
DAYS DEADLOCKED
100+
STRAW POLLS
9
GRYNSPAN VOTES
10/15
P5 VETOES · GRYNSPAN
2
The UN Security Council's ninth straw poll on Friday failed to produce a secretary general, extending a deadlock now past 100 days — the longest in the institution's history. Costa Rica's Rebeca Grynspan collected 10 of the 15 votes needed to win, clearing the nine-vote threshold, but two permanent members — believed to be the US and Russia — voted against her. Under the council's rules, a single P5 veto kills a candidacy regardless of overall support.
Extraction Map
The more revealing dynamic played out around Lana Nusseibeh, the UAE diplomat who entered late and drew seven encourage votes but three P5 vetoes — believed to be from the UK, France, and China. The UK and France appear to have blocked her over the UAE's documented links to atrocities in Sudan, where UN panels and rights groups have reported Emirati mercenary hiring and weapons supply to the Rapid Support Forces, the paramilitary group the UN and US have determined committed genocide in Darfur. Nearly 70 UK MPs wrote to Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband calling Nusseibeh not a "credible candidate" because she had "repeatedly denied and dismissed" those expert findings. China's opposition to Nusseibeh rests on different ground: an unwritten geographic rotation convention that makes this Latin America or the Caribbean's "turn." That convention has been ignored before but provides useful diplomatic cover. The UAE denies involvement in Sudan. Nusseibeh took leave from her UAE government ministerial post, citing "obligations of independence," and framed Sudan as the "litmus test" for the next secretary general — a remarkable framing given the allegations against her own government. Argentina's Rafael Grossi sits second with eight encourage votes but three P5 discourages, leaving him further from viability than Grynspan. The process itself is designed to favor incumbents of the P5 power structure: candidates need nine of 15 council votes, but the five permanent members vote on red ballots carrying effective veto weight. Elected members vote on white ballots. Tallies are never officially disclosed but leak through unofficial channels. Daniel Safran-Hon of the International Peace Institute called Grynspan the "undisputed frontrunner" but acknowledged she has struggled to "peel off American opposition." If she prevails, she would become the first woman and first Jewish person to lead the UN. Her background — daughter of WWII refugees who found safety in Costa Rica, head of UNCTAD which has documented economic damage from Israel's occupation of Palestinian territories — positions her as a consensus figure for the Global South while creating friction with the US. The structural picture is stark: a process controlled by five nations, using secret ballots with asymmetric veto power, to select the chief diplomat for 193 member states. António Guterres's second term ends 31 December. Another vote is scheduled for next week, but no mechanism exists to force resolution. The P5 can run this indefinitely. What the Sudan dimension reveals is how geopolitical extraction operates through institutional appointment. The UAE sought to place its diplomat atop the body investigating its own conduct — a move that, had it succeeded, would have represented a remarkable capture of multilateral accountability infrastructure. The UK and France blocked it, but the fact that it got to seven votes with US and Russian backing shows how thin the guardrails are.
Worth reading?
SKIP
Score
20
/100
Extractive — a selection process designed to let five states block the will of 188 others, now weaponized by competing power blocs to deadlock global governance for over 100 days.
What Is GRIN?
GRIN stands for Generativity, Resilience, Innovation efficiency, and Novelty openness. These four dimensions capture the essential characteristics of any memetic intelligence — whether a nation, a corporation, a religion, or a movement.
About GRINGenerativity
1/5
Resilience
1/5
Efficiency
1/5
Novelty
1/5
Extractive
4/5
Inverted
Does this create new capability or just redistribute existing value?
Zero new capability created. The 100-day deadlock destroys institutional capacity. No reform, no adaptation — just veto-wielders grinding each other to a halt while the role sits empty.
Verified Facts (9)
Rebeca Grynspan collected 10 votes in Friday's poll but received two P5 votes against
The vote to replace António Guterres is already the longest in UN history at more than 100 days
Guterres's second term ends on 31 December
Rafael Grossi received eight encourage but three discourage votes from among the P5
Lana Nusseibeh received seven votes for but three against from permanent members
Nearly 70 MPs wrote to UK Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband arguing Nusseibeh was not a credible candidate
The UN and US have determined the RSF has committed genocide in Darfur
Nusseibeh took a leave of absence from her ministerial post in the UAE government
Daniel Safran-Hon is a senior adviser at the International Peace Institute
More latest news
Read all