
The piece opens with a familiar irritation — tell someone you're going to the Bahamas for work and they smirk — then uses that friction as the entry point into something deeper. This is a reported essay from the Fuze Caribbean art fair in Nassau, structured around conversations with Bahamian artists John Cox and Antonius Roberts, plus encounters with younger artists like Anina Major, Cydne Coleby, April Bey, and Tavares Strachan. The question underneath everything: who gets to define what the Caribbean looks like, and what happens when the people who live there take the camera back? The strongest material comes from the artists themselves. Roberts, 68, recalls being told to stop 'painting Black' when he studied in the US — his Caribbean palette was read as naive, paint straight from the tube, rather than as accurate representation of tropical light. Major makes ceramic baskets that collapse inward, echoing Nassau's straw market, where goods once handwoven by local women are now imported from China with Minnie Mouse braided onto them. Cox describes a generation of artists who 'retain the beauty and raw, seductive quality of this landscape while bringing forward the complexity of lives filled with diversity, humour, irony.' These are concrete images doing real analytical work. The essay's structural engine is the tension between reclamation and exoticisation — a tension the writer turns on herself. At a luxury resort hosting the fair, surrounded by American bachelor parties and casinos where Bahamians are legally barred from playing, she remarks she's 'not like them.' A Black British curator who knows the country well corrects her instantly: 'You are.' That moment lands hard because the writer doesn't resolve it. She lets it sit. The historical spine is brisk and functional. Post-abolition, the Bahamas shed its reputation for poverty through deliberate image-making — postcards, photography, tourism marketing that ramped up mid-century. Flights from south Florida run as short as 30 minutes. Roberts calls the cruise industry the 'new colonial power,' curating what passengers see: no political art, no climate breakdown. The economy shifted from sugar exports to tourism, and the visual language shifted with it. Where the piece wobbles is in its final movement. After the sharp self-interrogation — am I reclaiming or exoticising? — the essay retreats into softer, more abstract territory. 'Art doesn't demand a definitive answer, and doesn't fix itself or the viewer in place' is true but generic. The conch-shell acrylic-pour workshop anecdote gestures at tokenisation without committing to the critique. The ending, 'I wonder what I can't see,' is honest but slightly inert after everything that preceded it. The best passages work because they trust the reader with ambiguity. The straw market becoming a shell of itself, Major's ceramics deflating as metaphor, Roberts' silk cotton tree and navel string — these images carry the essay's argument more effectively than the reflective passages. The writing is at its sharpest when it stays concrete and lets the objects do the thinking. As cultural journalism, this is doing something genuinely useful: introducing anglophone readers to a Caribbean art scene most will never encounter, naming specific artists and specific works, and framing the encounter through a question that doesn't have a clean answer. It doesn't pretend the fair exists outside economic power structures, and it doesn't pretend the writer exists outside them either.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
64
/100
Diaspora readers who've felt the am-I-tourist-or-local vertigo; anyone interested in Caribbean contemporary art and wants specific names and works to follow; readers of Kincaid, Cole, or Cadogan looking for a new voice in that lineage.
Cultural Placement
Like Jamaica Kincaid's 'A Small Place' filtered through the structure of a Teju Cole art-walk essay, with the self-interrogation of Zadie Smith's cultural criticism. The mechanism is the reversed gaze — using artists' concrete objects (collapsed baskets, fluorescent palettes, wooden sculptures) to dismantle the flattened image. Where Kincaid ran hot and accusatory, this piece runs warmer and more uncertain, closer to the register of Garnette Cadogan's 'Walking While Black' — the body in the space as the analytical instrument.
Honest assessment
A solid, well-reported piece of cultural journalism that introduces specific Bahamian artists and their work while honestly interrogating the writer's own position. It's strongest when concrete — the deflated ceramic baskets, the 'painting Black' anecdote, the casino where Bahamians can't play — and weakest when it retreats into abstraction at the end. Worth your time if you care about Caribbean art or diaspora identity, but it doesn't quite stick the landing.
What Is NOVEL?
64
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
3/5
Originality
3/5
Voice
3/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
4/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Moderate risk. Turning the gaze on herself — am I a tourist? — could have collapsed into navel-gazing or been read as performance. She mostly earns it through concrete reporting, though the ending hedges.
Lineage tree
A Small Place (Jamaica Kincaid)
direct ancestor — the foundational text on the ugly tourist and Caribbean flattening, explicitly invoked
Teju Cole's essay criticism
tonal influence — the art-walk-as-argument form, the camera as analytical tool
Zadie Smith's cultural essays
extends the form of — diaspora self-interrogation that refuses clean resolution
Garnette Cadogan, 'Walking While Black'
tonal influence — the body in geographic space as the essay's instrument
Verified Facts (10)
Jamaica Kincaid described the Caribbean as so beautiful that its fluffy white clouds, blue spectral waters and 'bottomless' black nights seemed 'unreal'
Antonius Roberts is 68 years old
Roberts was told to stop 'painting Black' when he first went to study in the US
Nassau's straw market now sells goods imported from China, including bags with Minnie Mouse's face braided on
Anina Major recently exhibited at TERN gallery in Nassau
It is illegal for Bahamians to play in the resort casinos
Flights from the south of Florida to the Bahamas can be as short as 30 minutes
Roberts helped establish the National Gallery of the Bahamas
John Cox directed Fuze and held multiple senior curatorial roles
New crop of Bahamian artists includes Cydne Coleby, April Bey, and Tavares Strachan
More latest news
Read all