
Get the book
The Death of Ivan Ilyich & Other Stories
on Guardian Bookshop
Gustavo Scarpa is a 32-year-old attacking midfielder for Atlético Mineiro who won two Copa Libertadores titles, was named best player in the Brazilian league in 2022, and had a forgettable six-month spell at Nottingham Forest. None of that is why you're reading about him. You're reading about him because his Instagram and YouTube book reviews sent Leo Tolstoy's The Death of Ivan Ilyich to #1 on Amazon Brazil's overall sales chart — not the fiction chart, the everything chart — and then spilled across the border into Argentina, where a bookseller in Chajarí, 311 miles from Buenos Aires, found himself fielding multiple requests for an 1886 Russian novella and had to Google why. The mechanism here is straightforward but the context makes it land differently. Brazilian football culture is not bookish. Players overwhelmingly come from poor backgrounds with limited educational access, and even those with better opportunities, as sports columnist Alicia Klein notes, "mostly choose to remain disengaged" from cultural debates. More than half of Brazil's population hasn't read a single book in the previous three months. The dominant model of footballer-as-influencer is Neymar, who was advertising betting companies before they were banned in Brazil in September 2026. Scarpa is running the same celebrity-to-audience pipeline but filling it with Dostoevsky, Kafka, Hurston, and Hugo. What makes Scarpa's BookTubing work as cultural production — and not just a curiosity — is the voice. His reviews are short, funny, and unbothered by literary prestige. On Machiavelli's The Prince: "liked this one. Didn't find it as controversial as people said." On Kafka's The Trial: "incomprehensible, but cool." On Stephen Hawking: "pretty cool — even though we disagree on a few things LOL." This is not a footballer performing intellectualism. It's a guy who reads while walking around the training ground, who wore headphones and a book while teammates listened to music before matches, and who got teased for it. The downstream effects are where the story compounds. Atlético Mineiro fans created Galeitura — a portmanteau of "galo" (rooster, the club mascot) and "leitura" (reading) — which grew into a book club with over 130,000 social media followers that organises donations and school activities. Fans of rival clubs started their own versions. People reported to Galeitura that they'd never read a book before Scarpa's recommendations. Vladimir Tolstoy, the author's great-grandson and director-general of the Tolstoy State Museum in Moscow, recorded a video thanking Scarpa personally. In late October, Scarpa was invited to present at Brazil's leading literary awards, handing out the newly created Reading Promotion category. The implicit comparison with Neymar is the structural core of this story. Same pipeline — massive footballer audience, social media distribution, parasocial trust — radically different payload. Klein frames Scarpa as a potential "antidote" to the Neymar effect, and while that's generous given the difference in their reach, the mechanism is real: when Scarpa says "read this," people who have never voluntarily picked up a book are reading 19th-century Russian fiction and reporting back that it was easier than they expected. Scarpa's reading taste, incidentally, is not performative middlebrow. His favourite genre is what he calls "self-destruction" — "like Dostoevsky — something a bit difficult; not melancholic, but about internal conflicts." His favourite book is Les Misérables. When the Guardian visited, he was reading Art Spiegelman's The Complete Maus. He says he's persuaded five teammates to start reading, and his Argentine coach says the book recommendations are helping him learn Portuguese. The most striking line in the whole story comes from Scarpa himself: "I've been in football for more than 20 years, and I know how passionate fans can get, to the point of killing someone simply for supporting a different club. So to see rival fans coming together around reading, inspired by a movement that was itself inspired by me, is incredibly rewarding." In a country where football tribalism is literally lethal, a shared reading list turns out to be neutral ground.
Worth reading?
RECOMMENDED
Score
64
/100
Anyone interested in how celebrity influence actually works as a cultural mechanism — especially readers who care about literacy, Latin American culture, or the sociology of sports fandom. Also: football fans who read.
Cultural Placement
Like Oprah's Book Club but running through football ultras culture instead of daytime TV demographics, with the unfiltered casualness of early Goodreads reviews rather than curated literary authority. The closest structural precedent is probably the manga-recommendation culture among Japanese athletes — celebrity taste-making that works precisely because the recommender has zero literary credentials and therefore zero gatekeeping instinct. Think of it as the inverse of the Booker Prize longlist: authority derived from parasocial trust and authenticity rather than institutional credentialing.
Honest assessment
This is a genuinely charming story about an unusual cultural phenomenon, elevated by Scarpa's distinctive voice and the structural contrast with Neymar's influence model. It's not a revolution in literary culture — celebrity book clubs have a long history of brief, intense impact followed by fade — but the downstream effects (fan-created reading clubs across rival teams, first-time readers engaging with Russian classics) suggest something slightly more durable than the typical viral moment. The story is worth your time for the voice alone.
What Is NOVEL?
64
/ 100
BedrockNews applies a structured analytical framework called NOVEL to cultural works — games, books, film, music, and more.
How NOVEL worksNerve
3/5
Originality
3/5
Voice
4/5
Endurance
3/5
Lineage
3/5
What did the artist risk? What could have failed?
Moderate personal risk. Brazilian football culture actively discourages intellectualism; Scarpa read at the training ground while teammates teased him. Not career-ending risk, but genuine social cost in a hyper-masculine environment.
Verified Facts (10)
Scarpa was named best player in the Brazilian league in 2022 and won two Copa Libertadores titles in 2020 and 2021
The Death of Ivan Ilyich reached the top of Amazon Brazil's overall sales ranking
Scarpa had a six-month spell at Nottingham Forest in 2023 before joining Atlético Mineiro
More than half of Brazil's population had not read a single book in the previous three months
Galeitura has more than 130,000 followers on social media
Vladimir Tolstoy, the author's great-grandson and director-general of the Leo Tolstoy State Museum in Moscow, recorded a video thanking Scarpa
Julián Scatolaro owns a bookshop in Chajarí, 311 miles from Buenos Aires
Scarpa's favourite book is Victor Hugo's Les Misérables
In late October Scarpa was invited to present at Brazil's leading literary awards, presenting the newly created Reading Promotion category
Online betting operations were banned in Brazil in September 2026
More latest news
Read all