
PHOTOS UPLOADED
3.5M
NIMBUS CONTRACT
2021
NIMBUS VALUE
$B+
CONSENT GIVEN
0
The Israeli military uploaded 3.5 million photographs of Palestinians to Amazon Web Services' Rekognition facial recognition platform in early 2024, according to leaked documents obtained by the Guardian. The images were transferred by a military department known as Rolling Stone — a unit that maintains expansive databases on Palestinian populations in Gaza and the West Bank, including identity-card photos collected from every resident at age 16. The upload coincided with Israel's ground offensive and aerial bombardment of Gaza.
Extraction Map
The infrastructure enabling this surveillance is Project Nimbus, a multibillion-dollar 2021 contract under which AWS and Google provide cloud services to Israeli government and military clients. AWS opened datacentres in Israel in early 2023, and the contract includes a segregated "walled garden" within the Tel Aviv facility — fortified with enhanced digital and physical security — where sensitive military and intelligence material is stored. Crucially, previously revealed contract terms prohibit AWS or Google from restricting or suspending Israeli government access, even if Israel breaches their terms of service. The Rolling Stone system has operated for decades as a centralised repository of personal data on Palestinians: family details, property holdings, checkpoint crossings, work permits, criminal records, and photographs. After Israel's ground invasion of Gaza in October 2023, temporary military checkpoints became pop-up surveillance posts where cameras captured images of displaced Palestinians. Facial recognition matched people against Rolling Stone's databases, and those flagged were pulled aside and detained. UN bodies and rights groups say many were held incommunicado, constituting enforced disappearances. Israeli soldiers worked from AWS's Tel Aviv offices on the 28th floor of one of Israel's tallest skyscrapers in early 2024, exploring ways to operationalise facial recognition programmes in Gaza. AWS characterised the visits as "routine customer engagement" and stated it has no "visibility" into customer workloads. A military source described the ambition plainly: "The plan was to migrate pictures, videos, all the confidential intelligence information — everything." The arrangement exposes a structural problem in how major cloud providers relate to state clients. AWS's contractual inability to restrict access — combined with its claim of zero visibility into how its tools are used — creates a framework where the platform profits from surveillance infrastructure while maintaining plausible deniability about its application. Microsoft, by contrast, unilaterally disabled Israeli military access to technology powering a mass surveillance system uncovered by the Guardian and +972 Magazine. The Nimbus contract was specifically designed to prevent such interventions. The New York Times previously reported that Israel's military experimented with commercially available facial recognition in Gaza to detect faces in crowds and drone footage, at times wrongly flagging civilians as militants. The Guardian's new documents add a layer: the scale of biometric data flowing through Amazon's systems, the institutional architecture enabling it, and the contractual protections shielding the arrangement from accountability. The IDF declined to comment on operational engagements or services. What emerges is a commercial surveillance supply chain. A US tech company provides the compute, storage, and AI tools. A military occupier provides the coerced biometric data of millions of people who never consented. The contract ensures the arrangement cannot be interrupted. The question is not whether facial recognition technology can be used this way — it clearly can — but what accountability framework exists when it is, and the current answer is: none.
Worth reading?
SKIP
Score
8
/100
Extractive. Amazon extracts revenue from providing surveillance infrastructure; Israel extracts biometric data and control from a captive population with no consent mechanism, no opt-out, and contractual protections against intervention.
What Is GRIN?
GRIN stands for Generativity, Resilience, Innovation efficiency, and Novelty openness. These four dimensions capture the essential characteristics of any memetic intelligence — whether a nation, a corporation, a religion, or a movement.
About GRINGenerativity
0/5
Resilience
1/5
Efficiency
1/5
Novelty
0/5
Extractive
5/5
Inverted
Does this create new capability or just redistribute existing value?
Zero generativity for the surveilled population. Value flows one direction: Palestinian biometric data becomes Israeli military intelligence product hosted on Amazon infrastructure. No capability created for those whose data is taken.
Verified Facts (14)
Israeli military uploaded 3.5m photos to Amazon's cloud platform to use Rekognition facial recognition technology
Images uploaded by a department commonly known as Rolling Stone, which sits within a military software unit
Department informed Amazon of the decision to upload images in early 2024
Project Nimbus is a multibillion dollar 2021 deal under which AWS and Google provide cloud services to Israeli government and military
Nimbus contract contains terms prohibiting US companies from restricting or suspending Israeli government and military use even if Israel breaches terms of service
AWS opened new datacentres in Israel in early 2023; large proportion of data also moved from AWS datacentres in Ireland
A segregated area within Tel Aviv datacentres described as a 'walled garden' with enhanced digital and physical security
Israeli soldiers worked from AWS's offices in Tel Aviv on the 28th floor in early 2024
Rolling Stone system includes data such as personal and family details, property holdings, checkpoint crossings, work permits, and criminal activity
Palestinians receive identity cards at age 16; photos from these feed Rolling Stone databases
Blue Wolf is a smartphone app Israeli soldiers use in the West Bank to scan Palestinians' faces
Microsoft previously disabled Israeli military access to technology used to operate a mass surveillance system uncovered by the Guardian and +972 Magazine
IDF spokesperson said it 'does not intend to comment on engagements or services related to operational needs'
AWS spokesperson said it had no 'visibility' into workloads held by its customers
More latest news
Read all