cure in one sentence: play Aja by Steely Dan, all 39 minutes and 54 seconds, and you will not skip a single track. That's not nostalgia talking. That's a structural observation about what Walter Becker and Donald Fagen actually built. Aja (1977) is the rare album where the sequencing is load-bearing. The seven tracks don't merely coexist — they form a tonal and harmonic argument that only resolves if you hear them in order. 'Black Cow' opens at a low simmer. By the time 'Josie' closes things out, you've been somewhere. Skip 'Deacon Blues' and you haven't just missed a track; you've missed the emotional centre of gravity around which the whole thing orbits. The album is also a masterclass in what might be called productive difficulty. Fagen and Becker hired the best session musicians in Los Angeles and New York — Victor Feldman, Wayne Shorter, Steve Gadd — and then wrote charts that demanded genuine improvisation within tightly controlled harmonic spaces. The result is jazz feeling inside pop architecture. It sounds effortless and is nothing of the kind. The letter's deeper point, made lightly, is that the shuffle button didn't just change listening habits — it changed what artists felt they could safely build. If your audience might hear track four before track one, there's little point writing an album that requires track one first. Aja predates that logic, which is partly why it survives it. The other letters in the same column — hot toddies and dental hygiene, the 'silent generation' ignored by Christmas gift guides, Black Friday spread across the entire month of November — are the texture of a particular kind of British public correspondence: wry, self-deprecating, sharply observed without being sharp. They don't belong in the same analytical frame as Aja, but they share the letter's unpretentious warmth. Pointer's recommendation lands because it's given the same way you'd give a friend a record — matter-of-factly, with absolute confidence, and without further argument.
Worth reading?
REVISIT
Score
84
/100
Anyone who listened to this on shuffle, in pieces, or as background music and thinks they've heard it. You haven't. Put it on from the beginning with nothing else open.
Cultural Placement
Like Kind of Blue but more polished and more paranoid, with the studio perfectionism of Pet Sounds applied to jazz-pop harmony and an LA session-musician roster that could have played anything but chose to play this. Aja sits in the tradition of the album-as-unified-statement — closer to Marvin Gaye's Let's Get It On in its sensual economy than to the maximalist prog it was contemporary with. What makes it distinctive is the compression: enormous harmonic ambition packed into radio-adjacent running times, with no fat and no filler, in an era when double albums were the prestige move.
Honest assessment
Aja is not a sentimental favourite — it's a structurally rigorous album that rewards the kind of attention most streaming interfaces actively discourage. The letter-writer is correct: you will not skip. What it offers a modern listener is the experience of hearing craft that is complete, unhurried, and indifferent to your desire to skip ahead.
What Is NOVEL?
84
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
3/5
Originality
4/5
Voice
5/5
Endurance
5/5
Lineage
4/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Moderate formal risk: jazz improvisation inside tight pop architecture could have collapsed into elevator music. It didn't, but Becker and Fagen had enough commercial cushion that collapse wasn't catastrophic.
Lineage tree
Kind of Blue — Miles Davis
modal jazz framework; emotional restraint as compositional tool
Pet Sounds — Beach Boys
studio-as-instrument; album as unified emotional statement
Burt Bacharach
harmonic sophistication inside pop song architecture
Great American Songbook
lyric craftsmanship and chord vocabulary
Verified Facts (4)
Aja by Steely Dan runs 39 minutes and 54 seconds
The letter is signed by Bren Pointer, London
The letter responds to an Adrian Chiles piece titled 'Instant gratification is ruining our lives – and for me it started with my CD player's shuffle button', dated 18 November
Other letters in the column cover hot toddies and dental hygiene (William Bryce, Farnham, Surrey; Paul Tattam, Chinley, Derbyshire), the 'silent generation' and Christmas gifts (Adam Bunting, Roussillon, France), and Black Friday confusion (Graham Thompson, Leyburn, North Yorkshire)
More latest news
Read all