
CITIES · TN CRUSADE
16
BELIEVERS · 14 CHURCHES
70
GOP · CHRISTIAN ID
3 in 4
CRUSADE DURATION
5 mo
In a parking lot in Columbia, Tennessee, evangelist James Thayer grips a woman's wrist and commands a demon to leave her body. She shudders, coughs, weeps. Nearby, children chase each other in circles and a band plays contemplative music under a white tent. This is Freedom Collective Ministries — 70 believers from 14 churches conducting a 16-city 'gospel crusade' through Tennessee, performing exorcisms, prophesying over strangers, and searching for gold dust on outstretched palms. Five years ago, this scene would have been unrecognizable to most white evangelicals. Now it's becoming the center of gravity.
Extraction Map
The shift is real and measurable. Deliverance ministries and the New Apostolic Reformation movement are growing in popularity, pulling mainstream evangelicals toward charismatic practices — emphatic worship, miraculous healing claims, and a cosmology in which demons are active agents in daily life. The old guardrails of evangelical respectability, epitomized by Billy Graham's buttoned-up style where even raising your hands felt rebellious, are dissolving. Dr Leah Payne, professor of American religious history at Portland Seminary, frames the distinction sharply: Graham 'helped popularize [evangelicalism] as a category in the 20th century' and 'you will not see charismatic practices at all.' The political pipeline is now explicit. Paula White-Cain, Trump's spiritual adviser — whom Southern Baptist theologian Russell Moore once called a heretic — speaks frequently about 'demonic networks' threatening the president. Pete Hegseth's Department of Defense repeatedly quotes scripture to position the US military as a divinely sanctioned force in a cosmic battle against evil. House Speaker Mike Johnson told Christian voters ahead of the midterms they face a 'spiritual battle' against socialists, speaking to a base where three out of four Republicans or Republican-leaners identify as Christian. In Kansas, a Republican gubernatorial candidate accused his rival of witchcraft and framed the election as 'a spiritual battle that I've never seen before.' He lost, but narrowly. The merger operates on two distinct levels that reinforce each other. At the grassroots, in places like rural Tennessee, the practices are personal — people seeking healing from physical ailments, mental anguish, spiritual distress. Thayer's Freedom Collective is a roving operation, setting up in parks and parking lots, attending to people who are mostly women, offering a framework of spiritual warfare that gives their suffering a cosmic explanation and a dramatic resolution. The appeal is visceral and intimate, not ideological. At the elite level, the same language of demons and spiritual warfare provides a theological scaffolding for political authoritarianism — enemies aren't merely wrong, they're possessed; opposition isn't political, it's satanic. The Overton window within American Christianity has shifted decisively. Where once the intersection of faith and conservatism was defined by reserved figures like Graham and Jerry Falwell, the televangelists they once dismissed as charlatans — the ones whose broadcasts featured speaking in tongues and convulsions — are now setting the terms. The article's author, a former evangelical who grew up Methodist in western Tennessee and joined Campus Crusade for Christ in college, documents this shift through personal experience: in those spaces, charismatic displays were explicitly forbidden as attention-seeking, and talk of demons was 'discouraged as fantastical at best, or a path toward evil at worst.' The institutional fractures are already visible. The author's childhood church split from the United Methodists in the schism over LGBTQ+ affirmation and now simply calls itself a 'community church' — one of thousands of congregations unmooring from denominational structures and drifting toward independent charismatic authority. This fragmentation creates a religious marketplace where accountability is thin, theological credentials are optional, and the most emotionally compelling offering wins. It's not unusual for religious practices to morph in times of political and cultural upheaval, but the speed and scale of this particular transformation — from fringe Pentecostal practice to White House theology in barely a decade — is structurally significant. The twenty-year question is whether this merger produces a durable political-religious formation or burns itself out. Charismatic movements historically cycle through intense enthusiasm and institutional collapse. But this one has something previous waves lacked: direct integration with state power, a media ecosystem that amplifies supernatural framing, and a political coalition that benefits from framing opponents as literally demonic. The cost falls on democratic deliberation itself — it is very difficult to compromise with someone you believe is possessed.
Worth reading?
SKIP
Score
24
/100
Extractive. Charismatic authority structures concentrate spiritual and political power in unaccountable leaders while degrading institutional checks, denominational accountability, and the capacity for democratic compromise.
What Is GRIN?
GRIN stands for Generativity, Resilience, Innovation efficiency, and Novelty openness. These four dimensions capture the essential characteristics of any memetic intelligence — whether a nation, a corporation, a religion, or a movement.
About GRINGenerativity
1/5
Resilience
1/5
Efficiency
1/5
Novelty
2/5
Extractive
4/5
Inverted
Does this create new capability or just redistribute existing value?
Net-negative generativity. No new civic or institutional capacity is being built — existing denominational structures are fragmenting into personality-driven ministries with no accountability layer or theological peer review.
Verified Facts (9)
James Thayer, 36, leads Freedom Collective Ministries, described as 'uniting 70 believers from 14 different churches in evangelism, healing and deliverance'
Freedom Collective conducted a 16-city gospel crusade through Tennessee over five months
Paula White-Cain, Trump's spiritual adviser, was called a heretic by Southern Baptist minister Russell Moore per Politico
Pete Hegseth's Department of Defense has repeatedly quoted scripture to position the US military as a divinely sanctioned force
Mike Johnson told Christian voters they faced a 'spiritual battle' against socialists ahead of the midterms
Three out of four Republicans or people who lean Republican identify as Christian per Pew Research
In Kansas, the Republican candidate for governor accused his rival of witchcraft and lost narrowly
Dr Leah Payne is a professor of American religious history at Portland Seminary
The author's childhood church split from the United Methodists in the schism over LGBTQ+ affirmation
More latest news
Read all