In July 2025, New Mexico governor Michelle Lujan Grisham issued a directive mandating that state child welfare seek custody of all newborns exposed to drugs or alcohol in utero. The order came after two child deaths linked to substance exposure. As of last month, 137 newborns had been taken into state custody under the policy, according to CYFD spokesperson Jake Thompson. At least 25 of those children were Native, with tribes taking jurisdiction in only 10 cases. The directive bypassed the framework it was supposed to replace. The federal Comprehensive Addiction and Recovery Act (Cara), passed in 2016, directed states to develop voluntary "plans of safe care" connecting families to supportive services. New Mexico adopted a state version but allocated zero state funds to implement it and remains grossly understaffed on public mental health services. "Even if families were accepting plans of care, there were no resources," said Micha Bitsinnie, policy manager at Bold Futures and a member of the Navajo Nation. The collision with tribal sovereignty is the sharpest edge. The 1978 Indian Child Welfare Act requires states to make efforts to keep Native children in Native communities and gives tribal governments jurisdiction over child welfare cases involving their citizens. New Mexico passed its own Indian Family Protection Act in 2022, strengthening those requirements. The governor's directive makes no reference to either law. Nine tribes joined an ACLU emergency petition to the state supreme court, which declined to pause the mandate in early June but will hear arguments. The policy contradiction is structural, not incidental. Only months before the governor's directive, the state legislature had passed a law directing the healthcare authority — not the child welfare agency — to develop new rules for treating drug use during pregnancy. Research consistently shows that children prenatally exposed to substances do best when they remain with their families and receive supportive services. Medical professionals warn that custody-first approaches deter parents from seeking care. Delaware's review of its child welfare registry found that only 0.82% of children given a plan of safe care sustained a serious or fatal injury. Native Americans bear the sharpest burden of the opioid crisis the directive claims to address. They recorded the highest overdose rate by race at 51.6 per 100,000 in 2024 — more than double the rate of all other races combined. New Mexico reported that more than one-third of infants born in the state between 2016 and 2019 were exposed to drugs, alcohol, or tobacco. Tribes have won millions in opioid settlements alleging that manufacturers targeted their communities with aggressive advertising, yet culturally grounded child welfare programs remain unfunded a decade after Cara's passage. Navajo Nation president Buu Nygren wrote in an April letter that the proposed rule "raises serious issues related to tribal sovereignty, jurisdiction, and the potential for unnecessary child welfare system involvement." Donalyn Lorenzo, formerly of Acoma Pueblo and the state's office of tribal affairs, noted the policy was written without consulting tribal nations — a sharp departure from the collaborative process that produced the 2022 ICWA law. "Safe children are created within safe communities," she said. The pattern is legible: a decade of unfunded mandates, a crisis deepened by Covid-era overdose surges and provider shortages, two child deaths that generated political pressure, and an executive response that centralizes state power over families while ignoring the legal architecture built to protect tribal jurisdiction. David Simmons of the National Indian Child Welfare Association put it plainly: "I don't think there's any state that is in what I would call really substantive compliance with the Indian Child Welfare Act. And New Mexico's no different."