The former Pennhurst state hospital — a site whose 1968 exposé of inhumane conditions for disabled residents remains one of Pennsylvania's darkest institutional memories — is now the flashpoint for a different kind of institutional failure. Pennhurst Holdings has proposed a three-building datacenter complex spanning nearly 2 million square feet, powered by methane gas, less than 600 feet from the Southeastern Veterans' Center. East Vincent township officials rejected the plan in May amid sweeping opposition, but the developers intend to appeal in court. The fight has scrambled Pennsylvania's political geometry. Governor Josh Shapiro, a Democrat and presidential hopeful, wants Pennsylvania to lead the nation's AI buildout. His Republican challenger, state treasurer Stacy Garrity, now calls for a moratorium on datacenters — despite advocating in January for siting them in rural communities. Shapiro's office dismissed her reversal as "desperate" given her "long record of supporting completely unregulated datacenter development." Democratic state senator Katie Muth, whose district includes East Vincent, introduced a bipartisan three-year moratorium bill on 29 May targeting hyperscale facilities using 20 megawatts or more. The numbers frame the national scale. The US hosts roughly 4,200 datacenters — about 40% of the global total — with thousands more planned or under construction. Four Silicon Valley giants alone are spending approximately $700 billion on AI infrastructure in 2026. Trump issued a December executive order designed to prevent states from restricting AI development in almost any form. At least 12 other states and Democratic senators in Congress are pursuing temporary bans. Pennsylvanians are paying the cost in their electric bills. Federal data shows power prices rose about 20% between November 2024 and 2025 in the state, one of the highest rates nationwide. A Gallup poll from May found seven in ten Americans oppose datacenter construction in their local areas. An Emerson College poll from December put Pennsylvania-specific opposition at 42%, with only 34% in support. The health concerns are concrete, not abstract. Donald Hyman, a 62-year-old veteran recovering from congestive heart failure, worries that air pollution from on-site power generation and backup generators could disrupt his treatment. Four fellow veterans at the Southeastern Veterans' Center raised concerns about noise triggering PTSD and construction exposing them to soil and water contaminants. "You're trying to force something on us we don't want," Hyman told the Guardian. Shapiro's response has been to split the difference. On 27 May he unveiled voluntary guidelines meant to incentivize responsible building — a framework critics see as toothless against developers who can simply choose not to comply. Muth's moratorium bill, by contrast, would impose a hard stop on new hyperscale construction and expansions that cross the 20-megawatt threshold. The bipartisan nature of the bill reflects how datacenter opposition has become one of the rare issues where left-right coalitions form around shared local impact rather than national ideology. Local victories remain fragile. In Montour County, more than 200 residents packed a fire station to protest Talen Energy's bid to rezone hundreds of acres of agricultural land for industrial use. County commissioners denied the request — but Talen said in February it would incorporate feedback and continue pursuing the complex. Farmers in the area report being approached by developers. Beth Livensperger, fighting a proposed datacenter in Lehigh Valley, supports the moratorium because it would buy time: "It would give time for the politics to settle out a little more." The pattern is clear — communities can win battles, but developers have the capital and legal resources to outlast them.