
The playlist interview is the music press's laziest format and, occasionally, its most revealing. Sharleen Spiteri's version for the Guardian lands in the second camp. What she chooses — Nancy Sinatra, Al Green, the Persuaders, the Beatles — is less interesting than how she talks about each one: with the blunt warmth of someone who has been famous long enough to stop performing candour and just be candid. The through-line from These Boots Are Made for Walkin' to I Don't Want a Lover is a coherent aesthetic: songs built around attitude rather than sentiment, where the singer's posture matters as much as the melody. Spiteri clocks this in Sinatra — 'the sass and the strength' — and traces it to her own public persona ('my whole don't fuck with me thing'). That's not revisionist mythology; it's how taste actually forms, through eight-year-old girls getting butterflies to records they half-understand. The Ave Maria entry is the piece's emotional centre, though Spiteri doesn't play it that way. Her mother's death, the lockdown funeral, the doctorate from Glasgow, the phone call to her sister — she assembles these facts briskly, without asking for anything from the reader. The punchline ('I can't save your life, but I can sing you a song') is genuinely funny and genuinely sad at the same time, which is a harder trick than it looks. The Highway to Hell admission is the most self-aware moment: she doesn't call it a guilty pleasure because she doesn't believe in guilty pleasures, but she knows it 'throws people' and she clearly enjoys that. A Texas fan expecting White on Blonde deep cuts gets AC/DC karaoke instead. The willingness to be incongruous without explaining yourself is a form of confidence most artists performing this format don't quite manage. What's missing is what's always missing in these pieces: any real account of craft. We learn when and where songs hit her, not how she hears them musically. The Oliver's Army story — buying Elvis Costello at a record shop inside an old cinema in Balloch because she was curious who would dare call themselves Elvis — is vivid and specific, but it's a story about attitude, not about the song's melodic writing or Costello's arrangement. That's consistent with who Spiteri presents herself as: a singer who leads with persona, not musicology. Fair enough. The White on Blonde 30th anniversary reissue, out 5 February, is presumably the occasion for all of this, though the album is mentioned exactly once, in a footnote.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
52
/100
Texas fans; readers who like personality-driven music journalism; anyone drawn to the specific craft of saying something true in a constrained format.
Cultural Placement
Like a Desert Island Discs session edited down to its best twelve minutes — intimate and apparently casual, but structurally revealing. Closer in spirit to Nick Hornby's 31 Songs than to a standard Q&A: each entry is a small autobiography, not a recommendation. The format is Richard Dyer's 'star text' made explicit — Spiteri is consciously constructing a self through musical associations — but she's doing it with enough dryness and wit that it doesn't feel like PR. Think Patti Smith's Just Kids if Smith had refused to be literary about it.
Honest assessment
This is a playlist interview that punches above the format's usual ceiling, primarily because Spiteri's voice — wry, unguarded, structurally anti-sentimental — survives the compression. The Ave Maria / doctorate sequence is the kind of material most subjects would over-explain; she doesn't. It won't matter in ten years, but it's worth your ten minutes now.
What Is NOVEL?
52
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
2/5
Originality
2/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
2/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
No structural risk taken — this is the format executed competently. The candour about grief and AC/DC is mild by interview standards. Nothing here could have collapsed.
Verified Facts (7)
Texas's White on Blonde 30th anniversary reissue is out 5 February
Spiteri was awarded a doctorate of music from the University of Glasgow
I Don't Want a Lover was written one week before her 18th birthday
Oliver's Army by Elvis Costello & the Attractions was her first single, bought at a record shop inside an old cinema
Texas covered Tired of Being Alone by Al Green and still occasionally play it live
Her mother asked for Ave Maria to be played at her funeral, just before lockdown
Her younger sister is named Corinne
More latest news
Read all