
This is not an article. It is a callout — a reader-submission form wrapped in three paragraphs of gentle prompting. The Guardian wants to know if you got engaged, married, or gave birth during the August 2024 solar eclipse. They'd also like your pictures. There is no reporting here. No interviews with people who actually had momentous eclipse experiences. No science about the eclipse itself — its path, its duration, its rarity. No cultural history of eclipses as backdrops to human drama. The piece exists entirely as an invitation to fill out a Formstack form. This is a common practice in digital journalism: crowdsource stories from readers, then publish a curated selection later as a standalone feature. The callout itself is the fishing line, not the catch. It has value as a production step but near-zero value as something a reader would consume on its own. The writing is pleasant and inoffensive. "Breathtaking solar eclipse." "Rare celestial event." "Special moment." "Momentous moments." Every adjective does exactly what you'd expect and nothing more. It reads like a template with the event name swapped in. As a piece of content to evaluate, there is almost nothing to evaluate. No voice, no risk, no craft beyond competent copywriting for a web form. It is infrastructure for future journalism, not journalism itself.
Worth reading?
SKIP
Score
12
/100
Nobody, unless you personally had a momentous eclipse experience and want to tell the Guardian about it.
Cultural Placement
Like a classified ad in the back of a parish newsletter, but published on a major news site's science page. The form is closest to the BuzzFeed-era 'tell us your story' template, minus BuzzFeed's self-aware energy. There are no predecessors worth naming because there is no creative ambition to place in a tradition. It occupies the space between a tweet asking for replies and an actual reported feature — the larval stage of content, published as if it were the butterfly.
Honest assessment
This is not content to consume — it's a production mechanism for future content. Three paragraphs of gentle prompting and a Formstack embed. If you had a wild eclipse story and want to share it with the Guardian, the form is there. Everyone else can move on.
What Is NOVEL?
12
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
0/5
Originality
0/5
Voice
0/5
Endurance
0/5
Lineage
0/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Zero risk taken. A web form with three paragraphs of soft prompting. Nothing could fail because nothing was attempted beyond the mechanical act of solicitation.
Verified Facts (3)
In August this year, many people stopped to witness the breathtaking solar eclipse.
Some peered through colanders to see the rare celestial event
Form link: guardiannewsandmedia.formstack.com/forms/solar_eclipse_moments
More latest news
Read all